QCE Legal Studies

QCAA Legal Studies IA1 Examination: How to Get Top Marks (QCE)

QCAA Legal Studies IA1 is a supervised examination on Unit 3 Topic 1, Governance in Australia, worth 25% of your QCE Legal Studies result and marked out of 25. You get 15 minutes of planning and 120 minutes of working time for 6 to 8 short response questions (10 marks) and one extended response to unseen stimulus (15 marks). Top marks in the extended response depend on analysing a legal issue, presenting legal alternatives, and justifying a recommendation with legal criteria.

This guide describes Legal Studies 2025 v1.3 (January 2026). It is one assessment in QCAA Legal Studies (QCE), and the QCE Legal Studies study guide has all four assessments. The marking rules below are current. The commentary is older: the 2023, 2024 and 2025 subject reports all describe the 2019 version of IA1, and no report yet describes a cohort marked on the 2025 criteria. Every report quote and figure is labelled by year for that reason. Your school writes its own IA1, and we hold no sample instrument for it.

Weighting25%
Marked out of25
Where it sitsUnit 3 Topic 1, Governance in Australia
Individual or groupIndividual, supervised
Planning time15 minutes
Working time120 minutes
Short response6 to 8 questions, 10 marks
Extended response1 question, 15 marks
Word lengthNone. The 2025 report says it must not appear on IA1 instruments

The short response questions are answered "in sentences and paragraphs". The syllabus says they ask you to "explain, describe, and/or create, label and annotate diagrams and/or graphs", so expect more than written answers. The extended response asks you to "respond to unseen stimulus; make a recommendation".

The stimulus has limits set by the syllabus:

  • It "fits on one A3 page or equivalent".
  • It has "a minimum of four different stimulus items from a variety of texts, e.g. political cartoons; excerpts from law journal articles; excerpts from newspaper reports; excerpts from legislation".
  • It has "up to 250 words in any one stimulus".

The exam must also "enable multiple possible extended responses from the provided stimulus", so more than one answer can work.

The instrument-specific marking guide (ISMG) is printed in the syllabus. It has three criteria and 25 marks. The short responses assess objective 1, which lines up with Comprehending. The extended response assesses objectives 3 and 4, which line up with Analysing and Evaluating. There is no Selecting or Creating criterion in this task.

Comprehending, 10 marks. The 9-10 band asks for:

  • "accurate and detailed description of the essential features of Australian and Queensland governance"
  • "thorough explanation of legal concepts, principles and processes of Australian and Queensland governance"
  • "precise use of legal terminology"

The three characteristics step down like this:

MarksDescriptionExplanationTerminology
9-10accurate and detailedthoroughprecise
7-8effectiveeffectiveeffective
5-6adequateadequatesatisfactory
3-4partial identificationpartial descriptionnarrow
1-2identification of aspectsidentification of aspectsinconsistent

Analysing, 8 marks. The 7-8 band asks for:

  • "perceptive application of legal concepts, principles and/or processes to determine the nature and scope of a legal issue involving Australian and/or Queensland governance"
  • "interpretation of legal information to perceptively examine different relevant viewpoints and their consequences related to the legal issue"
  • "discerning use of evidence from the stimulus to support the analysis"

The 5-6 band keeps those requirements at "effective". At 3-4 it becomes "adequate application of some legal concepts", "adequately examine different viewpoints" and "sufficient use of evidence in the analysis". At 1-2 it is "description of aspects of the nature and/or scope of the issue", "identification of superficial viewpoint/s" and "minimal use of evidence."

Evaluating, 7 marks. The 6-7 band asks for:

  • "insightful legal alternatives presented from the analysis leading to an informed recommendation"
  • "justification of the recommendation through the discerning use of legal criteria"
  • "discussion of considered implications of the recommendation"

The 4-5 band asks for effective alternatives and an effective recommendation, "effective use of legal criteria" and "discussion of relevant implications". The 2-3 band is "alternative/s presented and/or recommendation", "some justification of the recommendation" and "identification of implication/s of the alternative/s or recommendation". The 1 mark band is "alternative/s and/or a recommendation OR narrow discussion of the legal situation based on personal opinions."

