QCE Ancient History

QCAA Ancient History IA1 Extended Response: How to Get Top Marks (QCE)

QCAA Ancient History IA1 is a supervised essay exam worth 25% of your QCE Ancient History result and marked out of 25. You get 15 minutes planning and 120 minutes working time to write a historical argument that answers an unseen question, using 6 to 7 seen sources you received a week earlier and 3 to 5 unseen ones. Five criteria are worth 5 marks each, and the top of Evaluating asks for "discerning and well-reasoned judgments about the usefulness and/or reliability of evidence from historical sources in the stimulus".

This guide describes Ancient History 2025 v1.4 (March 2026), the current syllabus. IA1 is one of four assessments in QCAA Ancient History (QCE), and the QCE Ancient History study guide sets all four side by side. The syllabus prints no first-examined year; we read 2026 as the first Year 12 cohort under it. The commentary quoted here is older. The 2022 to 2025 subject reports describe 2019-syllabus cohorts, marked on a different split of marks, so report quotes are labelled by year and no report yet marks a response against the 2025 marking guide.

What is the QCAA Ancient History IA1?

Weighting25%
Marked out of25
ResponseAn essay in response to historical sources, to an unseen question
Stimulus6 to 7 seen sources and 3 to 5 unseen sources
Seen sourcesGiven "one week before the examination"
Planning time15 minutes
Working time120 minutes
Notes"Students must not take notes"
LengthNo word length is printed in the 2025 conditions
Individual or group"individual supervised task"

The syllabus describes the task like this: "Students write an essay in response to historical sources that requires them to create a historical argument that responds to an unseen question, using evidence from historical sources included in the stimulus."

It assesses objectives 2 to 6: comprehend, analyse, evaluate, synthesise and create. The IA1 pages don't name a unit. IA2 must use a Unit 3 topic "not previously assessed in IA1", and the QCAA sample IA1 is set on Unit 3, so expect a Unit 3 topic. Your task sheet names it.

What sources do you get in the Ancient History IA1?

Every source comes with "separate and distinct context statements". The 2024 report says a context statement "should not provide analysis or evaluation", and the 2025 report says not to include them, so the context tells you what the source is and leaves the judging to you.

The syllabus also says the "Stimulus must be succinct enough to be engaged with during the planning time." The reports add detail on how schools build it:

  • Count. The 2024 report says an image and the article it comes from are two sources, and the 2025 report says sources must not be "labelled as one".
  • Mix. The 2023 to 2025 reports ask for a range of source types and perspectives.
  • Length. The 2022 and 2025 reports ask for succinct unseen sources. The 2025 report notes "longer literary sources were provided as seen sources".

The question. The 2023 to 2025 reports describe questions phrased "To what extent …", and the 2022 report wants a question that lets students "develop their own hypothesis and a unique response". Expect to take a position.

The week before. "The teacher does not help students to interrogate the seen sources", and you can't take notes in. So the week is for knowing the seen sources well: who made each one, what its features are, and what would make it more or less useful or reliable. The final judgment has to wait for the question. The 2025 report praises a usefulness judgment made "in the specific context of the unseen question".

What does the IA1 essay need to include?

The syllabus lists the features of an essay in response to historical sources:

  • an introduction that "sets context and includes a hypothesis and outline of the historical argument"
  • "body paragraphs with topic sentences"
  • a conclusion
  • "ethical scholarship in the form of noting, e.g. the source number, author, title and/or combination of these or similar approaches"

Communicating marks those features. At 4-5 it asks that "all features of an essay in response to historical sources are consistently applied", with ideas conveyed "clearly and purposefully" and "minimal errors in spelling, grammar and punctuation". At 1, "frequent errors ... impede the communication of ideas". The 2023, 2024 and 2025 reports each come back to the full set: context, hypothesis and outline in the introduction, topic sentences, and a conclusion.

The 2024 report warned that "Excessive analysis and evaluation may impede" a concise response. That was written against a 2019 top descriptor that began "succinct". The 2025 one asks for ideas conveyed "clearly and purposefully".

Referencing. The 2024 and 2025 reports accept "(Source 1) or (S1)", and the 2023 report "Smith (Source 1) or Smith (S1)". The 2025 report says "A recognised system of referencing is not required." The 2023 report says it matters most "when there is more than one source from a particular author", so make sure two sources by one writer can't be confused.

The 2025 report says your task sheet must tell you to write an essay "that includes all its features". Listing them is "not mandatory, it is recommended", so the list above is your checklist even if your sheet doesn't print one.

How is Ancient History IA1 marked?

The instrument-specific marking guide (ISMG) is printed in the syllabus. It has five criteria, each worth 5 marks, for a total of 25.

CriterionMarksHow the levels run
Comprehending5Ranges: 4-5, 2-3, 1
Analysing5One descriptor per mark, 5 to 1
Evaluating5One descriptor per mark, 5 to 1
Synthesising5One descriptor per mark, 5 to 1
Communicating5Ranges: 4-5, 2-3, 1

In every criterion, 0 means "The student response does not match any of the descriptors above."

