QCE Legal Studies

QCAA Legal Studies External Exam: Format, Marks and Timing (QCE)

The QCAA Legal Studies external exam is worth 25% of your QCE Legal Studies result. Every school sits it at the same time, and you get 15 minutes of planning and 120 minutes of working time on Unit 4 Topic 1 (Human rights) and Topic 3 (Human rights in Australian contexts). Every paper from 2021 to 2025 had a short-response section and then one extended response to unseen stimulus, and the 2024 and 2025 papers were each out of 44 marks.

This guide describes Legal Studies 2025 v1.3 (January 2026). The 2026 sitting is the first external exam on that syllabus and the 2027 cohort sits the second. We hold no 2026 paper or marking guide, so every paper, marking guide and subject report below is from a 2019-syllabus sitting and is labelled by year. For the whole subject, start at the QCE Legal Studies study guide, and for the papers themselves go to QCAA Legal Studies past papers (QCE).

It's one of your four assessments, each worth 25%. The syllabus says it is "common to all schools and administered under the same conditions, at the same time, on the same day". The study guide has the full weighting table, and the date is on the QCAA external exam timetable.

Weighting25%
TopicsUnit 4 Topic 1, Human rights; Unit 4 Topic 3, Human rights in Australian contexts
Objectives1 (comprehend), 3 (analyse), 4 (evaluate)
ModeWritten
Planning time15 minutes
Working time120 minutes

Unit 4 Topic 2 isn't on the exam. It belongs to the IA3 analytical essay, which draws on Topics 1 and 2.

The syllabus says the exam "may ask students to respond by creating, labelling and/or annotating diagrams; writing in sentences or paragraphs; answering short response questions; creating an extended response to unseen stimulus". None of the 2021 to 2025 papers asked for a diagram, and none had multiple choice.

The shape held from 2021 to 2025. The marks did not.

SittingSection 1, short responseSection 2, extended responseTotal
20255 questions, 19 marksQ6, 25 marks44
20244 questions, 17 marksQ5, 27 marks44
20234 questions, 20 marksQ5, 27 marks47
20224 questions, 20 marksQ5, 27 marks47
20214 questions, 21 marksQ5, 27 marks48

The 2023, 2024 and 2025 covers told you to "Respond in paragraphs consisting of full sentences". Our own arithmetic, not a QCAA figure: Section 1 was 43% of the 2025 paper and 39% of the 2024 paper, and 120 minutes for 44 marks is about 2.7 minutes a mark, which puts the 25-mark extended response near 68 minutes.

If you read the 2025 subject report, its description of the paper's design repeats the 2023 report's and doesn't match the 2025 paper. Go by the 2025 question book and marking guide: five short-response questions and 44 marks.

Not in the 2025 syllabus. The 2019 syllabus set "50-250 words per item" for short responses, "400-600 words" for the extended response and "800-1000 words" for the whole exam. The 2025 version states no word length.

The papers kept printing one anyway. "Respond in 400-600 words" appears on the extended response in 2023, 2024 and 2025, all 2019-syllabus papers. Whether a 2026 or 2027 paper prints it is unknown, so take your length from the paper you sit.

What changed for the exam under the 2025 syllabus?

Time and topics are unchanged: 2 hours plus 15 minutes of planning, on Topics 1 and 3, in both versions. The rest of the specification moved, and no paper on the new syllabus is held here to show how much of that reaches the exam itself.

What2019 syllabus2025 syllabus
Word lengthSet for each short response, the extended response and the whole examNone stated
Objective weightingComprehending 40%, Analysing 30%, Evaluating 30%, described as approximateNo weighting given
The extended responseDescribed as requiring "a decision to be made""an extended response to unseen stimulus"
Evaluating in Topic 3"alternatives to make a decision or propose recommendations""legal alternatives to make a recommendation/s"
Analysing in Topic 3"viewpoints and consequences""different relevant viewpoints and their consequences"
Treaties in Topic 1Refugees, ICERD, CEDAW, CRCAdds the CRPD and the Convention against Torture
Key Acts in Topic 1RDA, SDA, DDAAdds the Age Discrimination Act 2004

Two of these already have a track record. The 2024 extended response was on age discrimination in employment and the Age Discrimination Act, even though the 2019 syllabus didn't list the Act. The 2025 paper and its marking guide still said "decision", so the recommendation wording has not yet been tested on a paper we hold. The two added treaties haven't appeared on any paper here. For the full topic list, see the QCAA Legal Studies syllabus (QCE).

What do the short-response questions ask?

Each of these patterns appeared on the 2021 to 2025 papers, and the 2025 syllabus still lists the subject matter behind each one.

