QCAA Engineering IA1 and IA3 Engineered Solution: How to Get Top Marks (QCE)
QCAA Engineering IA1 and IA3 are both Engineered solution tasks, each worth 25% of your QCE Engineering result and marked out of 25. You work individually and document how you applied the problem-solving process to a real-world-related problem, in up to 10 A4 pages and up to 2000 words. IA1 covers structures in Unit 3. IA3 covers machines and/or mechanisms in Unit 4 and must include logic control technology.
This guide describes Engineering 2025 v1.4 (March 2026), and the 2026 Year 12 cohort is the first assessed under it. Both tasks sit in QCAA Engineering (QCE), and the subject page has the overview of all four assessments. The marking rules below are current. The commentary is older: the 2023, 2024 and 2025 subject reports all describe 2019-syllabus cohorts, and the first report on current rules is the 2026 cohort's. The 2025 report does add advice on the 2025 syllabus. Report quotes here are labelled by year and task so you can see what each one covers.
What is the QCAA Engineering Engineered solution?
These conditions are the same for IA1 and IA3.
| Weighting | 25% each |
| Marked out of | 25 |
| Length | Up to 10 A4 pages, up to 2000 words |
| Response | Written and visual, "including images, graphs, calculations and diagrams" |
| Class time | "approximately 10 hours" |
| Where you work | "in class time and their own time" |
| Individual or group | "This is an individual task." |
The syllabus describes the task this way: "Students document the application of the problem-solving process in response to an identified real-world-related problem that requires an engineered solution." Your teacher provides the problem context.
The IA1 specification includes these items:
- "test of materials and processes"
- "calculate using mechanics concepts and principles to propose prototype and real-world solution performance"
- "annotations on photographs or screen captures of the prototype solution prior to and after testing"
- "destructive or non-destructive testing"
The syllabus process has "four phases of Explore, Develop, Generate, and Evaluate and refine". These tasks assess objectives 2, 4, 5, 6, 7 and 8 only. The 2025 report's advice says: "Objectives 1 and 3 are not assessed in IA1 in the 2025 syllabus, so students are not required to document the explore phase."
How do IA1 and IA3 differ?
| IA1 | IA3 | |
|---|---|---|
| Unit | Unit 3 | Unit 4 |
| You explain ideas and a solution "in relation to" | "structures" | "machines and/or mechanisms" |
| The problem requires | "an engineered solution" | an engineered solution "that includes logic control technology" |
| Context your teacher provides | Structural problem | Machine and/or mechanism problem |
| Subject matter the syllabus names | "complex open-ended structural problem involving truss structures", "method of joints and method of sections" | "Apply logic control, including logic gates AND/OR/NOT/NAND/NOR/XOR", "truth tables" |
| Synthesis knowledge | "engineering mechanics", "materials science", "technology", "research information" | The same list plus "control technologies" |
| Recommendations are | "for enhancements" | "for modifications" |
| Synthesis at 4-5 marks | "simple synthesis to predict" | "simple synthesis to propose" |
Other bands match apart from the subject wording, so the marking section below applies to both tasks. The topic pages cover civil engineering materials and machines, mechanisms and control.
How is the Engineered solution marked?
The instrument-specific marking guide (ISMG) is printed in the syllabus, with one for each task. Each has three criteria and 25 marks. A 0 means the response "does not match any of the descriptors above".
| Criterion | Objectives | Marks |
|---|---|---|
| Symbolising and Communicating | 2, 8 | 7 |
| Determining and Generating | 4, 6 | 9 |
| Synthesising and Evaluating | 5, 7 | 9 |
The wording below is from the IA1 ISMG. IA3 swaps "structures" and "structural" for "machines and/or mechanisms".
Symbolising and Communicating, 7 marks.
| Marks | ISMG wording |
|---|---|
| 6-7 | "adept symbolisation and discerning explanation of ideas and a solution"; "discerning decision-making about, and proficient use of" written and visual features |
| 4-5 | "effective symbolisation and considered explanation"; "fluent use of" |
| 2-3 | "competent symbolisation and appropriate explanation of some ideas"; "suitable language" |
| 1 | "inconsistent symbolisation or superficial explanation" |
At 6-7 the symbolisation uses sketches and drawings, tables and graphs, and diagrams and/or schemas. The written side covers "language for a technical audience", "grammatically accurate language structures" and "referencing conventions".
