QCAA Marine Science Managing fisheries
15 sample questions with marking guides and sample answers
Explain the need for agreements to manage migratory species in international waters.
Reveal Answer
International waters are freely accessed by different nations. Species that migrate through these areas are at risk due to the different management strategies of each nation.
To accommodate this, international agreements exist to protect migratory species.
| Descriptor | Marks |
|---|---|
explains that international waters have no restrictions | 1 |
explains that countries have different ways to manage migratory species | 1 |
explains why international agreements are needed | 1 |
The stock of a wild migratory Australian fish species needs sustainable management before being used as a commercial resource. However, there is little scientific data about the species' behaviours and distribution.
Explain how the precautionary principle applies to this situation.
Reveal Answer
The precautionary principle involves exercising caution in management decisions and helps to ensure no unnecessary or unwanted effects on the environment.
| Descriptor | Marks |
|---|---|
explains the precautionary principle | 1 |
Explain one management technique that should be implemented to prevent overexploitation of this resource.
Reveal Answer
E-monitoring as part of dynamic spatial zoning is a management technique that should be implemented since the fish species is migratory. E-monitoring is used to monitor species numbers and behaviours and involves sensors and video cameras capable of monitoring and recording fishing activities.
| Descriptor | Marks |
|---|---|
identifies a management technique | 1 |
explains the management technique | 1 |
Barramundi are a relatively difficult fish to breed. Fish that are less than 150 mm total length will cannibalise smaller fish up to 67% of their own length. Despite these challenges, barramundi remain a popular aquaculture species.
Identify two attributes of barramundi that make them desirable to farm.
Reveal Answer
- fast growth rate
- good market value
| Descriptor | Marks |
|---|---|
identifies an attribute of barramundi | 1 |
identifies a second attribute of barramundi | 1 |
Infer how cannibalism in barramundi can be reduced. Show your reasoning.
Reveal Answer
Cannibalism can be reduced by regularly sizing fish to keep fish of the same size together. By reducing the size difference in fish kept together, cannibalism would be reduced, as barramundi only eat fish up to 67% of their own length.
| Descriptor | Marks |
|---|---|
infers a method for reducing cannibalism | 1 |
provides reasoning | 1 |
The three main types of fisheries are
surf, estuarine and reef.
trawler, pot and long line.
wild caught, sea cage and pond.
artisanal, recreational and commercial.
Reveal Answer
surf, estuarine and reef.
Incorrect. These terms describe specific marine habitats or environments where fishing takes place, rather than the overarching categories of fisheries.
trawler, pot and long line.
Incorrect. These are specific types of fishing gear or methods used to catch fish, not the main classifications of the fisheries themselves.
wild caught, sea cage and pond.
Incorrect. These terms describe production methods, specifically distinguishing between wild-capture fisheries and different types of aquaculture.
artisanal, recreational and commercial.
Correct. Fisheries are primarily classified by their socio-economic purpose and scale into artisanal (small-scale or subsistence), recreational (for sport), and commercial (for profit).
Thermal habitat preferences are derived from a species' satellite data and real-time bycatch occurrences. When the species bycatch limit is reached in a season, it triggers the closure of a section of the associated fishery. This closure is an example of
dynamic spatial zoning.
controlling target catch.
the precautionary principle.
monitoring effort allocation.
Reveal Answer
dynamic spatial zoning.
Dynamic spatial zoning involves adjusting management boundaries in real-time based on environmental data and species occurrences, such as closing a fishery section to reduce bycatch.
controlling target catch.
The scenario describes a management action triggered by a bycatch limit (unintended catch), rather than controlling the primary target catch of the fishery.
the precautionary principle.
The precautionary principle involves taking protective action in the absence of complete scientific certainty, whereas this closure is a specific action based on concrete, real-time data thresholds.
monitoring effort allocation.
While monitoring is part of the process, the actual closure of a fishery section is an active spatial management strategy (zoning), not merely the monitoring of fishing effort.
Identify two attributes of an aquaculture species that would make it desirable to farm.
Reveal Answer
Resilience to disease
Fast growth rate
| Descriptor | Marks |
|---|---|
identifies 2 attributes | 2 |
identifies 1 attribute | 1 |
does not satisfy any of the descriptors above. | 0 |
Contrast open and closed aquaculture systems in terms of output pollution.
Reveal Answer
Open systems involve the accumulation of waste or the removal of waste via natural processes.
Closed systems involve significant water treatment before release into the environment.
| Descriptor | Marks |
|---|---|
identifies that waste is accumulated or removed via natural processes in open systems | 1 |
identifies that waste is removed via water-treatment processes in closed systems before being released into the environment | 1 |
Describe the impact of water quality on the carrying capacity of an aquaculture system.
Reveal Answer
If the water in a system is not treated, controlled or removed, water quality will reduce carrying capacity.
| Descriptor | Marks |
|---|---|
describes how decrease in water quality would lead to a decrease in carrying capacity | 1 |
Predict which farming technique (open or closed) is likely to support a higher stocking density. Explain your reasoning.
Reveal Answer
Closed systems support higher stocking density than open systems.
Closed systems have greater control over water quality and feed inputs.
| Descriptor | Marks |
|---|---|
predicts that closed systems can support a higher stocking density than open systems | 1 |
indicates that higher stocking density is possible because water quality can be controlled | 1 |
'Wild-caught fish are the most important single source of high quality animal protein globally.'
