QCE Ancient History

QCAA Ancient History IA2 and IA3 Investigations: How to Get Top Marks (QCE)

QCAA Ancient History has two investigations, each worth 25% and marked out of 25. IA2 is an independent source investigation on a Unit 3 topic: you devise a key inquiry question and 3 to 5 sub-questions, interrogate 4 to 6 sources and write a critical summary. IA3 is a historical essay based on your own research into a Unit 4 topic, up to 2000 words, with your key inquiry question at the beginning.

This guide describes Ancient History 2025 v1.4 (March 2026), the current syllabus. IA2 and IA3 are two of four assessments in QCAA Ancient History (QCE), and the QCE Ancient History study guide sets all four side by side. The syllabus prints no first-examined year; we read 2026 as the first Year 12 cohort under it. The commentary quoted here is older. The 2022 to 2025 subject reports describe 2019-syllabus cohorts, marked on different criteria and marks, so report quotes are labelled by year and no report yet marks a response against the 2025 marking guides.

What are the QCAA Ancient History IA2 and IA3?

IA2IA3
Weighting25%25%
Marked out of2525
TechniqueIndependent source investigationHistorical essay based on research
TopicA Unit 3 topic "not previously assessed in IA1"One Unit 4 topic "that is not the focus of the selected external assessment topic"
QuestionsA key inquiry question and 3 to 5 sub-questionsA key inquiry question "included at the beginning of the response"
Sources4 to 6, "including ancient and modern, that have not been studied or supplied in class"Sources "that they have located when researching"
Length"up to 2000 words"Up to 2000 words "including the key inquiry question and direct quotes"
Class timeAbout 15 hours, recommendedAbout 15 hours, recommended
Where you workClass time and your own timeClass time and your own time
Individual or groupIndividualIndividual

The syllabus describes IA2 as "an independent source investigation that requires them to devise and apply historical questions; interrogate evidence from historical sources; and develop a critical summary that presents a historical argument."

It describes IA3 as "a historical essay based on research that requires them to create a historical argument that responds to their key inquiry question using evidence from sources that they have located when researching."

The two are easy to blur because both start from a key inquiry question. The reports from 2022 to 2025 keep telling schools not to mix the two specifications. The 2022 report: "Sub-questions are not required in the IA3".

How do you write a key inquiry question?

The top of Devising and Conducting in both ISMGs asks for a "nuanced key inquiry question". In IA2 it also asks for "relevant sub-questions" and a "discerning selection of relevant evidence from ancient and modern historical sources". At the bottom (1 mark in IA2) the response only "includes a key inquiry question and/or sub-questions".

Narrow it. The 2025 report says a nuanced question narrows the focus "by specifying, e.g. the issue, event, time, individual, group, location, society". The reports make this point for IA2 in 2022 to 2025 and for IA3 in 2022 and 2025.

Use it throughout. The question and sub-questions should be "applied across the response, such as in the source analysis and/or critical summary". The reports say this for IA2 in 2022 to 2025 and for IA3 in 2022 and 2023.

Expect room to choose. The reports ask schools to word the task so you can develop your own question, for both IA2 and IA3.

What goes in the IA2 independent source investigation?

The syllabus lists the features:

  • a key inquiry question and 3 to 5 sub-questions
  • evidence selected from 4 to 6 historical sources, "including ancient and modern, that have not been studied or supplied in class"
  • an interrogation of those sources
  • a critical summary with "a historical argument in response to the key inquiry question"
  • "a reference list"

The suggested split is 150 words for the question and sub-questions, 1200 for the interrogation and 650 for the critical summary. The interrogation "may be in the form of bullet points, but the critical summary must be in the form of paragraph/s".

Stick to your 4 to 6 sources. The 2023 to 2025 reports say other sources may only give context. The 2024 report says they "must not be used to develop the key inquiry question or corroborate".

Include the excerpt. The 2022 to 2025 reports say to include the source excerpt you interrogate, and that it does not count: it "does not contribute to the word limit" (2022, 2023) and "is not included in the response length" (2024, 2025). Quotes in your own writing count "unless cited for authentication purposes". The 2023 and 2024 reports say headings and scaffold text count too. The 2019 IA2 ran 1500 to 2000 words with a different split, so older word advice uses different numbers.

