QCAA Physics Alternative Sequence Special relativity
15 sample questions with marking guides and sample answers
A train is travelling at relativistic speed and is about to move through a tunnel. An observer on the train measures the train and tunnel to each be 95 m long.
A second observer is stationary relative to the tunnel. They would observe the train to
simultaneously enter and exit the tunnel.
decrease its mass while in the tunnel.
move faster while in the tunnel.
be shorter than the tunnel.
Reveal Answer
simultaneously enter and exit the tunnel.
Because Observer 2 measures the train to be shorter than the tunnel, the train will fully enter the tunnel before its front exits, meaning these events are not simultaneous.
decrease its mass while in the tunnel.
The train's mass is an invariant property (rest mass) or depends only on its speed (relativistic mass), neither of which changes simply by entering the tunnel.
move faster while in the tunnel.
The train is traveling at a constant relativistic speed; entering the tunnel does not exert a force to cause it to accelerate.
be shorter than the tunnel.
Observer 1 measures the train's proper length as 95 m and the tunnel's contracted length as 95 m. Therefore, Observer 2 measures the tunnel's proper length ( m) and the train's contracted length ( m), making the train shorter than the tunnel.
A proton in an accelerator beamline of proper length has a Lorentz factor, , of .
Calculate the speed of the proton relative to the beamline in terms of , the speed of light in a vacuum. Give your answer to three significant figures.
Reveal Answer
... and after much transposition ...
| Descriptor | Marks |
|---|---|
Identifies the correct formula or correctly transposes the Lorentz factor formula to solve for velocity, e.g., | 1 |
Correctly substitutes the given values into the formula, e.g., | 1 |
Calculates the correct answer to three significant figures, | 1 |
Calculate the length of the beamline in the reference frame of the proton.
Reveal Answer
| Descriptor | Marks |
|---|---|
Calculates the correct length of the beamline in the reference frame of the proton, | 1 |
Calculate the kinetic energy of the proton in joules. Show your working.
Mass of proton .
Reveal Answer
| Descriptor | Marks |
|---|---|
Demonstrates correct working using the relativistic kinetic energy formula, e.g., | 1 |
Calculates the correct kinetic energy, | 1 |
An astronaut has left Earth and is travelling on a spaceship at 0.800c (γ = 1.67) directly towards the star known as Sirius, which is located 8.61 light-years away from Earth, as measured by observers on Earth.
How long will the trip take according to a clock that the astronaut is carrying on his spaceship? Show your working.
Reveal Answer
The distance of 8.61 light-years is the proper length in Earth's frame of reference. The proper time in the Earth's frame of reference is:
This time is the dilated time in the astronaut's frame of reference. The proper time as measured by the astronaut is:
| Descriptor | Marks |
|---|---|
Calculates the time in Earth's frame of reference () OR calculates the contracted length in the astronaut's frame of reference () | 1 |
Calculates the correct proper time of | 1 |
Is the trip time measured by the astronaut in part a. a proper time? Explain your reasoning.
Reveal Answer
The time measured by the astronaut will be proper time because the clock is stationary in the astronaut's frame of reference.
| Descriptor | Marks |
|---|---|
Identifies that the time measured by the astronaut is proper time | 1 |
Explains that this is because the clock is stationary in the astronaut's frame of reference | 1 |
Which one of the following is an example of an inertial frame of reference?
a bus travelling at constant velocity
an express train that is accelerating
a car turning a corner at a constant speed
a roller-coaster speeding up while heading down a slope
Reveal Answer
a bus travelling at constant velocity
This is correct because an inertial frame of reference is one that is not accelerating. A bus moving at a constant velocity has zero acceleration, making it an inertial frame where Newton's laws of motion hold true.
an express train that is accelerating
This is incorrect because an accelerating object represents a non-inertial frame of reference. By definition, an inertial frame must have zero acceleration.
a car turning a corner at a constant speed
This is incorrect because turning a corner involves a change in direction, which means the car is experiencing centripetal acceleration. Even at a constant speed, a change in direction makes it a non-inertial frame of reference.
a roller-coaster speeding up while heading down a slope
This is incorrect because the roller-coaster is speeding up, meaning its velocity is changing and it is accelerating. Any accelerating environment is a non-inertial frame of reference.
Describe the effects of relativistic travel on an object.
