QCE Modern History

QCAA Modern History IA1 Extended Response: How to Get Top Marks (QCE)

QCAA Modern History IA1 is a supervised essay exam worth 25% of your QCE Modern History result and marked out of 25. In 15 minutes of planning time and 120 minutes of working time, you write a historical argument that answers an unseen question, using evidence from 6 to 7 seen sources you received a week earlier and 3 to 5 unseen ones. Five criteria are worth 5 marks each: Comprehending, Analysing, Evaluating, Synthesising and Communicating.

This guide describes Modern History 2025 v1.4 (March 2026), the current syllabus. IA1 is one of four assessments in QCAA Modern History (QCE), and the QCE Modern History study guide sets all four side by side. The syllabus prints no first-examined year; we read 2026 as the first Year 12 cohort under it. The subject reports quoted here are older. The 2022 to 2025 reports describe cohorts marked under the 2019 syllabus, which split the 25 marks differently and called the last criterion Creating and communicating. No report yet marks a response against the 2025 marking guide, so every report quote is labelled by year.

What is the QCAA Modern History IA1?

Weighting25%
Marked out of25
TopicA Unit 3 topic, national experiences in the Modern World
ResponseAn essay in response to historical sources, answering an unseen question
Stimulus6 to 7 seen sources and 3 to 5 unseen sources
Seen sourcesGiven one week before, with no teacher help to interrogate them
Planning time15 minutes
Working time120 minutes
NotesStudents "must not take notes"
LengthNone set
Individual or group"individual supervised task"

The syllabus describes the task like this: "Students write an essay in response to historical sources that requires them to create a historical argument that responds to an unseen question, using evidence from historical sources included in the stimulus."

It assesses objectives 2 to 6, "focused on national experiences in the Modern World". That is Unit 3, which lists 13 topics; your school studies two. IA2 then uses a Unit 3 area "not previously assessed in IA1", which the QCAA Modern History IA2 and IA3 guide covers.

There is no length to aim for. The conditions print none, and the 2025 report says "A required or recommended word length must not appear on IA1 instruments."

What sources and question do you get in the Modern History IA1?

Each source carries "separate and distinct context statements", and the whole stimulus must be "succinct enough to be engaged with during the planning time".

The reports also give schools advice on building the task, which tells you what to expect:

  • A range of sources. The 2022 and 2024 reports ask for one.
  • Short sources. The 2022, 2024 and 2025 reports ask for a succinct stimulus.
  • A narrow question. The 2022, 2023 and 2025 reports suggest narrowing the unseen question, for example to a person or a timeframe (the 2025 report adds an idea).
  • Help with language. Reports ask schools to translate non-English words and define esoteric ones.

Use the week well. You can't take notes in, so the week is for knowing each seen source: who made it, when, where and why. The 2024 report frames reliability through those who, what, why, where and when questions. Usefulness has to wait for the question. The 2022 report says usefulness "considers the relevance of evidence from sources for a particular investigation", and you only learn the investigation on the day.

What does the IA1 essay need to include?

The syllabus lists the features of an essay in response to historical sources:

  • "an introduction (which sets context and includes a hypothesis and outline of the historical argument)"
  • "body paragraphs with topic sentences"
  • "a conclusion (which draws together the main ideas and the historical argument)"
  • "ethical scholarship in the form of noting, e.g. the source number, author, title and/or combination of these or similar approaches."

Communicating marks the set. Its 4-5 descriptors include "clearly and purposefully", "all features of an essay in response to historical sources are consistently applied" and "minimal errors in spelling, grammar and punctuation". At 2-3 it accepts "most features" and "some errors". At 1 the features are "inconsistently applied" and "frequent errors ... impede the communication of ideas".

The 2022, 2023 and 2025 reports come back to all the features. The 2025 report describes a response in which "the introduction set the context and included a hypothesis and an outline of the argument".

