QCAA Economics Economic management
15 sample questions with marking guides and sample answers
A strength of monetary policy is that it
can have an impact on the exchange rate.
can be targeted to specific sectors of the economy.
is more effective in a recession than fiscal policy.
is the only policy that can control inflation.
Reveal Answer
can have an impact on the exchange rate.
Changes in interest rates through monetary policy influence foreign investment and capital flows, which directly impact the country's exchange rate.
can be targeted to specific sectors of the economy.
Monetary policy is a broad macroeconomic tool that affects the general interest rate, making it difficult to target specific sectors, unlike fiscal policy.
is more effective in a recession than fiscal policy.
During a recession, monetary policy can become ineffective if interest rates are near zero (a liquidity trap), making fiscal policy generally more effective at directly stimulating demand.
is the only policy that can control inflation.
While monetary policy is a primary tool for controlling inflation, contractionary fiscal policy (like raising taxes or cutting government spending) can also reduce inflationary pressures.
Selling government bonds to domestic residents to finance successive budget deficits can lead to
(i) increased interest rates.
(ii) crowding in.
(iii) crowding out.
(iv) an increase in private sector investment.
i and ii only
i and iii
i, ii and iv
iii only
Reveal Answer
i and ii only
While selling government bonds does increase interest rates (i), this leads to a decrease in private investment known as crowding out, not crowding in (ii).
i and iii
Selling government bonds increases the demand for loanable funds, which drives up interest rates (i). These higher interest rates make borrowing more expensive, reducing private sector investment, a phenomenon known as crowding out (iii).
i, ii and iv
Higher interest rates resulting from government borrowing lead to a decrease, not an increase, in private sector investment (iv), meaning crowding in (ii) does not occur.
iii only
While crowding out (iii) is a correct outcome, this option is incomplete because it fails to include the increased interest rates (i) that directly cause the crowding out effect.
Assume the Australian economy is experiencing the following economic conditions:
- inflation = 2.0%
- economic growth = 1.5%
- unemployment = 6.5%.
On the basis of the data, the Reserve Bank of Australia (RBA) would most likely
leave the cash rate unchanged as price stability is its main objective.
increase the cash rate to reduce the level of aggregate demand.
sell government bonds to the public to increase liquidity in the financial sector.
reduce the cash rate to increase the level of aggregate demand.
Reveal Answer
leave the cash rate unchanged as price stability is its main objective.
Although price stability is a primary objective, inflation is at the bottom of the 2-3% target band. With high unemployment and low growth, the RBA would likely intervene rather than leave rates unchanged.
increase the cash rate to reduce the level of aggregate demand.
Increasing the cash rate is a contractionary policy used to cool down an overheating economy and lower high inflation, which contradicts the current conditions of low growth and high unemployment.
sell government bonds to the public to increase liquidity in the financial sector.
Selling government bonds actually decreases liquidity in the financial sector by taking money out of circulation, which is a contractionary measure.
reduce the cash rate to increase the level of aggregate demand.
With inflation under control, low economic growth, and high unemployment, the RBA would likely implement expansionary monetary policy by reducing the cash rate to stimulate aggregate demand, boost growth, and create jobs.
Australia's international competitiveness will most likely increase if
the Australian dollar appreciates relative to our trading partners' currencies.
the Australian Government spends more on ports and railroads.
Australian workers' wages increase faster than their productivity.
Gross Domestic Product (GDP) growth is higher in Australia than in other countries.
Reveal Answer
the Australian dollar appreciates relative to our trading partners' currencies.
An appreciation of the Australian dollar makes exports more expensive for foreign buyers, which decreases rather than increases international competitiveness.
the Australian Government spends more on ports and railroads.
Government investment in infrastructure like ports and railroads reduces transportation costs and improves supply chain efficiency, making Australian exports more competitive globally.
Australian workers' wages increase faster than their productivity.
When wage growth outpaces productivity growth, unit labor costs increase, making Australian goods more expensive to produce and less competitive internationally.
Gross Domestic Product (GDP) growth is higher in Australia than in other countries.
Higher GDP growth does not directly improve international competitiveness and could potentially reduce it if the growth leads to higher domestic inflation.
Explain why and how both monetary policy and fiscal policy have been used to influence the Australian economy in 2020. Use an aggregate expenditure (AE) model to support your answer.
Reveal Answer
Answer(s) could include:
Australian economy:
- reference to severe contraction (recession) and nature of demand and supply shock from exogenous factors particularly the coronavirus
- main economic indicators and how they have changed over the year: GDP growth, unemployment, inflation, investment, exchange rate, consumer spending etc.
