QCAA Legal Studies IA2 Inquiry Report: How to Get Top Marks (QCE)
QCAA Legal Studies IA2 is an individual inquiry report of up to 2000 words on a current legal issue from Unit 3 Topic 2, worth 25% of your QCE Legal Studies result and marked out of 25. You select an area of law that needs reform, analyse the issue with legislation and/or case law, then evaluate the legal situation and make a recommendation. Analysing and Evaluating carry 6 marks each, the most of the five criteria, so your viewpoints, legal alternatives and recommendation matter most.
This guide describes Legal Studies 2025 v1.3 (January 2026). It is one assessment in QCAA Legal Studies (QCE), and the QCE Legal Studies study guide has all four assessments. The marking rules below are current. The commentary is older: the 2023, 2024 and 2025 subject reports describe cohorts marked on the 2019 marking guide, and no report yet describes a cohort marked on the 2025 criteria. Report quotes are labelled by year for that reason.
What is the QCAA Legal Studies IA2?
| Weighting | 25% |
| Marked out of | 25 |
| Where it sits | Unit 3 Topic 2, Law reform within a dynamic society |
| Length | Written, up to 2000 words. Only an upper limit is stated |
| Class time | Approximately 15 hours, recommended |
| Where you work | In class time and your own time |
| Individual or group | Individual |
The syllabus says "Students research a current legal issue by collecting, analysing and synthesising primary and secondary information, data and sources." The specification then asks you to:
- "select an area of law that requires reform, change, or a new legislative instrument"
- "select a relevant legal issue that refers to the Australian and/or Queensland jurisdiction"
- "analyse the legal issue, referring to legislation and/or case law"
- "evaluate the legal situation making a relevant recommendation that focuses on depth rather than breadth"
- "write an inquiry report"
The syllabus doesn't say what counts toward the 2000 words. Ask your teacher about headings, tables and the reference list.
How is Legal Studies IA2 marked?
The instrument-specific marking guide (ISMG) is printed in the syllabus. It has five criteria and 25 marks. Each criterion is a ladder of descriptors with a mark range, and the 2023 report describes marking as a "best-fit approach".
Comprehending, 5 marks. The 4-5 band asks for:
- "comprehensive description of the relevant features of the Australian and/or Queensland law reform issue being investigated"
- "perceptive explanation of relevant legal concepts, principles and/or processes"
- "precise use of legal terminology"
The 2-3 band has "effective" description and explanation with "satisfactory use of legal terminology". The 1 mark band is "identification of some relevant legal concepts, principles or processes".
Selecting, 4 marks. The 3-4 band asks for:
- "discerning choice of current and relevant legal information from primary and/or secondary sources"
- "perceptive use of legal information"
- "consistent and accurate documentation of legal information in the form of a reference list and citations"
The 2 mark band has "satisfactory" choice and use. The 1 mark band has "narrow choice" and "narrow documentation of sources".
Analysing, 6 marks. The 5-6 band asks for:
- "perceptive application of relevant legal concepts, principles and/or processes, to determine the nature and scope of the law reform issue"
- "interpretation of legal information to perceptively examine different relevant viewpoints and their consequences"
- "discerning use of evidence to support the analysis"
The 3-4 band asks you to "effectively examine" viewpoints with "satisfactory use of evidence". The 1-2 band is "superficial description of legal concepts, principles and/or processes" and "narrow use of evidence".
Evaluating, 6 marks. The 5-6 band asks for:
- "perceptive legal alternatives presented from the analysis leading to an informed recommendation"
- "synthesis of information to justify the recommendation through the discerning use of legal criteria"
- "discussion of considered implications of the recommendation"
The 3-4 band has effective alternatives, an effective recommendation, effective use of legal criteria and "discussion of relevant implication/s". The 1-2 band is "alternative/s presented and/or recommendation made" and "some justification of the recommendation".
Creating a response, 4 marks. The 3-4 band asks for:
- "concise expression and logical development of relevant ideas that enhance legal meaning"
- "features of a report genre are consistently demonstrated"
- "minimal errors in spelling, grammar and punctuation"
The 2 mark band has "adequate expression". The 1 mark band is "some elements of report formatting and/or inconsistent use of language conventions".