Referencing. The 2023 report lists acceptable approaches: "source numbers, the names of sources’ authors ..., titles of sources, or a combination". The 2022 report says the same. On a full referencing system, the 2025 report says: "This approach, which was less common, is acceptable but is not mandated."

Succinct or clear? The 2022 and 2024 reports read the top level as "brevity and clarity", and the 2024 report adds "the absence of repetition". Those cohorts were marked against a 2019 top descriptor that began "succinct". The 2025 descriptor says "clearly and purposefully" instead.

How is Modern History IA1 marked?

The instrument-specific marking guide (ISMG) is printed in the syllabus. It has five criteria, each worth 5 marks, for a total of 25.

CriterionMarksHow the levels run
Comprehending5Ranges: 4-5, 2-3, 1
Analysing5One descriptor per mark, 5 to 1
Evaluating5One descriptor per mark, 5 to 1
Synthesising5One descriptor per mark, 5 to 1
Communicating5Ranges: 4-5, 2-3, 1

In every criterion, 0 means "The student response does not match any of the descriptors above."

How do you reach the top of Evaluating in Modern History IA1?

Evaluating climbs one word at a time. At 5 the ISMG asks for "discerning and well-reasoned judgments about the usefulness and/or reliability of evidence from historical sources in the stimulus". At 4 the judgments are "effective", at 3 "adequate", at 2 "superficial", and at 1 "irrelevant or inaccurate judgments".

Give the reason. The 2023 report draws the line: "Judgments explain the usefulness and/or reliability of evidence from sources (e.g. ‘The evidence from this source is reliable because …’). Statements provide only an assertion ... (e.g. ‘The evidence from this source is reliable’)." The 2022 report makes the same distinction. Both described 2019-syllabus marking, where the criterion assessed judgments and statements. The 2025 report says the current criterion "assesses judgments, rather than judgments and statement/s", so a bare assertion has no level of its own now. The lowest levels are for judgments "characterised as superficial, irrelevant or inaccurate".

Make more than one. The 2024 and 2025 reports point out that the upper and mid levels ask for "judgments (plural) about the usefulness and/or reliability".

Keep usefulness, reliability and analysis apart. The 2022 report defines usefulness as considering "the relevance of evidence from sources for a particular investigation", and analysis as "the unpacking of evidence". The 2024 report frames reliability with who, what, why, where and when questions. Describing what a source shows is analysis. Saying how far it helps answer this question is a usefulness judgment.

Corroboration is not required now. The 2023 report expected judgments "corroborated at the upper and mid performance levels", saying how other sources "support or contradict" them. That was a 2019-syllabus cohort. The 2025 report says the 2025 criterion "does not require these judgments to be corroborated".

How do you reach the top of Analysing?

At 5 the ISMG asks for "discerning selection and detailed examination of features of evidence from historical sources". At 4 the examination is "effective" and at 3 "adequate". At 2 it is "identification of features of evidence", and at 1 "identification of a feature of evidence".

Examine more than one feature, not every feature. The 2024 report says the upper and mid levels "can be achieved by identifying and examining two of the features of evidence". The 2022 report says "not all features ... were required". The 2023 and 2025 reports make the same point.

Draw on a range. The 2023 report describes the top Analysing level using "primary and secondary sources; written and visual sources; and/or sources that reflect different perspectives". The 2025 report says the same. The current Analysing descriptor says only "historical sources"; the word "range" sits in Synthesising, which asks for evidence "from a range of historical sources".

What "discerning" meant to older reports. The 2022 report read it as features "purposefully selected" that "clearly advanced the development of the focus of a paragraph and/or the hypothesis". The 2023 report says the features were "especially relevant for developing a hypothesis". The 2019 descriptor they applied included an "informed explanation about how evidence ... contributes to the development of the hypothesis". The 2025 descriptor drops that clause and says "discerning selection".

How do you reach the top of Synthesising?

At 5 the ISMG asks for a "sophisticated historical argument that skilfully combines evidence from a range of historical sources to justify decisions". At 4 the argument is "effective". At 3 it is a "basic historical argument ... to support decisions". At 2 it is "superficial", and at 1 "superficial ... or non-historical argument that refers to evidence from sources".