- reference to industries hardest hit by contraction
- global financial crises and uncertainty
- effect of slowdown of global economic growth on local economy.
Monetary policy:
- reduction in cash rate by RBA and market interest rates - expansionary
- intended effect on consumption, investment and exchange rate via transmission mechanism
- aim to support aggregate spending and create employment
- role of multiplier effect.
Fiscal policy:
- range of significant stimulus payments to households and government policy support for businesses during time of collapsing consumer spending
- reduction in government revenue and increase in expenditure
- movement to a significant budget deficit from planned budget surplus
- role of multiplier effect..
AE model:
- 45 degree line, AE on vertical axis, Real GDP on horizontal axis
- parallel AE lines demonstrating impact of recession and policy effect
- increase in equilibrium real GDP to reduce deflationary gap.
Australian economy in 2020
Marking Bands| Descriptor | Marks |
|---|---|
Explanation of the state of the Australian economy in 2020 | 3 |
Description of the Australian economy in 2020 | 2 |
Some awareness of the Australian economy in 2020 | 1 |
None of the above | 0 |
Monetary Policy
Marking Bands| Descriptor | Marks |
|---|---|
Explanation of the use of monetary policy and its relevance to the economic circumstances | 3 |
Description of monetary policy setting/changes connected to the economic circumstances | 2 |
Some awareness of how monetary policy has been used this year | 1 |
None of the above | 0 |
Fiscal Policy
Marking Bands| Descriptor | Marks |
|---|---|
Explanation of the use of fiscal policy and its relevance to the economic circumstances | 3 |
Description of fiscal policy setting/changes connected to the economic circumstances | 2 |
Some awareness of how fiscal policy has been used this year | 1 |
None of the above | 0 |
Economic model
Marking Bands| Descriptor | Marks |
|---|---|
Fully labelled and correct AE model demonstrating a deflationary gap and impact of expansionary policy settings | 3 |
Mostly correct model demonstrating impact of expansionary policy settings | 2 |
Some aspects on an AE model | 1 |
None of the above | 0 |
Discuss the factors likely to influence the effectiveness of each of these policies.
Reveal Answer
Answer(s) could include:
Monetary policy:
- overall effectiveness is likely to be poor; no guaranteed increase in aggregate spending such as, cost of borrowing and asset prices channels
- interest rates were already very low, further reductions likely to have limited impact due to low consumer and business confidence
- household debt is high making it more likely households will seek to retire debt rather than borrow
- depreciation of Australian dollar will have increased net exports despite a significant fall in world growth
- significant effect time lag.
Fiscal policy:
- more effective because government spending can increase aggregate spending directly
- government expenditure multiplier likely to be low because of low MPC
- government reluctant to go into too much debt given experience post-GFC
- other criticisms relevant to success of policies implemented in 2020.
A number of factors effect both policies, i.e. multiplier effect, expectation, and crowding out effects.
| Descriptor | Marks |
|---|---|
Discussion in detail several factors and reasons for their influence on effectiveness of policies | 8 |
The student response meets all criteria of the 6-mark band, and additionally meets the majority of criteria in the 8-mark band. | 7 |
Explanation of several factors and their influence on effectiveness of policies | 6 |
The student response meets all criteria of the 4-mark band, and additionally meets the majority of criteria in the 6-mark band. | 5 |
Description of a few factors and their link to effectiveness of policies | 4 |
The student response meets all criteria of the 2-mark band, and additionally meets the majority of criteria in the 4-mark band. | 3 |
Identification of a factor and its influence | 2 |
The student response meets all criteria of the 0-mark band, and additionally meets the majority of criteria in the 2-mark band. | 1 |
None of the above | 0 |
Which one of the following would not be classified as a direct tax in the Australian Government's federal budget?
company tax
capital gains tax
goods and services tax
pay-as-you-go income tax
Reveal Answer
company tax
Incorrect. Company tax is a direct tax because it is levied directly on the profits earned by corporations, meaning the tax burden cannot be shifted to someone else.
capital gains tax
Incorrect. Capital gains tax is a direct tax as it is applied directly to the profit an individual or entity makes from the sale of an asset or investment.
goods and services tax
Correct. The Goods and Services Tax (GST) is an indirect tax, not a direct tax, because it is levied on the consumption of goods and services and the cost is passed on to the final consumer.
pay-as-you-go income tax
Incorrect. Pay-as-you-go (PAYG) income tax is a direct tax because it is deducted directly from an individual's personal earnings or wages.