Your teacher matches your essay to the descriptors on best fit. The 2024 and 2025 reports describe matching the response to the "typical characteristics" of a level, and the 2023 and 2024 reports advise annotating the ISMG "particularly where there is a two-mark range".

How do you reach the top of Evaluating?

Evaluating runs from 5 to 1 on one word each. Judgments are "discerning and well-reasoned" at 5, "effective" at 4, "adequate" at 3, "superficial" at 2, and "irrelevant or inaccurate" at 1. Every level asks for judgments "about the usefulness and/or reliability of evidence".

Make a judgment, not a statement. The 2022 to 2025 reports all return to this. The 2022 report: "A judgment explains why/how a source may be useful or reliable, whereas a statement expresses an opinion only." The 2025 report says a judgment needs "a decision or opinion about the degree to which a source is reliable or useful, and reasoning".

Credentials belong to Analysing. The 2024 report says noting an author and their credentials is "best matched to the Analysing criterion". The judgment is what you decide those credentials mean for this question.

Avoid reasons that fit any source. The 2025 report: "'Plutarch is reliable because he's an ancient source' would best match a superficial judgment, as the judgment is vague and surface-level, and the reasoning provided is interchangeable with other similar sources."

Corroboration under the 2025 marking guide. The 2022, 2023 and 2024 reports describe top judgments drawn from "a range of sources and/or different perspectives", "well-reasoned and corroborated", with corroboration "linked to a judgment of usefulness and/or reliability". Those reports were applying the 2019 descriptor, which named both range and corroboration. The 2025 top descriptor asks for "discerning and well-reasoned judgments" and names neither, and the 2025 report doesn't mention corroboration for IA1.

How do you reach the top of Analysing?

At 5, Analysing asks for "discerning selection and detailed examination of features of evidence from historical sources". At 3 the examination is "adequate"; at 2 it is "identification of features", and at 1 "identification of a feature".

The key word is selection. The 2022 to 2025 reports all say it:

  • 2022: features "relevant to the development of the response"
  • 2023: "Not all features of evidence are required"
  • 2024: "the most relevant feature/s ... for each source"
  • 2025: not "the same features of evidence for each source in a formulaic way"

The 2022 and 2024 reports also ask for evidence examined "in relation to the historical argument being presented", and an explanation of "how this evidence contributes to the development of the hypothesis". That was a clause of the 2019 Analysing descriptor. The 2025 Analysing ladder has no such clause: it marks the selection and examination of features.

How do you reach the top of Synthesising and Comprehending?

Synthesising. At 5 the ISMG asks for a "sophisticated historical argument that skilfully combines evidence from a range of historical sources to justify decisions". At 1 it is a "superficial historical argument or non-historical argument that refers to evidence from sources."

Two reports describe "sophisticated". The 2023 report calls it "intellectual complexity ... sustained throughout", seen in "nuance in the hypothesis, signposting in topic sentences" and the conclusion. The 2025 report describes "acknowledging and accounting for the range of ideas presented in the available sources".

Comprehending. At 4-5 the ISMG asks for "thorough and mostly accurate use of terms in historical context", "informed understanding of concepts related to the unseen question" and "detailed explanation of issues related to the unseen question". At 1 it is "partial and/or inaccurate use of terms" and "superficial understanding of concepts." The 2022 to 2024 reports stress terms used in context and issues tied to the question.

Those reports also credit understanding of the "relationship between concepts and ideas". That phrase came from the 2019 descriptor. The 2025 descriptor asks for understanding of "concepts related to the unseen question".

Is there a sample QCAA Ancient History IA1?

Yes, but it is a sample, not a past paper and not your school's task. QCAA says it "has been compiled by the QCAA to assist and support teachers in planning and developing assessment instruments for individual school settings."

It is set on Unit 3, "Topic 13: The Medieval Crusades", with ten sources: unseen sources 1 to 4 and seen sources 5 to 10, each with a context statement. The task is to "Write an essay in response to historical sources that includes all its features", and the question is:

"To what extent does the evidence support this representation in the Gesta Francorum — that the participants in the First Crusade were motivated by a sense of religious duty?"

The sample is labelled v1.2, one version behind the current syllabus. Its criteria and marks match v1.4.

QCAA Ancient History IA1 exemplars from the subject reports

These are short excerpts from handwritten responses, transcribed from the reports. No mark is printed for either, and both were written under the 2019 syllabus. The reports say a characteristic shown "may not be the only time" it occurs in the response.

How did Ancient History IA1 marks hold up at confirmation?

Confirmation is QCAA checking your school's marking afterwards. Each report publishes how often the confirmed mark agreed with the school's provisional mark. These are 2019-syllabus cohorts and 2019 criteria, and the figures measure school marking, not student performance.