Only the 2025 report comments on IA1 Synthesising. It reads "sophisticated" as intellectual complexity: an argument that is "multifaceted and/or multilayered", with "considered refutation or reconciliation of contradictory or otherwise problematic evidence". A source that cuts against your hypothesis is something to refute or reconcile, so build it into the argument.

What does Comprehending reward in Modern History IA1?

At 4-5 the ISMG asks for "thorough and mostly accurate use of terms in historical context", "informed understanding of concepts related to the unseen question" and "detailed explanation of issues related to the unseen question". At 2-3 these become "appropriate", "reasonable" and "adequate". At 1 it is "partial and/or inaccurate use of terms" and "superficial understanding of concepts".

Place terms in time and place. The 2022 report wants terms linked "to specific times, places, and/or spaces related to the focus of the unseen question". Each report from 2022 to 2025 names an example: the Red Guards (2022), the Mukden Incident (2023), Billy Hughes (2024) and Father Adrian Tourchinsky (2025).

Explain the issues the question raises. The 2024 report describes a question "addressed by focusing on issues associated with the emergence of the Cold War in Asia". The 2022 and 2023 reports make the same point.

Concepts. The 2022 and 2023 reports looked for an understanding of "the relationship between concepts and ideas", following the 2019 descriptor ("a variety of ideas"). The 2025 descriptor asks for "concepts related to the unseen question".

Is there a sample QCAA Modern History IA1?

Yes, but it is a sample, not a past paper and not your school's task. QCAA says "This sample has been compiled by the QCAA to assist and support teachers in planning and developing assessment instruments for individual school settings."

It is set on "Topic 5: Germany since 1914 (World War I begins)", with 15 minutes of planning time, 120 minutes of working time, and 6 to 7 seen and 3 to 5 unseen sources. It tells students the degree to which the National Socialist Party wanted German women to become mothers "is contested", then asks:

"To what extent did the National Socialist Party want German women to become mothers during the Third Reich?"

Students answer with "the sources provided and your own historical knowledge and understanding of the Third Reich in Germany", and the task lists the essay features above. Each source carries a "Reference" and a "Context statement". The sample is labelled v1.2; the current syllabus is v1.4. Its criteria, marks and descriptors match v1.4.

QCAA Modern History IA1 exemplars from the subject reports

Both excerpts come from the 2025 report and are about Franklin D. Roosevelt. They are transcribed from handwritten work, no mark is printed, and they were written under the 2019 syllabus.

How did Modern History IA1 marks hold up at confirmation?

Confirmation is QCAA checking your school's marking afterwards. Each report publishes how often the confirmed mark agreed with the school's provisional mark. These are 2019-syllabus cohorts and 2019 criteria, and the figures measure how hard a criterion is to mark, not how well students did.

Evaluating2022202320242025
Agreement (%)85.2290.1592.9092.88
Confirmed below provisional (%)11.327.387.107.12

In each of those four years, Evaluating had the lowest agreement of the IA1 criteria and the highest share of marks lowered. For the wider process, see the QCE internal assessments guide.

Common mistakes in Modern History IA1

Calling a source reliable and stopping. The 2023 report's example of an assertion is "The evidence from this source is reliable". Finish the sentence with "because" and a reason tied to this source.

Writing up one feature of a source. The bottom of Analysing is "identification of a feature of evidence". The 2024 report says two features examined can reach the upper and mid levels.

Describing a source and calling it evaluation. The 2022 report separates analysis, "the unpacking of evidence", from usefulness, which is relevance "for a particular investigation". Make the judgment explicit.

Dropping a feature of the essay. Communicating at 4-5 wants all features "consistently applied". Check your introduction sets context, states a hypothesis and outlines the argument.

Leaving terms floating. The 2022 report wants terms linked to specific times and places. Give each name or event its date and setting.

