HSC English Advanced Paper 2 (NESA): sections, marking and common mistakes
HSC English Advanced Paper 2 is NESA's 60-mark exam, with 5 minutes of reading time and 2 hours of writing time. It has three sections of 20 marks, about 40 minutes each: Section I, Textual conversations, on a pair of prescribed texts; Section II, Critical study of literature, on one prescribed text; and Section III, The craft of writing, a writing task of up to two parts that needs no prescribed text.
The 2027 HSC is the first examined on the English Advanced 11-12 Syllabus (2024). The 2021 to 2025 papers were all set on the 2017 syllabus, where these sections were Modules A, B and C. The 2017 syllabus stops being available after December 2026. This guide takes the format from NESA's 2027 sample paper and uses the 2021 to 2025 papers for patterns and markers' feedback. For the course as a whole, see the HSC English Advanced course page. The other 40 exam marks are in HSC English Advanced Paper 1, and the papers themselves are linked from HSC past papers.
What is the format of HSC English Advanced Paper 2?
| Section I | Section II | Section III | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Focus area (2024 syllabus) | Textual conversations (was Module A) | Critical study of literature (was Module B) | The craft of writing (was Module C) |
| Marks | 20 | 20 | 20 |
| Suggested time | About 40 minutes | About 40 minutes | About 40 minutes |
| What you write on | Your pair of prescribed texts | Your prescribed text | A stimulus or unseen text, with no prescribed text required |
| Questions | One | One | One, in up to two parts |
Everything goes in the Paper 2 writing booklet, in black pen. Paper 2 is 60 of the 100 exam marks. Your school assessment components are on the course page, and how the school and exam marks combine is in how the HSC works.
Each section prints what it is judged on. In our words:
- Section I: how well you understand the way a composer is shaped by the ideas and values of another text, how well you evaluate the link between texts and their contexts, and your expression.
- Section II: your understanding of the text's ideas, of its distinctive language and style, and your expression.
- Section III: how well you craft language to meet the question, and how well you use it for audience, purpose and context.
Under the 2024 specification, The craft of writing can ask for imaginative, discursive, persuasive or reflective writing, and can give you a stimulus or an unseen text to work from.
What is different about Paper 2 from 2027?
The frame stays: three 20-mark sections, 2 hours plus 5 minutes, one question per section, and a craft of writing question of up to two parts. NESA's sample says the structure matches its 2019 Paper 2. What has moved:
- Names. Module A is now Textual conversations, Module B is Critical study of literature and Module C is The craft of writing.
- Example questions. The sample shows its Section I and II questions as examples of possible types, not as the one fixed question. For Section II it adds that the 2019 to 2024 HSC papers show other types. Neither the specification nor the sample says whether 2027 will set one question for everyone or a separate question for each text.
- The craft of writing split. The sample's two parts are 10 and 10. The 2023 and 2025 papers used 12 and 8.
- No prescribed texts in The craft of writing. The sample says Section III doesn't require responses to prescribed texts. On the 2017 syllabus, part (b) of the 2021 question asked for reference to prescribed texts.
- Prescribed texts. The sample's Section I pairings are Baynton with Cobby Eckermann, Blake with Tokarczuk, Keats with Bright Star, Hamlet with Dickinson, Julius Caesar with The Prince, and Mrs Dalloway with The Hours. Its Section II texts are Pride and Prejudice, Warlight, Glück, Yeats, Othello and Henry IV Part 1. The 2021 to 2025 Section II lists were different (for example Emma, Great Expectations, Eliot, Malouf, A Doll's House and Nabokov). Some texts carry over: Keats with Bright Star and Woolf with Daldry were on earlier Section I lists, and Henry IV Part 1 on earlier Section II lists. The sample calls itself one way the syllabus could be examined, so it is not the confirmed 2027 list.
- Pairing groups. The 2021 to 2025 papers kept the same seven pairing types: film paired with Shakespearean drama, with prose fiction or with poetry; two prose fiction texts; two poetry texts; poetry with drama; and Shakespearean drama with prose fiction. The sample's mapping grid lists five groups. Whether the 2027 prescriptions keep all seven isn't shown.
For every course on a new syllabus, see the HSC syllabus guide.
What does Section I, Textual conversations, ask?