PatternWhere it appeared
Describe, identify or explain two things2022 Q1 (rights under the SDA); 2025 Q1 (DDA), Q2 (media), Q3 (ICERD), Q5 (common-law rights)
An international instrument or principle2021 Q1 (non-refoulement), Q3 (UN Charter Article 2(4)); 2023 Q1 (CRC), Q2 (UNHCR); 2024 Q1 (ICCPR Article 1), Q3 (sovereignty); 2025 Q3 (ICERD)
A process2022 Q4 (Human Rights (Parliamentary Scrutiny) Act); 2024 Q4 (a Federal Court claim); 2025 Q4 (treaty ratification)
The role of a rights group2021 Q2 (special interest group), Q4 (AHRC); 2022 Q3 (QCCL); 2023 Q4 (AHRC powers); 2025 Q2 (media)
The Constitution and rights2024 Q2 (express and implied rights)
A restriction on a right, with an example2023 Q3 (right to protest)

These are 2019-syllabus papers. A repeat shows what QCAA has asked, not what the next paper will ask. Topic-level figures across the papers are in the most-tested section.

How are the short responses marked?

Against the External Assessment Marking Guide, a separate document QCAA publishes for each paper the year after it is sat. It isn't an instrument-specific marking guide (ISMG). Where a response meets none of the descriptors, "a mark of '0' will be recorded."

Three items from the guides show how the marks split.

ItemMarksHow the marks were awarded
2025 Q1, "Describe two human rights promoted by the Disability Discrimination Act 1992 (Cth)."41 each: identifies a right, describes it, identifies a second right, describes the second
2025 Q4, "Outline the steps in the process of ratification of a treaty in Australia."3Graded: five to six steps described "using key terms, with accuracy" = 3; three to four steps, "with steps omitted" = 2; one to two steps = 1
2024 Q4, a Federal Court claim54a, 2 marks: a complaint made to the AHRC, and the complaint terminated. 4b, 3 marks: what, where and who; unlawful under a federal anti-discrimination statute; damage, loss or harm

In 2025 Q1, naming the two rights earned 2 of the 4 marks, and describing them earned the other 2. Q4 is the only item marked in levels across the marking guides used here, so don't assume every process question is marked that way.

What does the extended response ask?

The stem kept one shape from 2022 to 2025. Using the numbered stimulus, examine two different viewpoints to analyse an issue, then present two legal alternatives from your analysis and justify a decision about it.

SittingIssueStimulus items
2025 Q6Criminalising civil disobedience and the right to protest in Queensland10
2024 Q5Age discrimination in employment and the Age Discrimination Act9
2023 Q5Public nuisance offences and access to justice for people experiencing homelessness11
2022 Q5Freedom of speech9
2021 Q5Prisoners' vote9

Every issue sits inside the Topic 3 rights subject matter, which the 2025 syllabus keeps. The stimulus is a mix of sources. The 2025 book combined an ICCPR article, Queensland statutes, two journal articles, and Human Rights Law Centre and news items. The stimulus is unseen, so practise reading a set of nine to eleven sources against the clock.

In two parts, Analysing and Evaluating, with marks for each element. This is the 2025 split:

CriterionElementMarks
Analysing (14)Nature and scope3
Viewpoint 14
Viewpoint 24
Use of evidence3
Evaluating (11)Legal alternative 13
Legal alternative 23
Decision and justification3
Implications2

The 2023 and 2024 extended responses were 27 marks, split Analysing 15 and Evaluating 12. In both years Use of evidence was worth 4 and Implications 3. Each lost a mark in 2025, and with it a top level: "discerning use of a range of relevant information" for evidence and "effectively discusses" for implications. The 2022 extended response was also 27 marks.

Two details in the guides matter for how you write:

  • Consequences are credited even when the question leaves them out. The 2023 and 2025 stems omit "and their consequences" and the 2024 stem includes it, yet all three marking guides credit consequences.
  • The second viewpoint has to be different. It reads "a different valid viewpoint" in 2023 and 2024 and "a second valid viewpoint" in 2025.

How to build each element (nature and scope, viewpoints, legal alternatives, legal criteria and implications) is covered in the Legal Studies IA1 guide, which walks through the same elements.

These points come from the external assessment pages of the 2022, 2023, 2024 and 2025 subject reports, all on 2019-syllabus cohorts. Each one appears in at least two reports, except where marked.