Determining and Generating, 9 marks.
| Marks | ISMG wording |
|---|---|
| 8-9 | "astute determination of essential success criteria"; "proficient generation of a structural prototype solution"; "provide valid performance data to critically determine the feasibility of the structural real-world solution" |
| 6-7 | "reasoned determination of effective success criteria"; "effective generation" |
| 4-5 | "logical determination of appropriate success criteria"; "adequate generation"; "relevant performance data" |
| 2-3 | "reasonable determination of some success criteria"; "partial generation"; "provide elements of performance data to partially determine the feasibility" |
| 1 | "statements about some success criteria"; "generation of elements of a structural prototype solution." |
Synthesising and Evaluating, 9 marks.
| Marks | ISMG wording |
|---|---|
| 8-9 | "coherent and logical synthesis"; "critical evaluation of ideas and a solution using success criteria"; "discerning refinement of a solution using success criteria to make astute recommendations for enhancements justified by data and research evidence" |
| 6-7 | "logical synthesis"; "reasoned evaluation"; "considered recommendations" |
| 4-5 | "simple synthesis to predict a possible structural solution"; "fundamental recommendations" |
| 2-3 | "rudimentary synthesis"; "superficial evaluation"; "elementary recommendations" |
| 1 | "unclear combinations of information or ideas"; "identification of a change about an idea or the solution." |
How do you determine success criteria?
The Determining half of the Determining and Generating criterion marks your success criteria. The 2025 report explains it as how well students "considered the information from the explore phase (prior to assessment) to ascertain which needs, constraints or requirements will be most essential".
The reports raise success criteria for every cohort we hold:
- 2023, IA1: "determining solution success criteria that are focused primarily on the most important and relevant, measurable characteristics of the real-world solution".
- 2024, IA1: "extending beyond the parameters stated in the assessment instrument", with "measurable attributes in relation to loading and dimensions".
- 2024, IA3: criteria "must have been derived from the exploration of the problem and extend beyond the information that has been provided in the assessment instrument".
- 2025, IA3: "for astute determination of essential success criteria, student responses must go beyond statements made in the task context and specifications".
So check each criterion against your task sheet. If it only repeats the task sheet, it needs more. Then check that you can measure it, because your prototype data gets compared against it.
What should your prototype data do?
The syllabus says "The generate phase involves students producing a prototype that, when tested, provides data to determine the feasibility of the real-world-related solution." Your prototype is there to produce evidence about the real-world solution.
The 2025 report says Generating looks at "the quality of the production of their prototype and how useful it is in producing valid performance data when tested". You then use that data "to decide if elements of the solution are capable of being realised, including comparing the data to the measurable attributes of the success criteria".
Two report comments show what that looked like:
- 2024, IA1: a prototype that "produced legitimate and defensible performance data to determine whether or not the proposed real-world solution would be fit for the intended purpose".
- 2025, IA3: "prototype testing that enabled measurable data to be analysed and used to critically assess the real-world solution".
On scale, the 2025 report's advice for both tasks says: "When including a virtual prototype, use a 1:1 scale."
What do evaluation and recommendations need?
Evaluation in the 8-9 band uses your success criteria, and recommendations are "justified by data and research evidence". The syllabus's evaluate and refine phase includes "resolve uncertainties to refine the prototype solution" and "make and justify recommendations to modify real-world-related solution performance."
The 2023 report (IA1) describes evaluation as "weighing up the merit or worth of ideas and a solution against the solution success criteria and the data obtained from the testing of the prototype". The 2025 report (IA1) says: "Enhancements that could be made to the solution as a result of the evaluation are recommended in the student response and are supported by the result of testing the prototype and research."
The 2025 report treats justified recommendations for the real-world solution as a requirement of both tasks. In IA1 the ISMG calls them enhancements, and in IA3 it calls them modifications.
For IA3, the synthesis criterion adds "control technologies" and the 2025 report notes: "Synthesising includes control technologies."
What should your drawings show?