Always both texts of your pairing, and usually a judgement: 2022 to 2025 asked you to evaluate, while 2021 asked you to explain and the sample's Example A to analyse.
| Year | What Section I asked |
|---|---|
| 2021 | A question for each pairing, with an extract from each text: how the extracts add to a wider conversation |
| 2022 | A question for each pairing, with one extract (from the later text, where the paper names its source): how far the later text's perspectives clash with the earlier text's |
| 2023 | One question for every pairing, built on a quoted statement: how far the later text makes you ask that question of the earlier one |
| 2024 | One question for every pairing: how far your view of the earlier text decided how you read the later one |
| 2025 | A question for each pairing, each naming one idea (strategy, conformity, alienation, humility, creativity, reinvention or artistry): evaluate its role in deepening your appreciation of how the texts connect. No extract |
| 2027 sample | Two example types: one for any pairing, on each text's context and the conversation between them, and one for Hamlet and Dickinson, on shared or opposed perspectives on identity |
Extracts were supplied in 2021 and 2022 only. In 2025 the question returned to a separate one for each pairing, this time built on a named idea.
What does Section II, Critical study of literature, ask?
How, or how far, your prescribed text works and what it means.
| Year | What Section II asked |
|---|---|
| 2021 | One question for every text: a statement about literature, and how far it holds |
| 2022 | A question for each text: how studying it changed and widened your understanding of an idea, such as dependency or duty |
| 2023 | One question for every text: evaluate how its construction deepened your personal and intellectual engagement |
| 2024 | One question for every text: evaluate how artistry and integrity shaped your sense of its literary value |
| 2025 | A question for each text, each with a closing extract: in what ways the extract resolves the tensions the text explores |
| 2027 sample | Three examples: one for any text, on how its distinctive features shape meaning, and two statements to weigh up for Warlight and Yeats |
Of the 2021 to 2025 papers, only 2025 printed an extract for every text.
How are Sections I and II marked?
In the 2022 to 2025 guidelines and the 2027 sample, both sections use five bands: 17 to 20, 13 to 16, 9 to 12, 5 to 8 and 1 to 4. In the 2022 to 2025 guidelines (and the sample's Section I Example B), each of the top three bands checks three things:
- A judgement that answers the question, led by the question's verb.
- Understanding of context, language, form and ideas, shown through references to the text. The references go from plain, to detailed, to well-selected and detailed as the band rises.
- Control of language for audience, purpose and form.
The sample's other example ladders word the second strand differently, and its Section II Example A rewards understanding of the text's distinctive features rather than a judgement.
At 5 to 8 a response describes parts of the text with limited references, and 1 to 4 is an attempt.
The verb in the bands follows the verb in the question, so it changed with the paper:
- Section I, 2023: evaluate how far the later text prompted the quoted question.
- Section I, 2024: evaluate how the perspective on the earlier text shaped the reading of the later one.
- Section I, 2025: the top two bands evaluate the role of the named idea. The 9 to 12 band only explains it.
- Section II, 2023 and 2024: evaluate, in all three top bands.
- Section II, 2025: the question asked in what ways, and the top three bands asked you to explain the ways the extract resolves the tensions. They didn't use evaluate.
In 2025, then, a Section I answer that explained the named idea without judging its role sat in 9 to 12 at best. The Paper 2 guidelines for 2022 to 2025 print no sample answers, so the guidelines give no model of a top-band Section I or II response for those years.
What does Section III, The craft of writing, ask?
A short stimulus and a writing task that names its form. The split of marks between parts has varied, and only 2023 and 2025 shared one.
| Year | Part (a) | Part (b) |
|---|---|---|
| 2021 | 10 marks: use a supplied image to build a central metaphor, in imaginative, discursive or persuasive writing | 10 marks: evaluate how studying figurative language shaped your choices, with reference to prescribed texts |
| 2022 | 5 marks: explore how a supplied extract expresses personal fulfilment, naming a device | 15 marks: imaginative or discursive writing about a shared experience that brings fulfilment |
| 2023 | 12 marks: an imaginative or discursive piece from a short extract on hope and anticipation | 8 marks: justify your stylistic choices |
| 2024 | One 20-mark question with no parts: discursive or persuasive writing using the ideas in a short stimulus | None |
| 2025 | 12 marks: an imaginative narrative with a supplied image as its focus | 8 marks: explain how the image shaped meaning in your piece, citing your language choices |
| 2027 sample | 10 marks: continue a short extract as imaginative, discursive or persuasive writing that draws an emotional response | 10 marks: evaluate the language you used in part (a) |
The stimulus was an image in 2021 and 2025 and an extract in 2022, 2023 and 2024. A reflective or analytical part came after the writing in 2021, 2023, 2025 and the sample, and before it in 2022. 2024 had none.
How is The craft of writing marked?
Each sitting's guidelines set their own bands, so these are that year's, not a fixed rule.