What is the main consequence of this statement for the targeted fish species stock?
average fish size decreases
quotas become enforceable
reproductive rate increases
stock spatial distribution changes
Reveal Answer
average fish size decreases
High global demand leads to heavy fishing pressure, which typically targets the largest fish first. Over time, this selective harvesting results in a significant decrease in the average size of the remaining fish in the population.
quotas become enforceable
High demand and economic value actually make fishing quotas more difficult to enforce, as they increase the financial incentives for illegal, unreported, and unregulated fishing.
reproductive rate increases
Intense fishing pressure often removes the largest, most fecund individuals (often older females), which typically decreases the overall reproductive capacity and success of the stock rather than increasing it.
stock spatial distribution changes
While spatial distribution can change due to environmental factors like climate change, the most direct and primary consequence of intense harvesting on the stock itself is the reduction in population size and average individual size.
Which option is a major Australian edible seafood import product?
prawns
abalone
fish meal
rock lobster
Reveal Answer
prawns
Australia imports a large volume of prawns, primarily from Southeast Asian countries, to meet high domestic consumer demand that exceeds local production.
abalone
Australia is actually one of the world's largest producers and exporters of wild-caught abalone, rather than a major importer.
fish meal
While imported, fish meal is primarily used for agricultural and aquaculture feed, not as an edible seafood product for human consumption.
rock lobster
Rock lobster is one of Australia's most valuable seafood exports, heavily exported to international markets rather than imported.
Identify three differences between intensive and extensive aquaculture systems.
Reveal Answer
Extensive aquaculture requires lower levels of management than intensive.
Extensive uses lower stocking densities than intensive.
Extensive has lower yields than intensive.
| Descriptor | Marks |
|---|---|
provides one difference | 1 |
provides a second difference | 1 |
provides a third difference | 1 |
Which type of fishery is most likely to be a food source for small communities from developing nations?
trawling
artisanal
commercial
recreational
Reveal Answer
trawling
Incorrect. Trawling is an industrial fishing method requiring expensive vessels and massive nets, making it inaccessible and impractical for small, low-income communities.
artisanal
Correct. Artisanal fisheries are small-scale, traditional, and low-technology operations that primarily provide subsistence and local income for communities in developing nations.
commercial
Incorrect. Commercial fisheries operate on a massive scale for global or national profit, requiring significant capital investment that small communities typically lack.
recreational
Incorrect. Recreational fishing is done for sport or leisure rather than survival, whereas small communities in developing nations rely on fishing for essential sustenance.
Fisheries that are managed using fixed quotas are controlled by
electronic monitoring.
dynamic spatial zoning.
setting a total allowable catch.
limiting effort to maximise profit.
Reveal Answer
electronic monitoring.
Electronic monitoring is an enforcement tool used to ensure compliance with regulations, rather than the management mechanism that defines a fixed quota.
dynamic spatial zoning.
Dynamic spatial zoning involves managing where fishing can occur by opening and closing specific areas, which is different from setting a fixed catch limit.
setting a total allowable catch.
Fixed quota management systems operate by setting a Total Allowable Catch (TAC), which is a hard limit on the total amount of fish that can be harvested.
limiting effort to maximise profit.
Limiting effort (such as restricting the number of boats or days at sea) is an input control, whereas fixed quotas are output controls based on catch limits.
Identify a factor that reduces the capacity for aquaculture to address food security in developing countries.
Reveal Answer
Developing countries have limited access to technologies suitable to support aquaculture.
| Descriptor | Marks |
|---|---|
identifies a factor | 1 |
What is a limitation of using spatial movement to determine fisheries population data?
It is dynamic and unpredictable.
It relies on visual census methods.
It is limited to non-migratory species.
It is reliant on abiotic factors such as temperature.
Reveal Answer
It is dynamic and unpredictable.
Fish populations are highly mobile, and their spatial movement patterns constantly change due to various environmental and biological factors, making it difficult to accurately estimate population sizes.
It relies on visual census methods.
Tracking spatial movement does not rely solely on visual census; it frequently utilizes advanced technologies like acoustic telemetry, satellite tagging, and mark-recapture methods.
It is limited to non-migratory species.
Spatial movement tracking is actually widely used for highly migratory species to understand their complex travel routes and seasonal distributions.
It is reliant on abiotic factors such as temperature.
While abiotic factors like temperature do influence fish movement, the primary limitation of the method is the overall unpredictability of these dynamic shifts, rather than the reliance on the factors themselves.
The precautionary principle should be applied to ecosystem management decisions when
there is strong evidence to support the decision.
a decision results in a long-term, negative impact on habitat.
there is limited scientific knowledge on the impact of a threat.
all other ecosystem management strategies have been exhausted.
Reveal Answer
there is strong evidence to support the decision.
If there is strong evidence to support a decision, standard evidence-based management applies rather than the precautionary principle, which is used when evidence is lacking.
a decision results in a long-term, negative impact on habitat.
If a decision is known to result in a long-term negative impact, it should simply be avoided. The precautionary principle applies when the outcome is uncertain, not when harm is guaranteed.
there is limited scientific knowledge on the impact of a threat.
The precautionary principle states that when an activity raises threats of harm to the environment, precautionary measures should be taken even if some cause and effect relationships are not fully established scientifically.
all other ecosystem management strategies have been exhausted.
The precautionary principle is a proactive, guiding philosophy for initial decision-making, not a last resort to be used only after other strategies have failed.
Explain low feed conversion ratio and why it is a desirable attribute for an aquaculture species.
Reveal Answer
The feed conversion ratio of a species is the feed requirement per unit of body weight gain. A low feed conversion ratio means that less food is required to produce a marketable fish and so the product costs less to grow.
| Descriptor | Marks |
|---|---|
explains the low feed conversion ratio | 1 |
explains the lower cost of production | 1 |