The 2024 report describes the drawings in responses to each task, under the 2019 syllabus.
- IA1: "engineering drawings that facilitate the production of the prototype solution", with "correct use of layout, dimensioning and labelling conventions, aligned to Australian standards". It also names "free-body diagrams, shear force and bending moment diagrams".
- IA3: "third angle projection with correct labelling and dimensioning conventions", plus "logic circuit diagrams and truth tables".
How do you stay within 2000 words?
The 2025 report's IA1 advice has two specific comments:
- "Annotations on sketches and diagrams should be targeted and brief to ensure the Engineered solution is within the word limit".
- "Calculations conducted on content outside Unit 3 may hinder students' ability to adhere to the task-length specifications".
It also says of one stress-formula text box that it "would be counted in the word length." For IA3, the report says the ISMG "assesses the objectives using Unit 4 subject matter".
The QCAA sample tasks
QCAA publishes one sample for each task: "This sample has been compiled by the QCAA to assist and support teachers in planning and developing assessment instruments for individual school settings." You won't sit either one, but they show how the specification becomes a task.
IA1 sample: a cantilever sign gantry. The sample is a truss-type gantry for a sign "with a mass of 200 kg", "at least 6.5 m above the roadway", in Wind Region B ("51.9 m/s"), with "a 1.5 factor of safety loading as judged using the beam performance index". The prototype can be virtual or physical. A physical one uses "balsa wood", with the sign's weight force and the factor of safety loading "each scaled to 1:20". The sample also says "Detailed calculations of the torsional forces resisted by the structure are not required."
IA3 sample: a glass jar distribution system. A food processor is adding a new production line "1.5 m above the existing production line". The task is a mechanism that evenly distributes jars from the jar-feeder line to each line and raises them 1.5 m to the new one. Jars are "either round or hexagonal", the round jar has a 75 mm outside diameter, and the sample uses "a scale of 1:1 for virtual prototypes and 1:10 for physical prototypes". The task asks for an engineered solution "using logic control technology".
Both samples set a checkpoint: "Submit a draft demonstrating success criteria determined from the problem, the development of ideas and an indication of a proposed solution". IA1 sets it for "Term 1 Week 7" and IA3 for "Term 3 Week 3". Both also ask for "a declaration of authenticity", "a table of contents" and "a reference list and a recognised system of in-text referencing."
Those dates, scales and requirements are the samples' choices. Your school's task sheet sets yours.
The 2025 report's IA3 commentary also has advice for schools writing task sheets: "Design syllabus language, such as 'design' or 'folio' is not appropriate". The syllabus name for this task is Engineered solution, so use that name.
QCAA Engineering IA1 and IA3 exemplars from the subject reports
The reports reproduce student excerpts with captions. All of them come from 2019-syllabus cohorts, including the 2025 report's. We quote the captions, so go to the report for the work itself.
Common mistakes in Engineering IA1 and IA3
Restating the task sheet as success criteria. The 2025 report's IA3 commentary says astute criteria "must go beyond statements made in the task context and specifications". Derive yours from the problem, and make them measurable.
Testing a prototype that can't support a decision. The 8-9 band needs "valid performance data to critically determine the feasibility" of the real-world solution. Before you test, work out which success criterion each measurement will be compared against.
Evaluating without the data. The 8-9 band asks for evaluation "using success criteria", and recommendations "justified by data and research evidence". Go back to your test results and your research for each judgment and each recommendation.
Going over length on annotations or out-of-unit calculations. The 2025 report's IA1 advice warns about both, as covered above. Keep annotations "targeted and brief" and keep calculations on the unit being assessed.
Leaving control out of IA3. The 2025 report says "logic control technology must be included in the engineered solution". Show it in the solution itself, and synthesise control technologies with your other knowledge.
Weak versus strong wording
Every quoted phrase is from the IA1 ISMG, and the numbers in brackets are the band.
| Aspect | Weaker | Stronger |
|---|---|---|
| Success criteria | "statements about some success criteria" (1) | "astute determination of essential success criteria" (8-9) |
| Prototype data | "elements of performance data to partially determine the feasibility" (2-3) | "valid performance data to critically determine the feasibility" (8-9) |
| Evaluation and recommendations | "superficial evaluation"; "elementary recommendations" (2-3) | "critical evaluation of ideas and a solution using success criteria"; "astute recommendations" (8-9) |
Before you submit
- Is your response within 10 A4 pages and 2000 words?