In all three criteria, 0 means "The student response does not match any of the descriptors above."

The syllabus topic gives the sequence, and the ISMG marks each part. Analyse the issue by "determining the nature and scope of the legal issue" and "examining different relevant viewpoints and their consequences". Then evaluate by "presenting legal alternatives to make a recommendation/s", justifying with legal criteria and discussing implications.

Nature and scope

The syllabus's key terminology defines this as "the characteristics or elements of the legal issue, e.g. its origins and development, how it affects those involved ..., what law relates to the issue and the extent of the issue and its impact".

The reports all ask for more than a statement of the issue. The 2024 report put responses in the top bands when they "extended beyond a general statement and/or definition of the legal issue, and applied information by providing depth and detail". The 2025 report says "Perceptive responses applied information from the stimulus".

Viewpoints and consequences

The 2023 report says viewpoints "need to be different, but do not need to be associated with any particular group of people. Instead, the evidence used in the analysis should support the validity of the viewpoint". The 2024 report advises against "stakeholders", because the descriptors say "examine different viewpoints and their consequences".

The 2023 report also says viewpoints and alternatives are "drawn from the stimulus, not from students' own knowledge". The 2025 report adds that students are assessed on analysing and evaluating, "not their ability to determine a legal issue from the stimulus".

The key terminology defines these as "legal options". Its examples are "introducing new legislation, amending existing legislation, changing the legal process ..., establishing a new regulatory authority". The 2024 report adds "the creation of new courts".

Each one has to come from your analysis. The 2023 report ties "presenting two legal alternatives" to a top match. The 2025 report says "two legal alternatives are presented. The legal alternatives must stem directly from the analysis and be linked to the viewpoints".

The syllabus says legal criteria "are chosen from the following list":

  • "just and/or equitable outcomes"
  • relevant elements of the rule of law, "for example, that laws are clear, acceptable, not retrospective, that they apply to all and are able to be enforced"
  • "balancing the protection of individual rights with the protection of society"

Naming one is not the same as using it. The 2023 report wanted specified rule-of-law elements, "e.g. the law applies equally to all", and "an explanation linking the criteria and the decision".

Implications

The key terminology defines implications as "effects or consequences that may result from the recommendation. These do not need to be legal." Your alternatives have to be legal. Your implications don't.

As a set. The 2025 report says Comprehending is "considered collectively ..., rather than judging each response in isolation", with top marks for "both breadth and depth" and "precise use of legal terminology". In one 2023 example, two incorrect answers and four incomplete ones were "appropriately matched to the 'adequate' or 'partial' descriptors".

Revise both levels of government. The top band names "Australian and Queensland governance". The 2023 report says the short responses should cover "both Queensland and Australian governance", and the 2025 report makes the same point about covering both levels.

These excerpts are handwritten responses reprinted in the reports. All were written under the 2019 syllabus, and the reports use the word "decision".

Confirmation is QCAA checking your school's marks after the assessment (the QCAA internal assessments guide (QCE) explains it). The table shows the percentage of marks that agreed with the school's provisional marks. The figure in brackets is the percentage "less than provisional".

Criterion202320242025
Comprehending88.04% (7.06%)93.92% (5.47%)95.67% (3.72%)
Analysing82.21% (15.34%)92.10% (7.60%)93.81% (5.88%)
Evaluating73.31% (24.54%)84.19% (15.50%)85.76% (13.93%)

These are 2019-syllabus cohorts, and the criterion wording has since changed. The figures measure agreement with school marking, not how well students wrote. Evaluating had the lowest agreement in all three years.

Offering an alternative that isn't legal. The 2025 report says "education programs, awareness campaigns, social media initiatives and increased funding are not legal in nature and therefore would not match to the upper performance-level descriptors". The 2024 report adds policy changes and cultural initiatives. Propose a change to the law or a legal process.

Presenting alternatives that don't connect to your analysis. The 2023 report says they must align with "the viewpoints and their consequences examined in the analysis". Plan the alternatives from your viewpoints, not as a separate list.

Naming a criterion without using it. In the 2023 report, justification "where legal criteria were simply stated" matched 2-3 marks (a 2019 band). The 2025 report: "Simply stating that the recommendation will lead to fairness or equity will only align with the lower performance levels". Say which element applies and how your recommendation meets it.