Ancient and modern. The 2022 to 2024 reports talk about primary and secondary sources, and tie them to the upper levels of several criteria. That was the 2019 wording. The 2025 syllabus says "ancient and modern", and in the 2025 ISMG only Devising and Conducting names the pair.

The critical summary is marked for Synthesising. The 2025 report says Synthesising "is now assessed" in IA2, from a critical summary that combines evidence from your 4 to 6 sources only. The 2019 IA2 had no Synthesising criterion, so no report yet describes how it was applied.

What goes in the IA3 historical essay?

The syllabus lists the features of a historical essay based on research:

  • "a key inquiry question which is included at the beginning of the response"
  • an introduction with a hypothesis
  • topic sentences
  • a conclusion
  • "a reference list"

Put the question first. The 2025 report says the key inquiry question "must be included at the beginning", and that this is assessed in Communicating. The 2022 and 2024 reports, on 2019-syllabus cohorts, only recommended putting it at the top.

Pick a topic the external exam doesn't use. Unit 4 Topic 2 is the external assessment: "In 2026 and 2027, schools select one of the following topics: Cleopatra VII; Julius Caesar." Your IA3 can't focus on your school's choice. The 2025 report gives the case: "where schools select Julius Caesar as their external assessment topic and Topic 5 ... for IA3, students cannot focus their IA3 research on Julius Caesar." The 2019 syllabus had no such rule. The QCAA Ancient History external exam guide covers that exam.

Carry one argument through. The 2022 to 2024 reports describe a hypothesis set out in the introduction, developed in the body and "summed up in the conclusion". They define "sophisticated" as "intellectual complexity" sustained across the response. The top of IA3 Synthesising asks for a response that "skilfully combines evidence from historical sources to justify decisions".

Keep issues tied to your question. The 2023 to 2025 reports discuss Comprehending, which at 3-4 asks for an "informed understanding of concepts related to the key inquiry question". The 2025 report wants issues related "directly to the key inquiry question, rather than to the general time period". The 2024 report also credits the "relationship between concepts and ideas", a phrase from the 2019 descriptor that the 2025 one doesn't use, and the 2025 report credits "relationships between concepts ... and a variety of ideas".

Length. The 2023 and 2024 reports say a response over 2000 words triggers the school's academic assessment policy.

Reference list. The 2024 report asks for "a reference list ... rather than a bibliography".

How are Ancient History IA2 and IA3 marked?

Both instrument-specific marking guides (ISMGs) are printed in the syllabus. They share most criteria but weight them differently.

CriterionIA2 marksIA3 marks
Devising and Conducting54
ComprehendingNot a criterion4
Analysing54
Evaluating54
Synthesising55
Communicating54
Total2525

IA2 at the top. Devising and Conducting 4-5 is quoted above. Analysing runs 5 to 1 on the same ladder as IA1, which the QCAA Ancient History IA1 guide sets out. Evaluating 5 asks for "discerning and well-reasoned judgments about the usefulness and reliability" of evidence, and Evaluating 3 accepts "usefulness and/or reliability". Synthesising 5 asks for a "sophisticated historical argument that skilfully combines evidence from historical sources".

IA3 at the top. Devising and Conducting 3-4 matches IA2 without the sub-questions. Evaluating runs from 4, "discerning and well-reasoned judgments about the usefulness and reliability", down to 1, "superficial, irrelevant and/or inaccurate". Communicating 3-4 asks that "all features of a historical essay based on research are consistently applied".

How do you make judgments about usefulness and reliability?

Add the reasoning. The 2025 report shows a statement turning into a judgment. "Livy wrote 200 years after the battle, which must be considered when using his evidence" is a statement until it adds "as his proximity in time to Scipio Africanus limits reliability". The 2022, 2024 and 2025 reports make this point.

Weigh strengths and limitations. At the top, the reports describe judgments that weigh "strengths and limitations", tied to the focus of your inquiry and the excerpt you chose. They say so for IA2 in 2024 and 2025 and for IA3 in 2022 to 2025 (2022 and 2023 add "weaknesses").

Cover both across the response. For IA3, the 2025 report says usefulness and reliability must both be "evident across the response", not judged for every source. The 2022 and 2024 reports also put both at the upper levels.

Don't let evaluation swamp the argument. For IA3, the 2024 report says "evaluation should not come at the expense of presenting a clear argument". Between them, the 2024 and 2025 reports also say the words "reliable" and "useful" are "not mandated".