When the Reserve Bank of Australia (RBA) increases the cash rate, its main aim is to
increase real GDP, employment and the price level.
encourage private sector borrowing and spending.
reduce inflation to within the target range.
increase asset prices.
Reveal Answer
increase real GDP, employment and the price level.
Increasing the cash rate is a contractionary monetary policy, which typically slows down real GDP growth, reduces employment, and decreases the price level rather than increasing them.
encourage private sector borrowing and spending.
A higher cash rate increases the cost of borrowing, which discourages rather than encourages private sector borrowing and spending.
reduce inflation to within the target range.
The primary goal of increasing the cash rate is to cool down an overheating economy, thereby reducing inflation to keep it within the RBA's target range of 2-3%.
increase asset prices.
Higher interest rates generally put downward pressure on asset prices, such as housing and shares, because borrowing becomes more expensive and future returns are discounted at a higher rate.
Assume the Australian Government has simplified regulations in the medical and pharmaceutical industries.
Identify the expected change to the aggregate demand/aggregate supply diagram (ceteris paribus).
Average prices rise and GDP decreases because the aggregate supply curve shifts to the left.
Average prices fall and GDP increases because the aggregate supply curve shifts to the right.
Average prices rise and GDP increases due to an expansionary movement along the aggregate supply curve.
Average prices fall and GDP decreases due to a contractionary movement along the aggregate supply curve.
Reveal Answer
Average prices rise and GDP decreases because the aggregate supply curve shifts to the left.
This option describes a negative supply shock. Simplifying regulations reduces compliance costs for businesses, which increases (shifts right), rather than decreases (shifts left), aggregate supply.
Average prices fall and GDP increases because the aggregate supply curve shifts to the right.
Simplifying regulations acts as a positive supply-side shock by lowering production costs and increasing efficiency. This shifts the aggregate supply curve to the right, resulting in a lower price level and higher real GDP.
Average prices rise and GDP increases due to an expansionary movement along the aggregate supply curve.
A movement along the aggregate supply curve is caused by a shift in aggregate demand. Regulatory reform is a non-price determinant of supply that shifts the entire AS curve.
Average prices fall and GDP decreases due to a contractionary movement along the aggregate supply curve.
This outcome describes a decrease in aggregate demand. Supply-side reforms, such as deregulation, shift the AS curve to the right, leading to an increase in GDP rather than a decrease.
Which policy mix is the most appropriate in the following scenario?
- Annual consumer price index movement: () 100 to () 102.
- Nominal gross domestic product movement: () $9.3 billion to () $9.5 billion.
- Non-accelerating inflationary rate of unemployment: () 4.5% to () 4.0%.
- Dwelling approvals have fallen slightly from to .
expansionary monetary and fiscal policy
neutral monetary and fiscal policy stance
expansionary monetary policy and neutral fiscal policy stance
neutral monetary policy and fiscal policy that contracts the economy
Reveal Answer
expansionary monetary and fiscal policy
This option is incorrect because expansionary policies are typically reserved for periods of recession or deflation. With inflation at a stable (calculated from the CPI rise from 100 to 102), aggressive stimulus could risk pushing inflation above the target range.
neutral monetary and fiscal policy stance
This is the correct option. The inflation rate is , which is within the standard target band (e.g., 2–3%), and nominal GDP is growing. Since the economy is exhibiting price stability and the NAIRU has improved (allowing for lower unemployment without inflation), a neutral stance is appropriate to maintain equilibrium.
expansionary monetary policy and neutral fiscal policy stance
This option is incorrect. While dwelling approvals have fallen slightly, the overall macroeconomic indicators (specifically the inflation rate) do not suggest a need for monetary stimulus, which is usually employed to boost low inflation or combat rising unemployment.
neutral monetary policy and fiscal policy that contracts the economy
This option is incorrect because contractionary fiscal policy is used to cool down an overheating economy with high inflation. Since inflation is stable at and dwelling approvals are already softening, contracting the economy would risk stalling growth unnecessarily.