How do you choose a Legal Studies IA2 topic?
Topic, referencing method and deadlines are set by each school, so start with your task sheet. Then test your issue against these points.
It has to be current. The syllabus says "The issue must be current, e.g. domestic and family violence, elder abuse, consumer fraud, defamation, privacy, cybercrime and forensics."
It has to be an area of law, and it needs to require reform. The 2023 report says to "select a topic that relates to an area of law that may require reform, not a process for reform".
It can't have just been fixed. The 2023 report says "defamation, consent and coercive control have been reformed recently and therefore do not currently meet the task specifications." That sits awkwardly with the syllabus list above, which still names defamation, and the report is from an earlier cohort. Treat the list as examples and ask your teacher whether your issue still needs reform. The 2025 report says the same of domestic and family violence: "Due to recent reforms in this area, previously used issues might no longer be appropriate".
It has to be different from IA3. The syllabus says "The teacher must ensure individual students do not choose the same topical issue for assessment in IA2 (Unit 3) and IA3 (Unit 4)." The QCAA Legal Studies IA3 analytical essay guide covers that task.
What does a Legal Studies inquiry report need?
The ISMG marks each of these parts. The QCAA Legal Studies IA1 guide covers the same moves under exam conditions, with the stimulus supplying your evidence. In IA2 you find the evidence yourself.
Nature and scope
The 5-6 Analysing band asks you to "determine the nature and scope of the law reform issue". The 2024 report says this "was separate from the report's introduction, and depth was evident for both the nature and scope of the law reform issue". So don't let your introduction do this job.
Viewpoints and consequences
The three reports keep returning to one distinction. The 2023 report says "emphasis on the second descriptor should centre on the examination of viewpoints, rather than stakeholders." The 2025 report warns against "describing stakeholder perspectives", which is the same point.
The 2023 report says viewpoints are "different but not necessarily opposing, and are examined through the interpretation of legal information at the mid and upper performance levels". The 2025 report adds "showing how each perspective contributes to understanding the issue".
Legal alternatives
The syllabus glossary defines these as "legal options that are presented to address or respond to the viewpoints and associated consequences examined in the analysis of the legal issue. Examples include introducing new legislation, amending existing legislation".
The 2023 report wants "alignment between the viewpoints in the analysis, the legal alternatives presented and the recommendation/s made". The 2025 report describes alternatives "connected to a specific legislative instrument (e.g. an Act, Bill, or statutory provision) requiring reform".
The IA2 descriptors don't set a number of alternatives or viewpoints. The QCAA sample asks for two of each, and the reports speak of "both" alternatives, so read your task sheet closely.
Recommendation and legal criteria
Legal criteria are a closed list. The syllabus says they are "chosen from the following list":
- "just and/or equitable outcomes"
- "relevant elements of the rule of law", glossed as "that laws are clear, acceptable, not retrospective, that they apply to all and are able to be enforced"
- "balancing the protection of individual rights with the protection of society"
You have to use a criterion, and naming it isn't enough. The 2023 report says "this requires an explanation as to how the recommendation will improve or satisfy an element of the rule of law or lead to just and equitable outcomes." The 2025 report adds "this must be applied more than once across the response."
Implications
The glossary defines implications as "effects or consequences that may result from the recommendation. These do not need to be legal." The 2025 report says "Implications are to be discussed fluently (more than a brief sentence or list)."
Sources and referencing
The 2025 report separates two Selecting descriptors: "the first descriptor refers to the choice of legal information, while the second descriptor refers to the use and application of that information in the appropriate context". Finding a good source and using it well are marked separately.
Reference more than your quotes. The 2023 report says responses that did not acknowledge "sources of all information, not just quotes, correctly and consistently using a recognised referencing system, could only be matched to the third descriptor at the 1- or 2-mark levels". Those bands are from the 2019 guide.