Corroboration under the 2025 marking guides. The 2022 to 2024 IA2 reports discuss corroboration, and the 2024 report says "corroboration must be linked to judgments about reliability and usefulness". That followed the 2019 top band, "well-reasoned and corroborated". The 2025 ladders say "well-reasoned" only, and the 2025 report's IA2 section mentions corroboration only to rule out using additional sources to corroborate the 4 to 6 chosen sources.

How do you choose what to analyse?

Choose the features of each source that serve your question. The 2024 report (IA2 and IA3) and the 2025 report (IA2) both ask for chosen features, and the 2025 report says templates that make students analyse all features "may limit" discernment. The IA1 guide covers the same principle for an exam.

The 2025 report shows an IA2 analysis it places at the top level, on a coin.

It moves from what the coin is, to what it shows, to what that suggests about Athenian self-image.

Are there QCAA sample IA2 and IA3 tasks?

Yes, both are samples "to assist and support teachers", not past tasks. Your school writes its own.

  • IA2 sample: "Topic 6: Fifth Century Athens (BCE)". It lists the IA2 features as "you will" steps and suggests the same 150, 1200 and 650 word split.
  • IA3 sample: Topic 5, Ancient Rome, Civil War and the breakdown of the Republic. It asks for research "that is not the focus of the external assessment topic" and "your key inquiry question included at the beginning of your response", and says "The key inquiry question and direct quotes are included in the word count."

Both samples are labelled v1.2, one version behind the current syllabus.

QCAA Ancient History IA2 and IA3 exemplars from the subject reports

These excerpts were written under the 2019 syllabus and no mark is printed for them. Each shows one response.

How did IA2 and IA3 marks hold up at confirmation?

Confirmation is QCAA checking your school's marking afterwards. The reports publish how often the confirmed mark agreed with the school's provisional mark. These are 2019-syllabus cohorts and 2019 criteria, and the figures measure school marking, not student performance.

Evaluating agreement (%)2022202320242025
IA284.7790.6481.4089.32
IA381.7391.1394.4293.20

The reports show Evaluating as the least reliably marked criterion, tied with Analysing for IA2 in 2023. For the wider process, see the QCE internal assessments guide.

Common mistakes in Ancient History IA2 and IA3

Using extra sources to build the IA2 argument. Sources outside your 4 to 6 are for context only. The 2024 report says they "must not be used to develop the key inquiry question or corroborate".

Stating a fact about a source and stopping. "It must be noted that Polybius had close ties to Scipio Aemilianus" is a statement in the 2025 report. Say what that does to his reliability.

Writing sub-questions in IA3. Sub-questions belong to IA2, and the reports keep warning schools not to mix the two specifications. Check your features against the right list.

Researching the external personality for IA3. If your school chose Julius Caesar for the external assessment, your IA3 can't focus on him.

Letting evaluation take over. The 2024 report says evaluation "should not come at the expense of presenting a clear argument".

Writing about a whole period. The 2025 report wants issues tied "directly to the key inquiry question, rather than to the general time period". Narrow the question by issue, event, time, person, group, place or society.

Weak versus strong wording

Every quoted phrase is QCAA's own. The cells show what the reports and syllabus discuss and are not model sentences. Report comments are on 2019-syllabus cohorts.

WeakerStrongerSource
"Livy wrote 200 years after the battle, which must be considered when using his evidence"The same, adding "as his proximity in time to Scipio Africanus limits reliability"2025 p. 24
"It must be noted that Polybius had close ties to Scipio Aemilianus"The same, adding "so he may depict Scipio Africanus in a more positive light, reducing his trustworthiness."2025 p. 24
"includes a key inquiry question and/or sub-questions" (IA2, 1 mark)"nuanced key inquiry question and relevant sub-questions" (IA2, 4-5 marks)Syllabus p. 34
Issues related "to the general time period"Issues related "directly to the key inquiry question"2025 p. 23
A bibliography"a reference list"2024 p. 21; syllabus p. 11

Before you submit

IA2

  • Does your key inquiry question specify an issue, event, time, person, group, place or society?
  • Do you have 3 to 5 sub-questions, and do they show up in your interrogation and critical summary?
  • Are your 4 to 6 sources ancient and modern, and none of them studied or supplied in class?
  • Have you used any other source for context only?
  • Is each source excerpt included?
  • Is your critical summary in paragraphs, combining evidence from your 4 to 6 sources?
  • Is the response within 2000 words, counting headings and scaffold text?