  • Answer every element of a short-response item. If the question says describe and use an example, do both. Raised in the 2022, 2023 and 2024 reports. The 2025 marking guide still gave a mark per element.
  • Treat identify, describe and explain as different tasks. The 2023 and 2025 reports both raise it. In the 2025 guide, identifying and describing earned separate marks.
  • Use stimulus evidence that matches the viewpoint, and paraphrase it. Don't copy long blocks of source text. Raised in 2022 and 2023.
  • Answer the issue as stated, not the broader topic. Raised in 2022, 2023 and 2024.
  • Make consequences outcomes. A consequence that restates the viewpoint doesn't do the job. Raised in 2022 and 2023.
  • Keep alternatives legal, different from each other and drawn from your analysis. Raised in 2022, 2023 and 2025.
  • Use legal criteria inside the justification. Naming a criterion isn't using it. Raised in 2022, 2024 and 2025.
  • Discuss the implications of your decision. Raised in 2022, 2023 and 2025.
  • Link examples back to the answer. Raised in 2023 and 2024, and it applies where an item asks for an example. No 2025 short-response item did.

Three points appeared in one report only, so treat them as single-year advice. The 2024 report asked for viewpoints on the issue, not a stakeholder's view, and for viewpoints that are different, not opposing. It also asked for consistent legal terminology. The 2022 report suggested planning the extended response with a mnemonic or graphic organiser.

Sit a past paper under the real times: 15 minutes planning, 120 minutes working. Then mark it against that year's External Assessment Marking Guide and write down which element each lost mark came from. A missing consequence and an alternative that isn't legal need different fixes. The questions are on the QCAA Legal Studies past papers (QCE) page, the QCAA cognitive verbs guide (QCE) covers identify, describe and explain, and how to prepare for QCAA external exams covers planning across subjects.

When you use a 2021 to 2025 paper, adjust for the 2025 syllabus. Revise the CRPD, the Convention against Torture and the Age Discrimination Act alongside the older treaties and Acts, and be ready for an evaluating task framed as a recommendation.

Frequently asked questions

How many marks is the QCAA Legal Studies external exam out of?

It has varied. The 2021 paper was out of 48, the 2022 and 2023 papers 47, and the 2024 and 2025 papers 44. All five were set under the 2019 syllabus, and no paper on the 2025 syllabus is held here, so treat each total as the figure for that year.

Is there multiple choice in the QCE Legal Studies external exam?

No. The 2021 to 2025 papers had a short-response section followed by one extended response to unseen stimulus. The 2025 syllabus says the exam may also ask you to create, label or annotate diagrams, but none of those papers did.

Is there a word limit on the Legal Studies external exam?

The 2025 syllabus states none. The 2019 syllabus set 50 to 250 words per short response and 400 to 600 for the extended response, and the 2023, 2024 and 2025 papers still printed 'Respond in 400-600 words' on the extended response. Follow whatever the paper in front of you says.

Do you make a decision or a recommendation in the Legal Studies external exam?

Every extended response from 2022 to 2025 asked you to justify a decision, and the 2025 marking guide still marked 'Decision and justification'. The 2025 syllabus's Topic 3 subject matter says to present legal alternatives 'to make a recommendation/s'. Answer in the terms the question uses.

Which topics are in the QCAA Legal Studies external exam?

Unit 4 Topic 1, Human rights, and Unit 4 Topic 3, Human rights in Australian contexts. Topic 2 is not examined in the external exam. That was also true under the 2019 syllabus.

Sources

  • Legal Studies 2025 v1.3 General senior syllabus, QCAA, January 2026, pp. 25, 27, 42. External assessment specification (weighting, objectives, topics, what questions may ask, conditions) and the Unit 4 Topic 1 and Topic 3 subject matter.
  • Legal Studies 2019 v1.1 General Senior Syllabus, QCAA, pp. 42-44, 50-51. Superseded. The 2019 external assessment specification, word lengths and objective weighting, used to show what changed.
  • Legal Studies subject report, 2025 cohort, QCAA, January 2026, pp. 26-27. External assessment commentary on a 2019-syllabus cohort.
  • Legal Studies subject report, 2024 cohort, QCAA, January 2025, pp. 25-26. External assessment commentary on a 2019-syllabus cohort.
  • Legal Studies subject report, 2023 cohort, QCAA, January 2024, pp. 32-39. External assessment commentary on a 2019-syllabus cohort.
  • Legal Studies subject report, 2022 cohort, QCAA, pp. 30-34. External assessment commentary on a 2019-syllabus cohort.
  • External assessment papers and marking guides, 2020 to 2025, QCAA. The Legal Studies 2021 to 2025 question books, the 2023, 2024 and 2025 External Assessment Marking Guides and the 2025 stimulus book: cover instructions, mark totals, question stems and mark allocations.

Syllabus and assessment material referenced in this guide is © State of Queensland (Queensland Curriculum and Assessment Authority), licensed under CC BY 4.0. See our QCAA licensing notice. AusGrader is an independent study tool and is not affiliated with, endorsed by, or operated by the QCAA.

Keep reading

Practise what you just read

Work through real QCAA Legal Studies questions and get your written answers marked against the official criteria, instantly.