QCAA Economics Economic indicators and past budget stances
15 sample questions with marking guides and sample answers · Avg. score: 59.8%
Which of the following are economic indicators of an expansion phase of the business cycle?
increasing consumer confidence and increasing inventories
an increasing current account balance and increasing taxation revenue
decreasing consumer confidence and increasing inventories
a decreasing current account balance and increasing taxation revenue
Reveal Answer
increasing consumer confidence and increasing inventories
While increasing consumer confidence is a sign of expansion, increasing inventories typically indicates unsold goods piling up, which is a sign of an economic slowdown or contraction.
an increasing current account balance and increasing taxation revenue
Increasing taxation revenue occurs during an expansion, but the current account balance typically decreases (worsens) because higher domestic incomes lead to increased spending on imports.
decreasing consumer confidence and increasing inventories
Decreasing consumer confidence and increasing inventories of unsold goods are both classic indicators of an economic contraction or recession, not an expansion.
a decreasing current account balance and increasing taxation revenue
During an economic expansion, higher domestic incomes lead to increased imports (decreasing the current account balance), while higher employment and consumer spending lead to increased taxation revenue for the government.
Consider the following data for a hypothetical economy.
| Quarter | Real GDP ($ billion) |
|---|---|
| June 2021 | 50 |
| September 2021 | 56 |
| December 2021 | 57 |
| March 2022 | 40 |
| June 2022 | 48 |
Using this data, the rate of economic growth for the year ended June 2022 was
-2%
-4%
-20%
12%
Reveal Answer
-2%
This represents the absolute change in Real GDP (-$\2 billion) rather than the percentage growth rate.
-4%
The annual economic growth rate is calculated as the percentage change from June 2021 to June 2022: .
-20%
This is the growth rate from June 2021 to March 2022 (), not for the full year ended June 2022.
12%
This is the growth rate for the single quarter from June 2021 to September 2021 ().
Which policy mix is the most appropriate in the following scenario?
- Annual consumer price index movement: () 100 to () 102.
- Nominal gross domestic product movement: () $9.3 billion to () $9.5 billion.
- Non-accelerating inflationary rate of unemployment: () 4.5% to () 4.0%.
- Dwelling approvals have fallen slightly from to .
expansionary monetary and fiscal policy
neutral monetary and fiscal policy stance
expansionary monetary policy and neutral fiscal policy stance
neutral monetary policy and fiscal policy that contracts the economy
Reveal Answer
expansionary monetary and fiscal policy
This option is incorrect because expansionary policies are typically reserved for periods of recession or deflation. With inflation at a stable (calculated from the CPI rise from 100 to 102), aggressive stimulus could risk pushing inflation above the target range.
neutral monetary and fiscal policy stance
This is the correct option. The inflation rate is , which is within the standard target band (e.g., 2–3%), and nominal GDP is growing. Since the economy is exhibiting price stability and the NAIRU has improved (allowing for lower unemployment without inflation), a neutral stance is appropriate to maintain equilibrium.
expansionary monetary policy and neutral fiscal policy stance
This option is incorrect. While dwelling approvals have fallen slightly, the overall macroeconomic indicators (specifically the inflation rate) do not suggest a need for monetary stimulus, which is usually employed to boost low inflation or combat rising unemployment.
neutral monetary policy and fiscal policy that contracts the economy
This option is incorrect because contractionary fiscal policy is used to cool down an overheating economy with high inflation. Since inflation is stable at and dwelling approvals are already softening, contracting the economy would risk stalling growth unnecessarily.
Which of the following statements most accurately describes the impact of bushfires and drought on the 2019–2020 Commonwealth budget?
There was a planned budget surplus but the outcome was a budget deficit.
There was a planned budget deficit but the outcome was a budget surplus.
The actual budget surplus was larger than the planned budget surplus.
The actual budget deficit was larger than the planned budget deficit.
Reveal Answer
There was a planned budget surplus but the outcome was a budget deficit.