IA3

  • Is your key inquiry question at the beginning?
  • Is your topic outside your school's external assessment personality?
  • Does your introduction set out a hypothesis that your conclusion sums up?
  • Do your issues tie to your question, not the whole period?
  • Have you judged both usefulness and reliability somewhere in the response?
  • Is the response within 2000 words, including the question and direct quotes?

Both

  • Does each judgment give a reason, not only a fact about the source?
  • Does your response end with a reference list?

Frequently asked questions

What is the difference between QCE Ancient History IA2 and IA3?

IA2 is an independent source investigation on a Unit 3 topic: a key inquiry question with 3 to 5 sub-questions, an interrogation of 4 to 6 sources and a critical summary. IA3 is a historical essay based on research on a Unit 4 topic, with a key inquiry question at the beginning and no sub-questions. Both are up to 2000 words and worth 25%.

Which sources can you use in the Ancient History IA2?

Evidence from 4 to 6 historical sources, including ancient and modern, that have not been studied or supplied in class. The 2023 to 2025 reports say other sources may give context only, and the 2024 report says they "must not be used to develop the key inquiry question or corroborate".

Does the source excerpt count towards the Ancient History IA2 word limit?

No. The reports say the included excerpt does not count: it "does not contribute to the word limit" (2022, 2023) and "is not included in the response length" (2024, 2025). Quotes in your own writing count unless they are cited for authentication purposes, and the 2023 and 2024 reports say headings and scaffold text count too.

Can you research Julius Caesar for the Ancient History IA3?

Not if your school chose Julius Caesar for the external assessment. The 2025 report says that where a school selects Julius Caesar as its external assessment topic and Topic 5 for IA3, "students cannot focus their IA3 research on Julius Caesar."

Do you need sub-questions in the Ancient History IA3?

No. Sub-questions are an IA2 feature. The 2022 report says "Sub-questions are not required in the IA3", and the 2025 syllabus lists none among the IA3 features.

Why do older QCAA reports talk about primary and secondary sources for IA2 and IA3?

The 2022 to 2024 reports describe 2019-syllabus cohorts. The 2025 syllabus says ancient and modern sources, and in its marking guides only Devising and Conducting names the pair.

Sources

  • Ancient History 2025 v1.4 General senior syllabus, QCAA, March 2026, pp. 11, 22, 25, 32-39. The features of each technique, the external assessment topics, the IA2 and IA3 specifications and conditions, and both instrument-specific marking guides.
  • Ancient History 2025 v1.2 IA2: Sample assessment instrument, QCAA, pp. 1-4. A sample for teachers, set on Fifth Century Athens.
  • Ancient History 2025 v1.2 IA3: Sample assessment instrument, QCAA, pp. 1-4. A sample for teachers, set on the breakdown of the Roman Republic.
  • Ancient History 2019 v1.2 General Senior Syllabus, QCAA, pp. 61-63, 79-82. The 2019 IA2 and IA3 marking guides, used to label which report advice was written against older descriptors.
  • Ancient History subject report, 2025 cohort, QCAA, January 2026, pp. 14-25. Commentary on a 2019-syllabus cohort, the differences between the 2019 and 2025 marking guides, confirmation figures and excerpts.
  • Ancient History subject report, 2024 cohort, QCAA, January 2025, pp. 15-18, 20-24. Commentary on a 2019-syllabus cohort and confirmation figures.
  • Ancient History subject report, 2023 cohort, QCAA, January 2024, pp. 16-18, 20-25. Commentary on a 2019-syllabus cohort and confirmation figures.
  • Ancient History subject report, 2022 cohort, QCAA, February 2023, pp. 15-16, 19-20, 22-24. Commentary on a 2019-syllabus cohort, confirmation figures and an IA3 excerpt.

Syllabus and assessment material referenced in this guide is © State of Queensland (Queensland Curriculum and Assessment Authority), licensed under CC BY 4.0. See our QCAA licensing notice. AusGrader is an independent study tool and is not affiliated with, endorsed by, or operated by the QCAA.

Keep reading

Practise what you just read

Work through real QCAA Ancient History questions and get your written answers marked against the official criteria, instantly.