HSC English Advanced

HSC English Advanced Paper 1 (NESA): format, marking and common mistakes

HSC English Advanced Paper 1 is NESA's 40-mark exam on Texts and human experiences, with 10 minutes of reading time and 1 hour 30 minutes of writing time. Section I (20 marks, about 45 minutes) is a set of short-answer questions on unseen texts in a stimulus booklet. Section II (20 marks, about 45 minutes) is one extended response on the prescribed text you studied.

The 2027 HSC is the first one examined on the English Advanced 11-12 Syllabus (2024), and Year 12 teaching of it began in Term 4 2026. The 2021 to 2025 papers were all set on the English Advanced Stage 6 Syllabus (2017), when this unit was called the Common Module. This guide takes the format from NESA's 2027 sample paper and uses the 2021 to 2025 papers for question patterns and markers' feedback. For the course as a whole, see the HSC English Advanced course page. For the other 60 exam marks, see HSC English Advanced Paper 2. To find the papers themselves, go to HSC past papers.

What is the format of HSC English Advanced Paper 1?

The layout below holds for the 2021 to 2025 papers and the 2027 sample.

Section ISection II
Marks2020
Suggested timeAbout 45 minutesAbout 45 minutes
What you answerFive or six short-answer questions on texts in the stimulus booklet (five on the 2021 to 2025 papers and the sample)One extended response on your prescribed text
Where you writeThe ruled space under each questionA separate writing booklet
Shared with English StandardAt least three itemsThe whole question

You write in black pen, and the stimulus texts are in a booklet at the back of the paper. The ruled space under each Section I question is a hint from the examiners about how long your answer should be.

The paper states what each section is judged on. In our words:

  • Section I: how well you understand the human experiences in the texts, and how well you analyse, explain and assess the way those experiences are represented.
  • Section II: the same two things, plus how well you organise and express your ideas for your audience, purpose and context.

Paper 1 is 40 of the 100 exam marks. Your school assessment components are on the course page, and how the school and exam marks combine is in how the HSC works.

What is different about Paper 1 from 2027?

Less than the new syllabus name suggests. NESA's 2024 specification and the 2027 sample keep the shape of the old paper: two 20-mark sections, the same timing, five or six short-answer questions, at least three of them shared with English Standard, and one Section II question on a prescribed text, also shared. The sample says its structure matches NESA's 2019 Paper 1.

What has moved:

  • The name. The unit is now the focus area Texts and human experiences. Under the 2017 syllabus it was the Common Module. NESA's 2024 specification also calls Section II an extended response, where the 2017 wording called it sustained.
  • Visual texts can stand alone. The 2027 sample sets a Section I question on a magazine cover. On the past papers, a photograph only ever appeared as one half of a comparison (2022 and 2024).
  • The prescribed texts. The sample lists Au, Malouf and Lawson (prose fiction), Dobson, Harwood and Watson (poetry), Flanagan (nonfiction), Gow (drama) and Perkins (film). The 2023 to 2025 papers listed a different set, with authors such as Doerr, Orwell, Slessor and Shakespeare (The Merchant of Venice). The sample presents itself as one way the syllabus could be examined and notes that some texts may have been on earlier lists. It isn't the confirmed 2027 list, so take your text from your teacher and NESA's 2027 prescriptions.
  • Outcome codes. The sample's marking guidelines map questions to the new EAV-12 outcomes. The 2023 to 2025 guidelines used the 2017 EA12 codes.

The 2024 syllabus asks you to study four prescribed texts across the course, at least one by Shakespeare (the course page has the full rule). The 2017 Common Module also asked for a related text. The 2024 syllabus pages this guide draws on don't say whether that still applies, so check with your teacher. For every course moving to a new syllabus, see the HSC syllabus guide.

What kinds of questions are in Section I?

Five questions a year, adding to 20 marks, each built on its own stimulus.

YearMarks, Q1 to Q5Stimulus forms, in orderVisual or comparison item
20213, 3, 4, 4, 6nonfiction, poem, prose, nonfiction, proseNone
20223, 4, 4, 3, 6poem, prose, feature article, memoir, nonfiction with a photographQ5 compares a text with a photograph
20233, 4, 4, 4, 5prose, memoir, feature article, opinion piece, poemNone
20243, 4, 5, 3, 5nonfiction, nonfiction, prose with a photograph, poem, proseQ3 compares a text with a photograph
20253, 4, 4, 4, 5memoir, prose, poem, prose, nonfictionNone
2027 sample3, 4, 5, 3, 5magazine cover, prose, poem, nonfiction, proseQ1 is on a visual text alone

What repeats:

  • A poem every time. Each of the five papers and the sample had exactly one poem item: 2021 Q2, 2022 Q1, 2023 Q5, 2024 Q4, 2025 Q3 and sample Q3.
  • Mostly single-text "how" questions. Most items ask how a composer represents something in one text. In 2025, Questions 1 to 4 were all of this kind, as were 2023 Questions 2 to 4.
  • A judgement item near the end. The biggest item asked you to evaluate, assess or compare in 2021 Q5, 2022 Q5, 2024 Q3 and Q5, 2025 Q5 and sample Q5. The exception was 2023, whose Q5 asked you to analyse.
  • The last question shrank. Q5 was 6 marks in 2021 and 2022, and 5 marks in 2023, 2024, 2025 and the sample.