Reveal Answer
An object travelling near the speed of light will experience an increase in mass, resulting in increased momentum. It will also experience time slower compared to an observer in another, non-relativistic frame of reference.
Finally, an object moving at relativistic speeds would be observed to decrease in length in the direction of its travel.
| Descriptor | Marks |
|---|---|
describes the effect of time dilation | 1 |
describes the effect of length contraction | 1 |
describes the effect of relativistic momentum | 1 |
Identify the correct formula for the mass–energy equivalence relationship.
Reveal Answer
Correct. This is Einstein's famous mass-energy equivalence formula, stating that energy () equals mass () times the speed of light squared ().
Incorrect. This is the formula for gravitational potential energy, where is the acceleration due to gravity and is height.
Incorrect. This incorrectly combines the structure of the kinetic energy formula with the speed of light (), which does not represent any standard physical relationship.
Incorrect. This is the classical formula for kinetic energy, representing the energy of an object in motion with mass and velocity .
Salman and Priyanka have identical 1.00 m rulers. Priyanka takes her ruler and sets off in a rocket. She travels past Salman at a speed of . Their metre rulers are aligned in the direction of Priyanka's travel. Each then measures the length of the other's ruler by carefully determining the position of each end of the ruler at the same instant, and measuring the distance between these positions.
How long does Salman measure Priyanka's ruler to be?
Reveal Answer
| Descriptor | Marks |
|---|---|
Uses correct equation and places correct values in correct place | 1 |
Calculates correct answer | 1 |
How long does Priyanka measure Salman's ruler to be?
Reveal Answer
0.60 m
| Descriptor | Marks |
|---|---|
0.60 m | 1 |
When Priyanka returns, she and Salman compare the results of their measurements. How are they able to explain their seemingly contradictory results?
Reveal Answer
To successfully measure the length of the ruler moving relative to them, they determine the position of the ends of the ruler at the same time and measure the distance between these two positions. Each thought the other's measurements were not made simultaneously. Therefore they both measure the other's ruler as a different length to 1.00 m.
| Descriptor | Marks |
|---|---|
Explains that to successfully measure the length of the ruler moving relative to them, they determine the position of the ends of the ruler at the same time and measure the distance between these two positions. | 1 |
States that each thought the other's measurements were not made simultaneously. | 1 |
Concludes that therefore they both measure the other's ruler as a different length to 1.00 m. | 1 |
A high-energy proton is travelling through space at a constant velocity of 2.50 × 10^8 m s−1.
The Lorentz factor, γ, for this proton would be closest to
1.81
2.44
3.27
3.39
Reveal Answer
1.81
The Lorentz factor is calculated using . Substituting and yields .
2.44
This result comes from incorrectly omitting the squares on the velocities, calculating instead of the proper Lorentz factor formula.
3.27
This is the value of (approximately ), which occurs if you forget to take the square root of the denominator in the Lorentz factor formula.
3.39
This is an incorrect value resulting from a miscalculation. The correct Lorentz factor must be found using the formula .
An object is unable to accelerate to the speed of light because
length contraction will change the height of the object.
time dilation will decrease the velocity of the object.
the object will gain infinite momentum.
the inertia of the object will decrease.
Reveal Answer
length contraction will change the height of the object.
Length contraction only occurs parallel to the direction of motion, so the object's height would remain unchanged. Furthermore, length contraction is a consequence of relativistic speeds, not the limiting factor preventing an object from reaching the speed of light.
time dilation will decrease the velocity of the object.
Time dilation means time passes slower for the moving object relative to a stationary observer, but it does not act as a physical drag force that decreases the object's velocity.
the object will gain infinite momentum.
As an object's velocity approaches the speed of light (), its relativistic factor () approaches infinity. This causes its relativistic momentum () to become infinite, meaning it would require an infinite amount of energy to accelerate it to .
the inertia of the object will decrease.
As an object approaches the speed of light, its resistance to acceleration (effective inertia) actually increases toward infinity, making it harder to accelerate, rather than decreasing.
The half-life of an unstable subatomic particle is measured by a stationary detector to be longer when its velocity approaches the speed of light. This is because the particle
is moving relative to its frame of reference.
is in the same frame of reference as the detector.
experiences time differently relative to the detector.
cannot be accurately observed at relativistic speeds.
Reveal Answer
is moving relative to its frame of reference.