Which one of the following best describes a regressive tax?
a tax that takes proportionally less from low-income earners compared to high-income earners
a tax that takes proportionally more from low-income earners compared to high-income earners
a tax that takes proportionally more from high-income earners compared to low-income earners
a tax that takes proportionally the same from all income earners
Reveal Answer
a tax that takes proportionally less from low-income earners compared to high-income earners
This describes a progressive tax, where the tax burden increases as income rises. A regressive tax does the opposite.
a tax that takes proportionally more from low-income earners compared to high-income earners
A regressive tax imposes a heavier relative burden on low-income earners because the fixed tax amount takes up a larger percentage of their total income.
a tax that takes proportionally more from high-income earners compared to low-income earners
This is the definition of a progressive tax, such as the standard federal income tax, rather than a regressive tax.
a tax that takes proportionally the same from all income earners
A tax that takes the exact same proportion from everyone regardless of income is known as a proportional or flat tax.
Assume there is an increase in Australians preferring to rent rather than buy their own home. The effect on the transmission mechanism would be (ceteris paribus)
a change to how the transmission mechanism is channelled.
a decrease in the effective size of the transmission mechanism.
quicker interest rate changes so banks maintain their profit levels.
a shorter time frame for the cash rate to be transmitted throughout the economy.
Reveal Answer
a change to how the transmission mechanism is channelled.
While the relative importance of specific channels might shift, the fundamental structure of the transmission mechanism remains the same. The more significant impact is on the magnitude of the effect rather than the method of channeling.
a decrease in the effective size of the transmission mechanism.
The cash flow channel acts largely through mortgage repayments; if fewer people have mortgages (preferring to rent), household disposable income becomes less sensitive to interest rate changes, reducing the overall effectiveness or 'size' of the policy impact.
quicker interest rate changes so banks maintain their profit levels.
Bank interest rate decisions are primarily driven by funding costs and the official cash rate, not directly by the proportion of households renting versus buying.
a shorter time frame for the cash rate to be transmitted throughout the economy.
Rents are typically fixed for the duration of a lease (e.g., 12 months) and adjust more slowly than variable mortgage rates, so a shift toward renting would likely increase the time lag rather than shorten it.
Outline the economic policy objectives of the Australian Government and describe the extent to which these may conflict with or complement each other.
Reveal Answer
Answers could include:
Economic policy objectives
- price stability
- full employment
- sustainable economic growth
- equitable distribution of income
- efficient allocation of resources.
Complementary objectives
- full employment and economic growth – expanding the economy requires the employment of more resources, including labour. This complements economic growth
- efficient allocation of resources and economic growth – as the economy expands, resources become scarcer and are used more intensively and efficiently.
Conflicting objectives
- price stability and economic growth – expanding the economy will increase competition for resources, increasing the cost of resources to meet additional demand
- and equitable distribution of income could reduce economic growth through increase in welfare payments
- equitable distribution of income - gains from economic growth are likely to benefit specific groups at a cost of others
- full employment and price stability – typically, during periods of full employment inflation is generally high. Inflammatory policies are often used during periods of full employment and counteract demand-pull inflation with higher cash rates or lower fiscal spending. As a result of lower aggregate demand, higher unemployment can be expected.
Objective 1
Marking Bands| Descriptor | Marks |
|---|---|
Describes the extent to which the government economic policy objective compliments or conflicts with other objectives. | 2 |
Outlines the government economic policy objective. | 1 |
None of the above | 0 |
Objective 2
Marking Bands| Descriptor | Marks |
|---|---|
Describes the extent to which the government economic policy objective compliments or conflicts with other objectives. | 2 |
Outlines the government economic policy objective. | 1 |
None of the above | 0 |
Objective 3
Marking Bands| Descriptor | Marks |
|---|---|
Describes the extent to which the government economic policy objective compliments or conflicts with other objectives. | 2 |
Outlines the government economic policy objective. | 1 |
None of the above | 0 |
Objective 4
Marking Bands| Descriptor | Marks |
|---|---|
Describes the extent to which the government economic policy objective compliments or conflicts with other objectives. | 2 |
Outlines the government economic policy objective. | 1 |
None of the above | 0 |
Objective 5
Marking Bands| Descriptor | Marks |
|---|---|
Describes the extent to which the government economic policy objective compliments or conflicts with other objectives. | 2 |
Outlines the government economic policy objective. | 1 |
None of the above | 0 |
Outline the two methods used to measure productivity and, using an aggregate demand/aggregate supply (AD/AS) model, illustrate and explain the impact of productivity growth on the achievement of any three economic objectives.
Reveal Answer
Answers could include:
Methods:
- labour productivity equals GDP per worker
- multifactor productivity equals output divided by all inputs – the growth in output caused by the growth in inputs.