Questions often take an idea from the stimulus itself, such as paradox, memory, awe, or discomfort alongside joy, and make it the thing you have to analyse. Missing that idea costs marks (see the mistakes below). For what each key word wants, see HSC key words.

How is Section I marked?

Each question has its own ladder in the Marking Guidelines, and the key word decides the top rungs. In the 2023 to 2025 guidelines and the 2027 sample, the top mark usually repeats the question's verb and adds a quality word, such as effectively or skilfully, with strong evidence. The next rung keeps the verb but asks for less evidence. Below that, the ladder drops a level: explaining, then describing, then a single mark for some relevant information.

These ladders are from particular sittings. Each is that year's, not a fixed rule, and every question's ladder is in its own guidelines.

3-mark items (2024 Q1 and 2025 Q1). 3 marks for a clear explanation backed by apt evidence, 2 for an explanation with some evidence, 1 for some relevant information. The sample's Q1 and Q4 ladders have the same three rungs without the evidence wording. The 2023 Q1 asked why, and its ladder rewarded showing understanding instead of explaining.

4-mark items. In 2023 Q2 and 2024 Q2, analysis was needed for both 4 and 3 marks. An explanation with some evidence earned 2. In 2025 (Q2 and Q4), the top two rungs used explaining instead, and a description with some evidence earned 2. So a 4-mark item can top out at explain or at analyse depending on the question. Read the verb.

5-mark comparison (2024 Q3). 5 marks for a skilful comparison with evidence from both texts, 4 for an effective one, 3 for a comparison with some evidence, 2 for an attempt at comparing with thin evidence, 1 for some relevant information.

5-mark evaluation (2025 Q5). 5 marks for a skilful evaluation with detailed evidence and 4 for an evaluation with well-chosen evidence. An answer that only explained sat at 3, one that described at 2.

That last ladder is the one to remember. In 2025, an answer that explained the text well, without judging it, could not get past 3 of 5.

What does the Section II question ask?

One question, on how your prescribed text deals with an aspect of human experience. Each question ended by asking you to refer to your text, and to make close reference from 2023 on.

  • 2021: how people respond to challenges.
  • 2022: a separate question for each prescribed text, each on how the composer uses the features of the text's form to show emotion.
  • 2023: a statement about human experience, with how far you agree.
  • 2024: what the text reveals about people's qualities, motivations and actions.
  • 2025: individual lives and how the human spirit endures.
  • 2027 sample: how stories show experience that is both personal and shared.

The 2021, 2023, 2024 and 2025 papers and the sample each gave one question for all the prescribed texts. That's useful for practice: you can answer those questions with whichever text you're studying, even if it wasn't on that year's list.

How is the Section II response marked?

In the 2023, 2024 and 2025 guidelines and the 2027 sample, Section II has five bands: 17 to 20, 13 to 16, 9 to 12, 5 to 8 and 1 to 4. The top three bands each check three things:

  1. A judgement on the question's idea, led by its verb. The verb follows the question: evaluate in 2023, explain in 2024, analyse in 2025 and explain in the sample.
  2. Your references to the text, which have to get better as the band goes up.
  3. Your control of language for audience, purpose and context.

The middle band (9 to 12) is where explaining with some references sits. Below that, 5 to 8 is a limited understanding with description, and 1 to 4 is minimal reference to the text.

The 2023 to 2025 Paper 1 guidelines and the 2027 sample include sample answers. Read across them and three habits recur: an opening claim about how the composer builds the idea in the question, short quotations worked into the sentence, and a named technique tied to its effect.

How NESA marking works across courses is in the HSC marking guide, and how marks become bands is in HSC bands.

What do markers say costs marks in Paper 1?

NESA's Marking Feedback comments on every Section I question and on Section II each year. These are the problems it names as areas to improve, in our words, with the years each one appears.

No comparison language on two-text items. Named in the two years that set one: 2022 Q5 and 2024 Q3. Describing two texts in turn is not a comparison.

No clear judgement on evaluate or assess items. Named on 2021 Q5, 2024 Q5 and 2025 Q5, the only evaluate or assess items in Section I, and for the 2023 Section II question, which asked how far you agree. If the verb asks for a judgement, state one.

Generic talk about human experience. Named for 2021 Q1 and Q2, and for Section II in 2023 and 2024. In 2021 and 2022 the Section II feedback also warned against vague or generic comments. In 2024 markers wanted the particular qualities, motivations and actions identified. Name the specific experience the question is about.

