QCE Study of Religion

QCAA Study of Religion IA1 Extended Response: How to Get Top Marks (QCE)

QCAA Study of Religion IA1 is a supervised analytical essay, worth 25% of your QCE Study of Religion result and marked out of 25. With 15 minutes of planning, 120 minutes of working time and no notes, you respond to an unseen question or hypothesis on one social-ethical issue from Unit 3 Topic 1, using unseen stimulus and perspectives from two of the five major world religions. The top of Evaluating asks for "discerning judgments and relevant conclusions" and "consistent and thorough justification of judgments using religious teachings".

This guide describes Study of Religion 2025 v1.4 (March 2026), the current syllabus. IA1 is one of four assessments in QCAA Study of Religion (QCE), and the QCE Study of Religion study guide sets them side by side. The version history says implementation started in 2025, but the pages we read print no first-examined year, so treating 2026 as the first Year 12 cohort under it is our reading. The report commentary below is older. The 2022 to 2025 subject reports describe cohorts marked under the 2019 syllabus, on criteria with other names and wording, so every report quote is labelled by year.

What is the QCAA Study of Religion IA1?

Weighting25%
Marked out of25
Where it sitsUnit 3 Topic 1, one social-ethical issue
ResponseAn analytical essay to an unseen question or hypothesis
ReligionsPerspectives from two of the five major world religions
StimulusUnseen and succinct, "e.g. one A3 page or equivalent"
Planning time15 minutes
Working time120 minutes
Notes"Students must not bring notes into the examination."
LengthNone printed in the 2025 syllabus
Individual or group"individual supervised task"

The specification asks you to "engage with unseen stimulus material" and "respond in the form of an analytical essay". The essay analyses how two religions shape adherents' responses to the issue, and evaluates how much that religious influence matters.

The Unit 3 Topic 1 list has ten issues: asylum seekers, capital punishment, employment and work, environment, animal testing, refugees, slavery, privacy, food security and war. Your task covers one of them and two religions, and the 2022 to 2025 reports hold schools to that.

You may know the issue in advance. The 2024 report says "It is not a requirement that the focus of the IA1 be unknown to students." The question or hypothesis and the stimulus are new on the day.

What is in the IA1 stimulus?

The syllabus sets four rules for it:

  • "a balance of information related to two of the five major world religions and the social–ethical issue"
  • it "is succinct enough to allow students sufficient time to engage with it, e.g. one A3 page or equivalent"
  • it "has not been copied from information or texts that students have directly used in class"
  • it is written "without giving specific information about religious positions or direct teachings on the issue"

It can be written texts, visual texts or both.

The teachings come from you. The 2022 to 2025 reports all tell schools to keep specific or direct teachings out of the stimulus, and the 2025 report names "the Ten Commandments or the Noble Eightfold Path" as examples of what not to include. You can't bring notes either. So the beliefs, practices and teachings of both religions on your issue have to be in your head when you walk in, and the stimulus gives you the situation to apply them to.

It is short on purpose. The same four reports ask for stimulus that can be read in the 15 minutes of planning. The one-A3-page example is new in the 2025 syllabus; the 2019 version said only "succinct". The 2024 and 2025 reports also ask for a task that deals with views within a religion, not one denomination.

How is Study of Religion IA1 marked?

The instrument-specific marking guide (ISMG) is printed in the syllabus. It has four criteria, one for each IA1 objective (explain, analyse, evaluate, communicate), and 25 marks. Each mark range carries three descriptors, and 0 means the response matches none of them.

CriterionMarksTop rangeBottom range
Explaining65-61-2
Analysing87-81-2
Evaluating87-81-2
Communicating331

Analysing and Evaluating together carry 16 of the 25 marks.

How do you reach the top of Analysing?

At 7-8 the ISMG asks for:

  • "comprehensive selection and accurate use of relevant information from stimulus that influence decision-making"
  • "detailed and accurate explanation of distinct beliefs and practices in religious traditions, including similarities and differences"
  • "thorough examination of perspectives from two religious traditions"

At 1-2 it reads "limited selection and lack of/irrelevant use of information from stimulus" and "simplistic and/or erroneous understanding".

Use the stimulus to explain decisions. Every report from 2022 to 2025 comes back to the stimulus. The 2024 report wants it "incorporated into the essay". The 2025 report is sharper: "selection and use of relevant information from stimulus must demonstrate the influence on decision-making". So a stimulus detail earns its place when it shows why adherents of a religion respond to the issue the way they do.

Explain similarities and differences. The 2022 to 2025 reports describe a 2019 descriptor built on differentiation, and the 2023 report advised "focusing on differences, not similarities". That advice does not carry over. The 2025 report says "The word 'differentiation' does not appear in the ISMG for the 2025 syllabus", and responses "must include similarities and differences".

Examine both perspectives in full. The 2022 report said the perspectives "need to be logically thought out", the 2023 report asked for "well-reasoned" analysis, and the 2024 report wanted it "logical and justified, and interrelated through the effective use of the stimulus material". Those comments were on the 2019 descriptor, which asked for well-reasoned analysis. The 2025 top level asks for a "thorough examination of perspectives from two religious traditions".