Evaluating2022202320242025
Agreement (%)88.8389.6690.7091.26
Confirmed below provisional (%)9.148.376.057.28

Evaluating had the lowest agreement of the criteria in each of those four years. For every other criterion, the share confirmed below provisional stayed under 4%. For the wider process, see the QCE internal assessments guide.

Common mistakes in Ancient History IA1

Calling a source useful without saying why. The 2023 report sets "Ernst Badian, professor at Harvard University, is a useful source for understanding Alexander the Great" against a judgment that explains what Badian's standing means for the question. A label with no reasoning is a statement.

Giving a reason that fits any source. "Plutarch is reliable because he's an ancient source" is the 2025 report's example of a superficial judgment. Tie the reason to this source and this question.

Running every source through the same checklist. The 2025 report warns against examining "the same features of evidence for each source in a formulaic way". Pick the features that move your argument.

Treating credentials as evaluation. The 2024 report places author and credentials in Analysing. Go on to say what they mean for usefulness or reliability.

Leaving out a feature of the essay. Communicating at the top wants all features "consistently applied". Check your introduction has context, a hypothesis and an outline.

Weak versus strong wording

Every quoted phrase is QCAA's own. The cells show what the reports discuss and are not model sentences. All report comments are on 2019-syllabus cohorts.

WeakerStrongerSource
"Ernst Badian, professor at Harvard University, is a useful source for understanding Alexander the Great""Determined by his peers to be the most influential Alexander historian, Ernst Badian, through his research as a professor at Harvard University, provides a useful opposing viewpoint that reshaped the scholarly perception of Alexander the Great"2023 p. 14
"Plutarch is reliable because he's an ancient source""a decision or opinion about the degree to which a source is reliable or useful, and reasoning"2025 p. 12
A statement that "expresses an opinion only"A judgment that "explains why/how a source may be useful or reliable"2022 p. 13
"the same features of evidence for each source in a formulaic way""the most relevant feature/s ... for each source"2025 p. 11; 2024 p. 11
Noting an author and credentials, which is "best matched to the Analysing criterion"A usefulness judgment "in the specific context of the unseen question"2024 p. 12; 2025 p. 13, one excerpt

Frequently asked questions

Can you take notes into the QCE Ancient History IA1?

No. The syllabus says "Students must not take notes". You get the 6 to 7 seen sources one week before the exam, and your teacher does not help you interrogate them. The 3 to 5 unseen sources and the question are new on the day.

How do you reference sources in the Ancient History IA1 essay?

The syllabus calls it ethical scholarship, noting for example the source number, author or title. The 2024 and 2025 reports accept "(Source 1) or (S1)" (the 2023 report gives "Smith (S1)"), and the 2025 report says "A recognised system of referencing is not required".

What is the difference between a statement and a judgment in Ancient History?

The 2022 report says a judgment "explains why/how a source may be useful or reliable, whereas a statement expresses an opinion only." The 2025 report says a judgment needs a decision about the degree of reliability or usefulness, and reasoning.

Why do older QCAA reports give different marks for the Ancient History IA1 criteria?

The 2022 to 2025 reports describe 2019-syllabus cohorts, marked on Comprehending 6, Analysing 4, Synthesising 4, Evaluating 6 and Creating and communicating 5. Under the 2025 syllabus all five criteria are worth 5.

Sources

  • Ancient History 2025 v1.4 General senior syllabus, QCAA, March 2026, pp. 11, 28-31. The features of an essay in response to historical sources, the IA1 specification and conditions, and the instrument-specific marking guide.
  • Ancient History 2025 v1.2 IA1: Sample assessment instrument, QCAA, pp. 1-3. A sample for teachers. The source of the sample task described in this guide.
  • Ancient History 2019 v1.2 General Senior Syllabus, QCAA, pp. 58-60. The 2019 IA1 marking guide, used to label which report advice was written against older descriptors.
  • Ancient History subject report, 2025 cohort, QCAA, January 2026, pp. 9-13. Commentary on a 2019-syllabus cohort, the differences between the 2019 and 2025 marking guides, confirmation figures and an excerpt.
  • Ancient History subject report, 2024 cohort, QCAA, January 2025, pp. 9-14. Commentary on a 2019-syllabus cohort, confirmation figures and an excerpt.
  • Ancient History subject report, 2023 cohort, QCAA, January 2024, pp. 10, 12, 14-15. Commentary on a 2019-syllabus cohort and confirmation figures.
  • Ancient History subject report, 2022 cohort, QCAA, February 2023, pp. 9-13. Commentary on a 2019-syllabus cohort and confirmation figures.

Syllabus and assessment material referenced in this guide is © State of Queensland (Queensland Curriculum and Assessment Authority), licensed under CC BY 4.0. See our QCAA licensing notice. AusGrader is an independent study tool and is not affiliated with, endorsed by, or operated by the QCAA.

Keep reading

Practise what you just read

Work through real QCAA Ancient History questions and get your written answers marked against the official criteria, instantly.