Report format
Creating a response asks for "features of a report genre". The 2023 report says responses containing "recognised features of a report genre" could match the top band's second descriptor, but it doesn't list them, and neither does the syllabus material we hold. We can't tell you which headings are required, so take the format from your task sheet.
The QCAA sample task
QCAA publishes a sample instrument "to assist and support teachers in planning and developing assessment instruments for individual school settings". You won't sit it, but it shows one way the specification becomes a task. Its marking ladders match the syllabus, though it is labelled v1.2, one version behind.
- Issue: "In this report you are to investigate the legal issue of regulating AI in Australia."
- Conditions: the syllabus time and word limits, individual, with "Open access to resources".
- Task: "Create an inquiry report that analyses the nature and scope of the issue of regulating AI in Australia. Examine two viewpoints and their consequences. Present two legal alternatives from your analysis. Make a recommendation to reform this issue in Australia. Use legal criteria to justify your recommendation."
QCAA Legal Studies IA2 exemplars from the subject reports
These excerpts were written under the 2019 syllabus. Each one shows a single Analysing characteristic. The 2025 report warns that a characteristic "may not be the only time the characteristic/s occurred throughout a response", and we hold no full annotated report or Evaluating exemplar, so don't read either as a full-mark report.
How often did confirmation change Legal Studies IA2 marks?
Confirmation is QCAA checking your school's marks after the assessment (the QCAA internal assessments guide (QCE) explains it). The table shows the percentage of marks where confirmed marks agreed with the school's provisional marks, for the two criteria with the lowest agreement and the one with the highest.
| Criterion | 2023 | 2024 | 2025 |
|---|---|---|---|
| Evaluating | 82.77% | 86.93% | 92.55% |
| Analysing | 86.77% | 89.67% | 91.61% |
| Creating a response | 96% | 98.78% | 99.07% |
Evaluating was lowest in 2023 and 2024, and Analysing was lowest in 2025. Those two were the lowest pair every year. Evaluating marks came in "less than provisional" 15.69%, 12.77% and 7.14% of the time. These are 2019-syllabus cohorts. The figures show how hard a criterion is to judge, not how well students wrote.
Common mistakes in Legal Studies IA2
Describing stakeholders. The 2023, 2024 and 2025 reports all raise this. Listing who is affected doesn't examine a viewpoint. Take a perspective on the law, and show its consequences through legal information.
Offering alternatives that aren't legal. The 2023 report says they "must be related to the law (not social or educational alternatives)". The 2024 report says "Only when both alternatives are legal in nature, can they be matched to the first descriptor in any performance level." The 2025 report: "Alternatives that are educational, social or administrative cannot be matched to higher performance levels." Tie each option to the law you're proposing to change.
Offering no change as an alternative. The 2025 report says "Legal alternatives that present no legal change (e.g. keep things the same) will not meet the upper-performance level descriptor for this criterion. This would match the lower performance level descriptor in the 1-2 mark range."
Merging nature and scope into the introduction. The 2024 report wants the nature and scope kept separate from the introduction, with depth on both.
Listing implications. A short list fails the 2025 report's test of "more than a brief sentence or list". Discuss the effects of your recommendation.
Choosing a process or a settled law. The 2023 report rules out a "process for reform" and issues that were reformed recently. Check that your area of law still needs reform.
Weak versus strong wording
These rows are our summaries of the sources listed, not student sentences. Report rows come from commentary on 2019-syllabus cohorts, apart from the 2025 report's advice on the 2025 ISMG: no-change alternatives, applying legal criteria more than once, and discussing implications fluently.
| Element | Weaker | Stronger | Source |
|---|---|---|---|
| Viewpoints | Describes who is affected | Examines a perspective on the law and its consequence, from sources | 2023 to 2025 reports; 2025 ISMG |
| Alternatives | An educational or social measure, or keeping the law as it is | Legal options tied to an Act or provision | 2023 to 2025 reports; syllabus glossary |
| Legal criteria | Names "the rule of law" once | Explains how the recommendation satisfies an element of it, more than once | 2023 and 2025 reports |
| Implications | A one-line list | Fluent discussion of effects, which need not be legal | 2025 report; syllabus glossary |
| Topic | A reform process, or a law just reformed | A current area of law still needing reform | 2023 report; syllabus |
Before you submit
- Is your report within 2000 words, counted the way your school counts them?