An object cannot move relative to its own frame of reference; by definition, it is always stationary within its own frame.
is in the same frame of reference as the detector.
The particle is moving at relativistic speeds relative to the stationary detector, meaning they are in completely different frames of reference.
experiences time differently relative to the detector.
According to special relativity, time dilation causes time to pass more slowly for the moving particle relative to the stationary detector, resulting in a longer measured half-life.
cannot be accurately observed at relativistic speeds.
The longer half-life is a real, measurable physical consequence of time dilation, not an error or limitation in observation.
Proper length is the length measured in the frame of reference where the object is
at rest.
in motion.
accelerating.
in motion but not accelerating.
Reveal Answer
at rest.
Proper length is defined in special relativity as the length of an object measured by an observer who is at rest relative to the object.
in motion.
If the object is in motion relative to the observer's frame of reference, the measured length will be shorter than the proper length due to length contraction.
accelerating.
Proper length is specifically defined in the object's rest frame. Measurements taken from an accelerating frame do not yield the proper length.
in motion but not accelerating.
Even if the object is moving at a constant velocity, an observer in a different frame will measure a contracted length rather than the proper length.
Protons with a Lorentz factor, , equal to are injected into a long beamline in a particle physics laboratory.
In the reference frame of the protons, which one of the following is closest to the length of the beamline?
Reveal Answer
This value is incorrect and does not follow the proper length contraction formula. The length must be divided by the Lorentz factor, not calculated using an incorrect relativistic relation.
In the protons' reference frame, the beamline is moving and undergoes length contraction. The contracted length is calculated as .
This is the proper length of the beamline measured in the laboratory frame where it is at rest. The protons will observe a shorter, contracted length due to their relative motion.
This result comes from incorrectly multiplying the proper length by the Lorentz factor (), which would represent length expansion rather than length contraction.
Muons are unstable particles produced when cosmic rays strike atoms high in the atmosphere. The muons travel downward, perpendicular to Earth's surface, at almost the speed of light.
Classical physics predicts that these muons will decay before they have time to reach Earth's surface.
Explain qualitatively why these muons can reach Earth's surface, regardless of whether their motion is considered from either the muon's frame of reference or the Earth's frame of reference.
Reveal Answer
In the muon's reference frame, the distance travelled is less than that observed by a stationery observer on Earth's surface, due the effects of length contraction. This shortened distance means that they will get further than would be expected by an observer observing the rest length.
From the Earth's frame of reference, the time dilation means that the half-life of the muon is dilated compared to the half-life measured in the rest frame of the muon. This greater time allows more muons to reach the ground than would otherwise be expected.
| Descriptor | Marks |
|---|---|
Explains why muons reach the Earth's surface with reference to relativistic effects in both frames of reference | 3 |
| 2 |
Provides some relevant information | 1 |
None of the above | 0 |
An observer who is stationary relative to a moving spaceship measures the velocity of the spaceship to be .
Calculate the length of the spaceship if the observer records it as 18 m. Show your working.
Reveal Answer
Length = (to two significant figures)
| Descriptor | Marks |
|---|---|
recognises the scenario relates to an object experiencing length contraction | 1 |
correctly substitutes for relativistic length | 1 |
calculates the length of the spaceship | 1 |
One of Einstein's postulates for special relativity is that the laws of physics are the same in all inertial frames of reference.
Which one of the following best describes a property of an inertial frame of reference?
It is travelling at a constant speed.
It is travelling at a speed much slower than .
Its movement is consistent with the expansion of the universe.
No observer in the frame can detect any acceleration of the frame.
Reveal Answer
It is travelling at a constant speed.
Incorrect. Travelling at a constant speed is insufficient because the direction could be changing (such as in circular motion), which implies acceleration. An inertial frame must travel at a constant velocity.
It is travelling at a speed much slower than .
Incorrect. The definition of an inertial frame does not depend on its speed relative to the speed of light, . A frame moving at a constant velocity close to is still a valid inertial frame.
Its movement is consistent with the expansion of the universe.
Incorrect. The expansion of the universe is a cosmological phenomenon and does not define an inertial frame. Inertial frames are defined strictly by the absence of acceleration.
No observer in the frame can detect any acceleration of the frame.
Correct. An inertial frame of reference is defined as one that is not accelerating. Therefore, an observer within this frame will not experience any fictitious forces and cannot detect any acceleration.