Impacts:
- increased productivity decreases costs of production thereby achieving price stability
- increased productivity leads to increased economic growth, rising standard of living.
- higher wages from increased productivity can impact on standard of living and equitable distribution of income
- increased productivity may have negative impacts on employment in the short run. In the long-run, productivity increases incomes, leading to an increase in jobs, lowering unemployment
- increased productivity will result in higher government revenue which can be used to improve income distribution.
The model should show:
- a rightward shift in the AD curve
- a rightward shift in the AS curve;
Methods used to measure productivity
| Descriptor | Marks |
|---|---|
Outlines labour productivity. | 1 |
Outlines multifactor productivity (MFP). | 1 |
Impact 1
Marking Bands| Descriptor | Marks |
|---|---|
Explains the impact of productivity on any three economic objectives. There is consideration of both positive and negative impacts. | 2 |
Outlines how productivity may impact on any three economic objectives. | 1 |
None of the above | 0 |
Impact 2
Marking Bands| Descriptor | Marks |
|---|---|
Explains the impact of productivity on any three economic objectives. There is consideration of both positive and negative impacts. | 2 |
Outlines how productivity may impact on any three economic objectives. | 1 |
None of the above | 0 |
Impact 3
Marking Bands| Descriptor | Marks |
|---|---|
Explains the impact of productivity on any three economic objectives. There is consideration of both positive and negative impacts. | 2 |
Outlines how productivity may impact on any three economic objectives. | 1 |
None of the above | 0 |
Model
Marking Bands| Descriptor | Marks |
|---|---|
Detailed AD/AS model shows both short run and long run shift in AD and AS. | 2 |
Mostly correct model showing a rightward shift in either AD or AS curve. | 1 |
None of the above | 0 |
Which of the following is an example of a counter-cyclical demand-management policy?
an increase in transfer payments during a boom
a decrease in the cash rate during a boom
an increase in tax rates during a recession
an increase in infrastructure spending during a recession
Reveal Answer
an increase in transfer payments during a boom
Increasing transfer payments during a boom is a pro-cyclical policy, as it would further stimulate aggregate demand when the economy is already expanding.
a decrease in the cash rate during a boom
Decreasing the cash rate is an expansionary monetary policy that stimulates borrowing and spending, which is pro-cyclical and could lead to overheating during an economic boom.
an increase in tax rates during a recession
Increasing tax rates during a recession is a pro-cyclical policy, as it reduces disposable income and aggregate demand, which would worsen the economic downturn.
an increase in infrastructure spending during a recession
Increasing infrastructure spending is an expansionary fiscal policy that boosts aggregate demand, making it a counter-cyclical approach designed to stimulate the economy during a recession.
Which of the following statements most accurately describes the impact of bushfires and drought on the 2019–2020 Commonwealth budget?
There was a planned budget surplus but the outcome was a budget deficit.
There was a planned budget deficit but the outcome was a budget surplus.
The actual budget surplus was larger than the planned budget surplus.
The actual budget deficit was larger than the planned budget deficit.
Reveal Answer
There was a planned budget surplus but the outcome was a budget deficit.
The Australian government initially projected a budget surplus for 2019-2020, but increased emergency spending and reduced tax revenues caused by the severe bushfires and drought resulted in a budget deficit.
There was a planned budget deficit but the outcome was a budget surplus.
The government originally planned for a budget surplus, not a deficit, before these natural disasters occurred.
The actual budget surplus was larger than the planned budget surplus.
The economic impact of the bushfires and drought worsened the budget balance, turning the planned surplus into a deficit rather than increasing the surplus.
The actual budget deficit was larger than the planned budget deficit.
The government had planned for a budget surplus, not a deficit, prior to the economic shocks of the bushfires and drought.
Which one of the following is not a role of the RBA?
adjusting tax rates
issuing Australia’s bank notes
managing foreign currency reserves
providing specialist banking services to the Australian Government
Reveal Answer
adjusting tax rates
Correct. Adjusting tax rates is a tool of fiscal policy managed by the federal government, whereas the RBA is responsible for monetary policy.
issuing Australia’s bank notes
Incorrect. Issuing and managing Australia's banknotes is one of the core responsibilities of the RBA.
managing foreign currency reserves
Incorrect. The RBA holds and manages Australia's foreign currency and gold reserves to support monetary policy and facilitate international transactions.
providing specialist banking services to the Australian Government
Incorrect. The RBA acts as the central bank and serves as the primary banker for the Australian Government and its various agencies.