- Is your issue current, in the Australian and/or Queensland jurisdiction, and different from your IA3 issue?
- Does your analysis refer to legislation and/or case law?
- Is nature and scope treated in its own right, beyond the introduction?
- Are you examining viewpoints and their consequences, or describing stakeholders?
- Is every alternative legal, and does each one follow from your viewpoints?
- Does your recommendation align with those viewpoints and alternatives?
- Have you explained how the recommendation meets a legal criterion from the syllabus list, more than once?
- Have you discussed implications, not listed them?
- Does every source of information appear in your citations and reference list, not just your quotes?
- Have you checked the report features your task sheet asks for?
Practise and get it marked
Practise this IA on AusGrader: sit a prewritten practice IA where your subject has one, or build your own from real QCAA questions, and get it graded against the marking guide with feedback. You can also upload your IA draft for feedback against the ISMG.
Frequently asked questions
How long is the QCE Legal Studies IA2?
Written, up to 2000 words, with approximately 15 hours of class time recommended. The syllabus states an upper limit only, and it does not say what counts toward the limit, so check headings, tables and references with your school.
Do I need exactly two viewpoints and two legal alternatives in Legal Studies IA2?
The IA2 descriptors give no number. They say "different relevant viewpoints" and "legal alternatives". The QCAA sample task asks for two of each, and the 2023 and 2024 reports talk about both alternatives, so follow your task sheet.
Can defamation be my Legal Studies IA2 topic?
Check with your teacher first. The syllabus lists defamation as an example of a current issue, but the 2023 report says defamation, consent and coercive control had been reformed recently and did not then meet the task specifications.
Can keeping the law as it is count as a legal alternative in IA2?
It won't reach the top. The 2025 report says alternatives that present no legal change will not meet the upper-performance level descriptor, and that this would match the descriptor in the 1-2 mark range.
Do I have to reference everything in Legal Studies IA2, or just quotes?
Everything. The top Selecting band asks for consistent and accurate documentation in a reference list and citations, and the 2023 report says responses needed to acknowledge sources of all information, not just quotes. Your school sets the referencing method.
Sources
- Legal Studies 2025 v1.3 General senior syllabus, QCAA, January 2026, pp. 7-8, 23, 32-36. The IA2 specification, conditions and instrument-specific marking guide, plus the glossary terms and legal criteria.
- Legal Studies 2025 v1.2 IA2: Sample assessment instrument, QCAA, pp. 1-3, 5-7. A sample for teachers, one version behind the syllabus. The source of the sample task described in this guide.
- Legal Studies subject report, 2025 cohort, QCAA, January 2026, pp. 16-19. Commentary on the 2019 version of IA2, advice on the 2025 syllabus, and the excerpt described in this guide.
- Legal Studies subject report, 2024 cohort, QCAA, January 2025, pp. 16-17, 19. Commentary on the 2019 version of IA2 and the excerpts described in this guide.
- Legal Studies subject report, 2023 cohort, QCAA, January 2024, pp. 19-20, 24. Commentary on the 2019 version of IA2.
Syllabus and assessment material referenced in this guide is © State of Queensland (Queensland Curriculum and Assessment Authority), licensed under CC BY 4.0. See our QCAA licensing notice. AusGrader is an independent study tool and is not affiliated with, endorsed by, or operated by the QCAA.
Keep reading
QCAA Legal Studies IA1 Examination: How to Get Top Marks (QCE)
How QCAA Legal Studies IA1 is marked out of 25, what the extended response needs, and what QCAA reports say about legal alternatives and criteria (QCE).
QCAA Legal Studies IA3 Analytical Essay: How to Get Top Marks (QCE)
How QCAA Legal Studies IA3 is marked out of 25, what the analytical essay must include, and what QCAA reports say about topics and alternatives (QCE).
Practise what you just read
Work through real QCAA Legal Studies questions and get your written answers marked against the official criteria, instantly.