How do you reach the top of Evaluating?

At 7-8 the ISMG asks for:

  • "succinct synthesis of ideas about the role of religion"
  • "discerning judgments and relevant conclusions about the significance of religious–ethical stances ... and its influence on adherents"
  • "consistent and thorough justification of judgments using religious teachings"

At 1-2 judgments are "simplistic and/or erroneous" and "inaccurate and/or irrelevant".

Judge the stances of adherents. The 2024 report says it is "not the purpose of the task to have students make judgments about the religious traditions". The objective is to "Evaluate the significance and influence of religion on religious–ethical stances made by adherents to a social–ethical issue". So you weigh how strongly a religion shapes what its adherents do about the issue, and you leave the worth of the religion itself alone.

Back every judgment with a teaching. Justification "using religious teachings" sits in the top descriptor, and the stimulus won't supply those teachings.

Synthesise. The 2023 report asked for evaluation that links "to the question or hypothesis", "consistently demonstrated throughout the response", and the 2024 report said to "embed this assessment objective throughout the essay". That was the 2019 descriptor. The 2025 report says "The link between synthesis and evaluation is more explicit", and the 2025 top level names synthesis and justification from religious teachings, not the question.

How do you reach the top of Explaining?

At 5-6 the ISMG asks for:

  • "comprehensive and relevant identification of distinguishing features"
  • "thorough and detailed description of characteristics"
  • "accurate and detailed explanation of the ways in which the two religious traditions are expressed in the lives of adherents"

At 1-2 it is "simplistic identification" and "limited and basic explanation".

Accuracy carries more weight than it did. The 2019 top descriptor tolerated inaccuracies that were "not significant to the response", and the 2023 report described responses that "contained no significant errors or inaccuracies". The 2025 descriptor says "accurate and detailed" with no such allowance. The 2025 report describes a "comprehensive understanding of the beliefs and practices of each religion".

How should you write the IA1 analytical essay?

Communicating is worth 3 marks. At 3 the ISMG asks for:

  • "accurate choice of religious language, logical, cohesive, and succinct development of ideas suitable for the analytical essay genre, including creation of hypothesis"
  • "consistently appropriate application of language conventions"
  • "consistent identification and acknowledgment of sources"

At 1 it is "some use of religious language", "limited application of language conventions" and "limited acknowledgment of sources".

Open with a hypothesis. The 2022 report: "A clear hypothesis provides a focus for the remainder of the response." The 2023 report describes a "clear introduction, body paragraphs and conclusion written in third person", and the 2024 report sets a clear introduction against "a restatement of the question". The 2025 report looks for "a hypothesis used throughout the essay". One loose end: the specification says you respond to "an unseen question or hypothesis", while the ISMG marks "creation of hypothesis", and no QCAA document we hold says how the two fit together when you are given a hypothesis.

Name your sources. Acknowledging sources is new in the 2025 ISMG, and no IA1 report section mentions it. The syllabus gives the form: "identifying sources, e.g. Source 1, Source 3". The IA1 objective says the same: "identifying sources used". This is lighter than the referencing system the Study of Religion IA2 and IA3 investigations require.

Don't chase a flawless script. The 2025 report says "some minor errors in spelling, grammar and punctuation" can still match the top level, as "this does not require an error-free response".

Is there a sample QCAA Study of Religion IA1?

Yes, but it is a sample, not a past paper and not your school's task. QCAA says it "has been compiled by the QCAA to assist and support teachers in planning and developing assessment instruments for individual school settings." Its conditions match the syllabus.

The task is to "construct an analytical essay response that evaluates the significance and influence of religious–ethical stances of Buddhist and Islamic adherents to the social–ethical issue of war". It adds a prompt: "Consider Saul Alinsky's statement that 'in war, the end justifies almost any means' and examine this in reference to the use of chemical agents during the Vietnam War (1955-1975)."

The stimulus has seven sources. Sources 1 to 3 are on chemical agents and napalm in Vietnam. Source 4 is Surah al-Baqarah 2:190-191, Source 5 is Article 2 of the Cairo Declaration, Source 6 is an extract from the Dalai Lama and Source 7 is Dhammapada 129.

The syllabus allows "excerpts from sacred texts and religious writings" as stimulus, and the 2025 report recommends sacred texts and authoritative sources, but not familiar teachings such as "the Ten Commandments or the Noble Eightfold Path", which could lead to "a predetermined or expected response". So expect unfamiliar extracts to work from, not your answer.

The sample is labelled v1.2, two versions behind the current syllabus. Its marking guide matches v1.4.

QCAA Study of Religion IA1 exemplars from the subject reports

Both excerpts are from handwritten responses in the 2025 report, written by a 2019-syllabus cohort. QCAA's comments describe one response each.

Common mistakes in Study of Religion IA1

Writing only about differences. That was the 2023 report's advice under the 2019 descriptor. The 2025 marking guide asks for similarities and differences.