- Does your solution match the unit: structures for IA1, machines and/or mechanisms with logic control technology for IA3?
- Does each success criterion go beyond your task sheet, and can you measure it?
- Does your prototype data let you decide whether the real-world solution is feasible?
- Have you compared your test data to the measurable attributes in your success criteria?
- Does your evaluation use the success criteria?
- Is every recommendation for the real-world solution justified by data and research evidence?
- Are your annotations targeted and brief?
- Do your calculations stay on the unit being assessed?
- If you included a virtual prototype, is it at 1:1?
- Have you followed referencing conventions?
The Engineering formula sheet guide covers the formula book, which the syllabus names only for IA2 and the external assessment. For how internal assessment works across the certificate, see the QCE internal assessments guide.
Practise and get it marked
Practise your IAs on AusGrader: sit a prewritten practice IA where your subject has one, or build your own from real QCAA questions, and get it graded against the marking guide with feedback. You can also upload your IA draft for feedback against the ISMG.
Frequently asked questions
What is the difference between QCE Engineering IA1 and IA3?
IA1 is on structures in Unit 3. IA3 is on machines and/or mechanisms in Unit 4 and must include logic control technology. Conditions and marks match, but the IA3 marking guide adds control technologies to the synthesis criterion and asks for recommendations for modifications, where IA1 asks for enhancements.
Does a text box with a formula count towards the Engineering word limit?
The 2025 subject report, commenting on an IA1 excerpt, says a stress-formula text box would be counted in the word length. That comment is about one text box. The syllabus limit is up to 10 A4 pages and up to 2000 words.
What scale should a virtual prototype be in Engineering IA1 or IA3?
The 2025 subject report says, for both tasks, to use a 1:1 scale when including a virtual prototype. Numeric scales for physical work appear only in the QCAA sample tasks: the IA3 sample sets 1:10 for physical prototypes and the IA1 sample scales the loads to 1:20. Those are sample choices.
Do I need logic control in Engineering IA3?
Yes. The syllabus describes IA3 as a problem requiring an engineered solution that includes logic control technology, and the 2025 report says it must be included. The marking guide also adds control technologies to the Synthesising and Evaluating criterion.
Why do QCAA subject reports use different criterion names for Engineering IA1?
The 2023, 2024 and 2025 reports describe cohorts assessed under the 2019 syllabus, and their statistics keep the 2019 names. The 2025 report states the criteria changed from 4 to 3. Use the three criteria in the 2025 syllabus.
Sources
- Engineering 2025 v1.4 General senior syllabus, QCAA, March 2026, pp. 8, 10, 24-25, 29-30, 33-37, 43-47. The IA1 and IA3 specifications, conditions and instrument-specific marking guides.
- Engineering 2025 v1.2 IA1: Sample assessment instrument, QCAA, pp. 1, 3-5. A sample for teachers. The source of the sign gantry task described in this guide.
- Engineering 2025 v1.2 IA3: Sample assessment instrument, QCAA, pp. 1, 3-5. A sample for teachers. The source of the glass jar distribution task described in this guide.
- Engineering subject report, 2025 cohort, QCAA, January 2026, pp. 10-15, 21-24. Commentary on a 2019-syllabus cohort, plus the board's advice on the 2025 syllabus.
- Engineering subject report, 2024 cohort, QCAA, pp. 11-12, 17, 32-33. Commentary on these tasks under the 2019 syllabus.
- Engineering subject report, 2023 cohort, QCAA, p. 18. Commentary on IA1 under the 2019 syllabus.
Syllabus and assessment material referenced in this guide is © State of Queensland (Queensland Curriculum and Assessment Authority), licensed under CC BY 4.0. See our QCAA licensing notice. AusGrader is an independent study tool and is not affiliated with, endorsed by, or operated by the QCAA.
Keep reading
Practise what you just read
Work through real QCAA Engineering questions and get your written answers marked against the official criteria, instantly.