The Australian government initially projected a budget surplus for 2019-2020, but increased emergency spending and reduced tax revenues caused by the severe bushfires and drought resulted in a budget deficit.
There was a planned budget deficit but the outcome was a budget surplus.
The government originally planned for a budget surplus, not a deficit, before these natural disasters occurred.
The actual budget surplus was larger than the planned budget surplus.
The economic impact of the bushfires and drought worsened the budget balance, turning the planned surplus into a deficit rather than increasing the surplus.
The actual budget deficit was larger than the planned budget deficit.
The government had planned for a budget surplus, not a deficit, prior to the economic shocks of the bushfires and drought.
____________________ are a leading indicator of economic activity, while ____________________ are considered to be a lagging indicator.
Share prices; unemployment rates
Building approvals; retail sales
Bankruptcies; job advertisements
New business start-ups; motor vehicle sales
Reveal Answer
Share prices; unemployment rates
Share prices reflect investor expectations of future economic performance, making them a leading indicator. Conversely, unemployment rates change after the economy has already begun to shift, making them a lagging indicator.
Building approvals; retail sales
While building approvals are a leading indicator, retail sales are generally considered a coincident indicator because they move in tandem with the current state of the economy.
Bankruptcies; job advertisements
This option reverses the order. Bankruptcies are a lagging indicator because they occur after an economic downturn has taken its toll, while job advertisements are a leading indicator of future hiring.
New business start-ups; motor vehicle sales
New business start-ups are a leading indicator, but motor vehicle sales are typically considered a coincident or leading indicator, not a lagging indicator.
Consider the following data showing the Consumer Price Index (CPI) for a number of quarters in a hypothetical economy.
| Quarter | CPI |
|---|---|
| June 2020 | 110.0 |
| Sept. 2020 | 110.7 |
| Dec. 2020 | 111.1 |
| Mar. 2021 | 111.6 |
| June 2021 | 112.0 |
The inflation rate for the year ended June 2021 is
2%
1.8%
1%
0.8%
Reveal Answer
2%
This is the absolute difference in index points (), not the percentage change required to find the inflation rate.
1.8%
The annual inflation rate is the percentage change in the CPI over the year: .
1%
This is an incorrect calculation. The inflation rate must be calculated using the percentage change formula between June 2020 and June 2021.
0.8%
This is an incorrect calculation. The correct inflation rate is found by calculating the percentage change from June 2020 to June 2021.
Australia's economic objective of price stability is most compatible with the
balanced budget objective.
equitable distribution of income objective.
sustainable economic growth objective.
efficient resource allocation objective.
Reveal Answer
balanced budget objective.
A balanced budget is a fiscal policy stance rather than a primary macroeconomic objective, and strictly pursuing it can sometimes conflict with stabilizing the economy.
equitable distribution of income objective.
While price stability helps protect the purchasing power of low-income earners, it is not the objective most directly and broadly compatible with price stability at a macroeconomic level.
sustainable economic growth objective.
Price stability reduces economic uncertainty and preserves the value of money, which encourages long-term investment and consumption, thereby fostering sustainable economic growth.
efficient resource allocation objective.
Although low inflation helps maintain clear price signals for efficient resource allocation, sustainable economic growth is the broader macroeconomic objective most fundamentally compatible with price stability.
The data shows an economic scenario over a three-year period.
| Year 1 | Year 2 | Year 3 | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Nominal GDP ($ billion) | 700 | 730 | 745 |
| Budget surplus ($ billion) | 100 | 115 | 140 |
Which economic policies would improve this situation?
raising the age pension and increasing income taxes
selling government assets and reducing retirement age
increasing retirement age and decreasing health expenditure
increasing job seeker payments and decreasing income taxes
Reveal Answer
raising the age pension and increasing income taxes
While raising pensions injects money, increasing income taxes removes money from the economy (contractionary), which would likely maintain the high surplus and fail to stimulate the slowing GDP growth.
selling government assets and reducing retirement age
Selling government assets is not a direct fiscal stimulus, and reducing the retirement age shrinks the labor supply; neither action effectively utilizes the budget surplus to boost aggregate demand.
increasing retirement age and decreasing health expenditure
Decreasing health expenditure is a contractionary policy that would reduce aggregate demand and increase the budget surplus further, likely causing GDP growth to slow even more.
increasing job seeker payments and decreasing income taxes
The data indicates slowing GDP growth alongside a rising budget surplus; increasing transfer payments and decreasing taxes are expansionary fiscal policies that inject funds into the economy to stimulate growth.