Leaving the stimulus outside the argument. The top of Analysing wants stimulus information "that influence decision-making", and the 2024 report wants it "incorporated into the essay". Use each detail to explain an adherent's response.

Judging the religion. The 2024 report says the task is not about judgments of the religious traditions. Your judgments are about the stances adherents take and how far religion shapes them.

Waiting for the stimulus to give you the teachings. It is written to leave them out, and you have no notes. Revise the teachings of both religions on your issue beforehand.

Restating the question as your introduction. The 2024 report sets a clear introduction against "a restatement of the question", and Communicating marks "creation of hypothesis".

Forgetting to name sources. The top of Communicating asks for "consistent identification and acknowledgment of sources". A label such as Source 3 is enough.

Weak versus strong wording

Every quoted phrase is QCAA's own. The cells describe what the marking guide and reports set apart and are not model sentences. Report comments are on 2019-syllabus cohorts.

WeakerStrongerSource
"focusing on differences, not similarities" (2019-syllabus advice)"must include similarities and differences"2023 report p. 14; 2025 report p. 12
3-4: "selection and use of relevant information from stimulus"7-8: "comprehensive selection and accurate use ... that influence decision-making"Syllabus p. 29
3-4: "partial explanation ... similarities and/or differences"7-8: "detailed and accurate explanation of distinct beliefs and practices"Syllabus p. 29
Judgments "about the religious traditions"Judgments about "the significance of religious–ethical stances ... and its influence on adherents"2024 report p. 10; syllabus p. 30
An introduction that is "a restatement of the question""a hypothesis used throughout the essay"2024 report p. 11; 2025 report p. 12
1-2: "simplistic and/or erroneous judgments"7-8: "discerning judgments and relevant conclusions"Syllabus p. 30

The other supervised paper in the course is the external exam on Unit 4 Topic 2, covered in the QCAA Study of Religion external exam guide.

Practise and get it marked

Practise this IA on AusGrader: sit a prewritten practice IA where your subject has one, or build your own from real QCAA questions, and get it graded against the marking guide with feedback. You can also upload your IA draft for feedback against the ISMG.

Frequently asked questions

How long should a QCE Study of Religion IA1 essay be?

The 2025 syllabus prints no word length for IA1. What it sets is time: 15 minutes of planning and 120 minutes of working time. A word range in older material was written for the 2019 syllabus.

Can you take notes into the Study of Religion IA1?

No. The syllabus says "Students must not bring notes into the examination." The stimulus is unseen and, by design, does not give you religious positions or direct teachings on the issue, so the teachings you use have to come from memory.

Should the Study of Religion IA1 compare similarities or differences?

Both. The 2025 subject report says the word differentiation is gone from the 2025 marking guide and responses "must include similarities and differences." Older advice to focus on differences was written for 2019-syllabus cohorts.

Do you reference the stimulus in the Study of Religion IA1?

Yes. The top Communicating level asks for "consistent identification and acknowledgment of sources", and the syllabus gives the form: "Source 1, Source 3". A full referencing system is not part of the IA1 descriptors.

Will you know the issue before the Study of Religion IA1?

Possibly. The 2024 subject report says "It is not a requirement that the focus of the IA1 be unknown to students." The question or hypothesis and the stimulus are unseen either way.

Sources

  • Study of Religion 2025 v1.4 General senior syllabus, QCAA, March 2026, pp. 20, 27-30, 42. The Unit 3 Topic 1 issue list, the IA1 specification and conditions, the instrument-specific marking guide and the version history.
  • Study of Religion 2025 v1.2 IA1: Sample assessment instrument, QCAA, pp. 1-6. A sample for teachers. The source of the sample task and stimulus described in this guide.
  • Study of Religion 2019 v1.2 General Senior Syllabus, QCAA, November 2019, pp. 23-26. The 2019 IA1 specification and marking guide, used to label which report advice was written against older descriptors.
  • Study of Religion subject report, 2025 cohort, QCAA, January 2026, pp. 9-14. Commentary on a 2019-syllabus cohort, the differences between the 2019 and 2025 IA1 marking guides, and the two excerpts quoted here.
  • Study of Religion subject report, 2024 cohort, QCAA, January 2025, pp. 9-12. Commentary on a 2019-syllabus cohort.
  • Study of Religion subject report, 2023 cohort, QCAA, January 2024, pp. 10-15. Commentary on a 2019-syllabus cohort.
  • Study of Religion subject report, 2022 cohort, QCAA, February 2023, pp. 9-13. Commentary on a 2019-syllabus cohort.

Syllabus and assessment material referenced in this guide is © State of Queensland (Queensland Curriculum and Assessment Authority), licensed under CC BY 4.0. See our QCAA licensing notice. AusGrader is an independent study tool and is not affiliated with, endorsed by, or operated by the QCAA.

Keep reading

Practise what you just read

Work through real QCAA Study of Religion questions and get your written answers marked against the official criteria, instantly.