Weak use of form and technical language in Section II. Named in all five years, 2021 to 2025. The wording varied: form and metalanguage (2021), metalanguage (2023), evidence suited to the medium (2022), and how language, form or genre shape meaning (2024 and 2025). Show how the text works as a novel, poem, play or film, not only what it says.

Wordy or muddled expression in Section II. Named in 2024 and 2025.

Two single-year points are specific enough to check against your own writing. In 2025, some Section II responses restated the question instead of citing specific parts of the text. In 2024, some stayed inside the world of the story and never moved to what the composer was doing and why.

The feedback also says what the better responses did. Across 2021 to 2025 they chose their evidence well, and in Section II they held one line of argument in a controlled voice (2021) or a personal one (2022 to 2025). From 2022 to 2025 they used the question's own idea to organise the answer.

What separates a weaker Paper 1 answer from a stronger one?

These pairs come from the ladders, bands and feedback above. They aren't NESA sample answers.

WeakerStrongerWhere it comes from
Retells what happens in the extractExplains how a named technique builds the idea in the questionFeedback, 2021 to 2025; Section I ladders, 2023 to 2025
Drops in a quotation and moves onUses a short quotation and says what it shows about the question's ideaFeedback, 2021, 2022, 2024 and 2025
Writes about one half of the key termDeals with every key term the question setsFeedback, 2022 to 2025
Describes one text, then the otherCompares the two, with comparison language throughoutFeedback, 2022 Q5 and 2024 Q3; 2024 Q3 ladder
Explains the text well but never judges itGives a clear judgement and supports itFeedback, 2021, 2023 (Section II), 2024 and 2025; 2025 Q5 ladder
Talks about human experience in generalNames the particular experience, quality or motivationFeedback, 2021 to 2024
Lists techniques with no link to formShows how the features of the novel, poem, play or film shape meaningSection II feedback, 2021 to 2025
Restates the question in the bodyCites specific moments from the textSection II feedback, 2025

How should you prepare for HSC English Advanced Paper 1?

  1. Sit Section I in 45 minutes. That's about 2.25 minutes a mark (our arithmetic), so roughly 7 minutes for a 3-mark item and 11 for a 5-mark item. The 2021 to 2025 papers all fit the format the 2027 sample uses.
  2. Practise every key word that has topped the ladder. Explain, analyse, compare and evaluate have all set the top rung of a Section I item. Practise turning an explanation into a judgement, because in 2025 that was the difference between 3 and 5 marks.
  3. Include a poem and a visual text. Every paper had a poem. The 2027 sample shows a visual text can be a question by itself.
  4. Write Section II answers to the past questions. The 2021, 2023, 2024 and 2025 questions and the sample's were set for any text, so they work with yours. Give each 45 minutes, plan included.
  5. Mark your Section II against the three strands. Is your judgement led by the question's verb? Are your references specific? Is your expression controlled? The top three bands all ask for the judgement, so strong references alone won't get you there.
  6. Check your expression. Wordiness was flagged in 2024 and 2025. Cut sentences that repeat the question.

For a revision routine that works across subjects, see how to prepare for HSC exams, and for your exam date, the HSC exam timetable.

Frequently asked questions

How long is HSC English Advanced Paper 1?

You get 10 minutes of reading time, then 1 hour 30 minutes of writing time. The paper suggests about 45 minutes for Section I (short answers on unseen texts) and about 45 minutes for Section II (one extended response on your prescribed text). Each section is worth 20 marks.

How many questions are in Section I of Paper 1?

NESA's specification allows five or six short-answer questions worth 20 marks between them. The 2021, 2022, 2023, 2024 and 2025 papers and the 2027 sample each set five, with the last one worth 5 or 6 marks.

Is Paper 1 the same for English Advanced and English Standard?

Partly. NESA says at least three Section I items are shared with English Standard Paper 1, and the Section II question is shared as well. In the 2027 sample the shared items are Questions 1 to 3.

Are the 2021 to 2025 Paper 1 exams still useful for the 2027 HSC?

Yes for Section I practice: the two sections, the marks and the timing carry over, and NESA says the new paper keeps the structure of its 2019 Paper 1. They were set on the 2017 syllabus, though, when the unit was the Common Module and the prescribed text list was different, so check the current format against NESA's 2027 sample.

Can Paper 1 have a visual text?

Yes. The 2027 sample sets a Section I question on a magazine cover on its own. In the 2022 and 2024 papers a photograph appeared only as one of the two texts in a comparison question.

Sources

Syllabus and assessment material referenced in this guide is used under licence, © Copyright NSW Education Standards Authority. See our NESA licensing notice. The NSW Education Standards Authority (NESA) does not endorse this product or service. NESA takes no responsibility for any errors in the reproduction of NESA Materials. Any sample examination papers or model answers accompanying the NESA Materials are not part of the NESA Materials and are in no way endorsed or authorised by NESA.