2023 and 2025. Part (a), out of 12, ran in bands of 10 to 12, 7 to 9, 4 to 6 and 1 to 3, looking at how you engage with the stimulus or image, how you craft language, and your control of language and structure. Part (b), out of 8, ran 7 to 8, 5 to 6, 3 to 4 and 1 to 2. In 2023 the top two bands of part (b) needed you to justify your choices, and explaining them sat at 3 to 4. In 2025 the top band was a skilful explanation of how the image shaped meaning, and describing sat at 3 to 4. Both years wanted references to your own part (a).
2024. The single question ran in five bands out of 20. It rewarded a sound, engaging discursive or persuasive piece that used the stimulus's ideas, with control of language and structure suited to audience, purpose, context and form.
2022. Part (a), out of 5, rewarded exploring the idea, explaining a device and control of language. Part (b), out of 15, ran in five bands.
2027 sample. Both parts ran in bands of 9 to 10, 7 to 8, 5 to 6, 3 to 4 and 1 to 2. Part (b) rewarded evaluating the language you crafted and the link between composing a text and responding to one.
How NESA marking works in general is in the HSC marking guide, and what each key word asks for is in HSC key words.
What do markers say costs marks in Paper 2?
These come from the general feedback NESA wrote on each section for 2021 to 2025, in our words. Text-by-text and pairing-by-pairing feedback isn't covered here.
Section I, Textual conversations
Evidence that describes but doesn't support a judgement. Named in 2023, 2024 and 2025. In 2021 the point was detailed knowledge of both texts.
Themes in place of ideas. In 2023 and 2024 markers wanted the conversation treated as a set of concepts, not a list of shared themes. In 2025 the point became showing how the composers use the named ideas.
One text carrying the answer. An area to improve in 2021. From 2022 to 2025 it stayed as advice: treat both texts in a balanced, integrated way.
Ignoring the extract. An area to improve in 2021, and advice in 2022 (bring the extract or image into the answer). Only those two years supplied extracts.
Section II, Critical study of literature
None of the Section II general feedback for 2021, 2022, 2023, 2024 or 2025 names an area to improve. It repeats advice instead: answer every part of the question, show conceptual understanding, use detailed evidence, show how context, form and language build the text's value, and write with a personal voice. In 2021 and 2025 it also warned against a pre-prepared response.
Section III, The craft of writing
Answering only some of the question. Named for 2021 part (a), 2022 part (b) and 2023 part (a).
Writing in the wrong form. Named in 2024 and 2025 part (a). If the question says narrative, or discursive or persuasive, write that form.
Cliché and shock. Clichés, tired settings, and disturbing or grotesque content were flagged in 2021 part (a) and 2022 part (b).
Control and clarity. Language control, clarity and cohesion were flagged in both parts in 2021 and 2022, and in 2025 part (b).
No plan or visible purpose. In 2024 only, markers asked for planning, a clear purpose and intent, a range of crafting techniques, and control of register and modality.
The feedback also gave advice. Watch the mark value of each part (2021 to 2025) and manage your time (2022 to 2025). Don't recycle a response built on a prescribed text unless the question asks for one (2022, 2023 and 2024).
Better responses got credit for specific moves, each named in a single year: a sustained central metaphor in 2021 part (a), the stimulus used as a motif or a cyclical structure in 2023 part (a), and the image used through structure as well as language in 2025 part (a).
What separates a weaker Paper 2 answer from a stronger one?
These pairs come from the bands and feedback above. They aren't NESA sample answers.
| Weaker | Stronger | Where it comes from |
|---|---|---|
| Lists themes the two texts share | Treats the conversation as ideas and shows how each composer handles them | Section I feedback, 2023 to 2025 |
| Describes how the texts connect | Judges how purpose, form, language and context shape the connection | Section I bands and feedback, 2023 to 2025 |
| Spends most of the answer on one text | Moves between the two texts throughout | Section I feedback, 2021; advice, 2022 to 2025 |
| Explains a named idea's role | Evaluates the idea's role, as the 2025 question asked | 2025 Section I bands |
| Writes a prepared essay on the text | Reshapes the argument to the question's words | Section II advice (not a measured weakness), 2021 and 2025 |
| Mentions the stimulus without linking it to the question | Builds the piece around the stimulus and what the question asks | Section III feedback, 2021, 2023, 2024 and 2025; 2023 and 2025 better responses |
| Writes in a form the question didn't ask for | Writes in the form the question names | Section III feedback, 2024 and 2025 |
| Reflects on choices in general terms | Quotes from your own part (a) and ties each quotation to the question's focus | Part (b) feedback, 2021, 2023 and 2025 |
How should you prepare for HSC English Advanced Paper 2?