Letting errors pile up. The 2022 report describes "frequent errors in spelling, grammar and punctuation that impeded the communication of ideas", which is the wording of the lowest Communicating level.

Weak versus strong wording

The first row is a report-written example; the rest set the ISMG's own descriptors side by side. Report comments are on 2019-syllabus cohorts.

CriterionWeakerStrongerSource
Evaluating"The evidence from this source is reliable""The evidence from this source is reliable because …"2023 report p. 14
Evaluating"superficial judgments" (2) or "irrelevant or inaccurate judgments" (1)"discerning and well-reasoned judgments" (5)Syllabus p. 29
Analysing"identification of features of evidence" (2)"discerning selection and detailed examination of features" (5)Syllabus p. 29
Comprehending"partial and/or inaccurate use of terms" (1)"thorough and mostly accurate use of terms in historical context" (4-5)Syllabus p. 29
Synthesising"superficial historical argument" (2)"sophisticated historical argument that skilfully combines evidence from a range of historical sources to justify decisions" (5)Syllabus p. 30

Frequently asked questions

Can you take notes into the QCE Modern History IA1?

No. The syllabus says students "must not take notes". You receive the 6 to 7 seen sources one week before the exam, and your teacher does not help you interrogate them. The 3 to 5 unseen sources and the question are new on the day.

Is there a word limit for the Modern History IA1 essay?

No. The 2025 syllabus conditions state no length, and the 2025 subject report says "A required or recommended word length must not appear on IA1 instruments." You have 15 minutes of planning time and 120 minutes of working time.

How do you reference sources in the Modern History IA1?

The syllabus calls it ethical scholarship: noting the source number, author, title or a combination. The 2025 report says a recognised referencing system "is acceptable but is not mandated".

Do you need to corroborate sources in Modern History IA1?

Not under the 2025 syllabus. The 2025 subject report says the Evaluating criterion "does not require these judgments to be corroborated". The 2023 report expected corroboration, but it was describing a cohort marked under the 2019 syllabus.

Why do older QCAA reports give different marks for the Modern History IA1 criteria?

The 2022 to 2025 reports describe 2019-syllabus cohorts, marked on Comprehending 6, Analysing 4, Synthesising 4, Evaluating 6 and Creating and communicating 5. Under the 2025 syllabus all five criteria are worth 5, and the last is called Communicating.

Sources

  • Modern History 2025 v1.4 General senior syllabus, QCAA, March 2026, pp. 11, 22, 27-30. The features of an essay in response to historical sources, Unit 3 topics, the IA1 specification and conditions, and the instrument-specific marking guide.
  • Modern History 2025 v1.2 IA1: Sample assessment instrument, QCAA, pp. 1-12. A sample for teachers. The source of the sample task described in this guide.
  • Modern History 2019 v1.2 General Senior Syllabus, QCAA, pp. 65-67. The 2019 IA1 marking guide, used to label which report advice was written against older descriptors.
  • Modern History subject report, 2025 cohort, QCAA, January 2026, pp. 9-14. Commentary on a 2019-syllabus cohort, the differences between the 2019 and 2025 marking guides, confirmation figures and the excerpts quoted in this guide.
  • Modern History subject report, 2024 cohort, QCAA, January 2025, pp. 9-13. Commentary on a 2019-syllabus cohort and confirmation figures.
  • Modern History subject report, 2023 cohort, QCAA, January 2024, pp. 11-14. Commentary on a 2019-syllabus cohort and confirmation figures.
  • Modern History subject report, 2022 cohort, QCAA, February 2023, pp. 10-14. Commentary on a 2019-syllabus cohort and confirmation figures.

Syllabus and assessment material referenced in this guide is © State of Queensland (Queensland Curriculum and Assessment Authority), licensed under CC BY 4.0. See our QCAA licensing notice. AusGrader is an independent study tool and is not affiliated with, endorsed by, or operated by the QCAA.

Keep reading

Practise what you just read

Work through real QCAA Modern History questions and get your written answers marked against the official criteria, instantly.