Stopping at the issue. In the 2023 report, a response that "merely stated the legal issue and/or what it relates to, and identified a group of people affected by it" matched 1-2 marks (a 2019 band). Go on to apply stimulus evidence to the issue.

Writing a decision. The 2019 reports and excerpts use the word, but the 2025 ISMG marks a recommendation. The 2025 report also moves the top Evaluating band to "discussion of considered implications of the recommendation".

Weak versus strong wording

Every quoted phrase is QCAA's own, and none is a student sentence. ISMG rows are current. Report rows describe the 2019 version of the task.

ElementWeakerStrongerSource
Alternatives"alternative/s presented and/or recommendation""insightful legal alternatives presented from the analysis"ISMG, p. 31
Alternativesawareness campaigns or increased fundinglegal alternatives that "stem directly from the analysis and be linked to the viewpoints"2025 report, p. 12
Justification"legal criteria were simply stated""an explanation linking the criteria and the decision"2023 report, pp. 13, 17
Analysis"merely stated the legal issue""applied information by providing depth and detail"2023 report, p. 13 (weaker); 2024 report, p. 11 (stronger)
Evidence"minimal use of evidence.""discerning use of evidence from the stimulus to support the analysis"ISMG, p. 31
Short responses"narrow" terminology"precise use of legal terminology"ISMG, p. 30

Practise and get it marked

Practise this IA on AusGrader: sit a prewritten practice IA where your subject has one, or build your own from real QCAA questions, and get it graded against the marking guide with feedback. You can also upload your IA draft for feedback against the ISMG.

Frequently asked questions

How long is the QCE Legal Studies IA1 exam?

The syllabus gives 15 minutes of planning time and 120 minutes of working time. In that time you answer 6 to 8 short response questions worth 10 marks and one extended response worth 15 marks.

Is there a word limit on the Legal Studies IA1 extended response?

No. The 2025 report says the syllabus conditions no longer include word length for examinations, and that a required or recommended word length must not appear on IA1 instruments. The 400 to 500 words quoted in the 2024 report is from the 2019 syllabus.

Does an awareness campaign count as a legal alternative in Legal Studies IA1?

No. The 2025 report says education programs, awareness campaigns, social media initiatives and increased funding are not legal in nature and would not match the upper performance-level descriptors. The syllabus's key terminology (p. 7) gives examples including new legislation, amending legislation, changing the legal process and establishing a new regulatory authority.

Do I make a decision or a recommendation in Legal Studies IA1?

A recommendation. The 2025 report says the extended response question must now direct students to make a recommendation, not a decision. Reports and excerpts from the 2019 syllabus still say decision.

Do my viewpoints in Legal Studies IA1 have to belong to stakeholders?

No. The 2023 report says viewpoints need to be different but do not need to be associated with any particular group of people, and that the evidence should support the validity of the viewpoint. The 2024 report advises against the word stakeholders.

Sources

  • Legal Studies 2025 v1.3 General senior syllabus, QCAA, January 2026, pp. 7, 21-22, 28-31. The IA1 specification, conditions and instrument-specific marking guide, plus the key terminology and legal criteria.
  • Legal Studies subject report, 2025 cohort, QCAA, January 2026, pp. 9-13. Commentary on the 2019 version of IA1, the board's statement of what changes under the 2025 syllabus, and excerpts quoted in this guide.
  • Legal Studies subject report, 2024 cohort, QCAA, January 2025, pp. 9-12. Commentary on the 2019 version of IA1, the question stem and excerpts quoted in this guide.
  • Legal Studies subject report, 2023 cohort, QCAA, January 2024, pp. 11-13, 17. Commentary on the 2019 version of IA1.

Syllabus and assessment material referenced in this guide is © State of Queensland (Queensland Curriculum and Assessment Authority), licensed under CC BY 4.0. See our QCAA licensing notice. AusGrader is an independent study tool and is not affiliated with, endorsed by, or operated by the QCAA.

Keep reading

Practise what you just read

Work through real QCAA Legal Studies questions and get your written answers marked against the official criteria, instantly.