- Practise at 40 minutes a section. That's 2 minutes a mark (our arithmetic). With a 12 and 8 split, that's about 24 minutes for part (a) and 16 for part (b). With the sample's 10 and 10, it's 20 each.
- Prepare Section I for both kinds of question. Write to the 2023 and 2024 questions (one for every pairing) and to a 2025-style question built on a named idea. The sample shows both types.
- Practise more than one Section II verb. Evaluate (2023 and 2024), in what ways (2025) and how far a statement holds (2021 and the sample) all appeared. Practise once with a closing extract, as in 2025.
- Write each craft of writing form. Imaginative, discursive and persuasive pieces have all been set, plus a reflection on your own piece. Practise from an image and from an extract.
- Quote yourself. For a reflective part, pick three or four lines from your own part (a) and practise judging what each does.
- Mark against the bands. For Sections I and II, check the judgement, the references and the expression. For Section III, check that the stimulus, the form and the question's key terms are all visible.
For a revision routine across subjects, see how to prepare for HSC exams, and for your exam date, the HSC exam timetable.
Frequently asked questions
How long is HSC English Advanced Paper 2?
5 minutes of reading time, then 2 hours of writing time. The paper has three sections of 20 marks and suggests about 40 minutes for each, which is 2 minutes a mark.
Do I need to write about my prescribed texts in The craft of writing?
Under the 2024 syllabus, no. NESA's 2027 sample says Section III does not require responses to prescribed texts. On the 2017 syllabus it sometimes did: part (b) of the 2021 question asked for reference to prescribed texts.
How many parts does the craft of writing question have, and what are they worth?
Up to two parts, adding to 20 marks. The split has changed: 10 and 10 in 2021 and the 2027 sample, 5 and 15 in 2022, 12 and 8 in 2023 and 2025, and a single 20-mark question in 2024.
Will Section I have a question for my pairing or one question for every pairing?
Both have happened. 2023 and 2024 set one question for every pairing, while 2021, 2022 and 2025 set one for each pairing. The 2027 sample shows both kinds as examples, and neither the 2024 specification nor the sample says which the 2027 paper will use.
What happened to Modules A, B and C?
They are the 2017 syllabus names. Under the English Advanced 11-12 Syllabus (2024), first examined in 2027, Module A is Textual conversations (Section I), Module B is Critical study of literature (Section II) and Module C is The craft of writing (Section III).
Sources
- English Advanced 11-12 Syllabus (2024): HSC examination specifications, NESA, HSC examination specifications. Paper 2 marks, timing, sections and the forms The craft of writing can ask for, under the 2024 syllabus. Paraphrased.
- English Advanced 11-12 Syllabus (2024): Overview, NESA, Implementation from 2026. Year 12 teaching from Term 4 2026 and the first HSC exam in 2027.
- English Advanced 11-12 (2024) HSC sample examination materials, Paper 2, NESA, Paper pp. 1-8; marking guidelines pp. 1-6 and mapping grid. The 2027 sample paper, its example questions, prescribed texts and marking guidelines. Described, not reproduced.
- Assessment and reporting in English Advanced (English Advanced Stage 6 Syllabus 2017), NESA, HSC exam specifications. The Paper 2 specification under the 2017 syllabus. Paraphrased.
- English Advanced Stage 6 Syllabus (2017), NESA, 2017, Cover notice. When the 2017 syllabus stops being available.
- HSC English Advanced Examination, Paper 2, NESA, 2025, 2021 and 2022: cover and questions; 2023: pp. 2, 5, 7; 2024: pp. 3-8; 2025: pp. 2-18. Section layout, marks, prescribed text lists and the questions set each year. Questions and extracts are described, not reproduced.
- HSC English Advanced Marking Guidelines, Paper 2, NESA, 2025, 2022: pp. 1-5; 2023, 2024 and 2025: pp. 1-4. Bands for each section and The craft of writing part marks, in our own words. Criteria are not reproduced.
- HSC Marking Feedback: English Advanced, NESA, 2025, Feedback on written exam, Paper 2 general feedback, 2021 to 2025. Markers' general commentary on each Paper 2 section for five cohorts. Paraphrased.
Syllabus and assessment material referenced in this guide is used under licence, © Copyright NSW Education Standards Authority. See our NESA licensing notice. The NSW Education Standards Authority (NESA) does not endorse this product or service. NESA takes no responsibility for any errors in the reproduction of NESA Materials. Any sample examination papers or model answers accompanying the NESA Materials are not part of the NESA Materials and are in no way endorsed or authorised by NESA.