An example of a leading economic indicator signaling a recovery is
an increase in new employment vacancies.
an increase in consumer debt.
maximum capacity utilisation.
high levels of inflation.
Reveal Answer
an increase in new employment vacancies.
Leading indicators change before the broader economy does. An increase in new employment vacancies signals that businesses are preparing to expand, which precedes an actual economic recovery.
an increase in consumer debt.
Consumer debt is typically a lagging indicator. Consumers usually take on more debt after they feel confident in their financial situation, which happens once a recovery is already underway.
maximum capacity utilisation.
Maximum capacity utilization occurs at the peak of an economic boom, not at the beginning of a recovery, making it a coincident or lagging indicator.
high levels of inflation.
Inflation is generally a lagging indicator that rises after the economy has been expanding and demand outpaces supply, rather than signaling the start of a recovery.
The table shows labour market data for an economy.
| Year | Labour force ('000) | Employed persons ('000) |
|---|---|---|
| 2021 | 580 | 550 |
| 2022 | 790 | 760 |
Based on the data in the table, fiscal policy measures
should be avoided because the number of employed persons has increased.
do not need to be changed because the employment rate is unchanged.
could be contractionary because the unemployment rate is falling.
could be expansionary because the employment rate is rising.
Reveal Answer
should be avoided because the number of employed persons has increased.
An increase in the number of employed persons does not automatically mean fiscal policy should be avoided; if the economy is overheating, intervention may still be necessary.
do not need to be changed because the employment rate is unchanged.
The employment rate did change; it increased from approximately () in 2021 to () in 2022.
could be contractionary because the unemployment rate is falling.
The unemployment rate fell from roughly () to (). A falling unemployment rate suggests the economy is expanding and potentially overheating, making contractionary fiscal policy appropriate to control inflation.
could be expansionary because the employment rate is rising.
Expansionary policy is typically used to boost the economy when employment is low or falling; implementing it when the employment rate is already rising could lead to excessive inflation.
Which of the following are incompatible economic objectives?
economic growth and equitable distribution of income
price stability and efficient allocation of resources
economic growth and full employment
efficient allocation of resources and economic growth
Reveal Answer
economic growth and equitable distribution of income
Policies that promote rapid economic growth, such as tax incentives for investment, often disproportionately benefit the wealthy, making it difficult to simultaneously achieve an equitable distribution of income.
price stability and efficient allocation of resources
Price stability actually supports the efficient allocation of resources by ensuring that price signals accurately reflect market conditions rather than inflation.
economic growth and full employment
Economic growth and full employment are complementary goals, as expanding production typically requires hiring more workers, thereby reducing unemployment.
efficient allocation of resources and economic growth
Efficient allocation of resources maximizes an economy's productive capacity, which directly supports and enhances economic growth.
An economic scenario is provided.
The 2021/22 federal budget is expected to deliver a deficit of $4.2b at the end of June 2022. A $7.1b surplus is anticipated the following year.
(Forecast released May 2022)
Export data shows coal exports are expected to fall from 2021 to 2022 by approximately $70 billion.
(Data released 10 July 2022)
CPI data shows that movements in the consumer price index (CPI) and the wage price index (WPI) were below 2% for the three years to June 2022.
(Data updated 31 July 2022)
Use the scenario to explain two relationships and their economic effects. Evaluate the merit of achieving a budget surplus in your answer.
Reveal Answer
The CPI data shows there are no inflation pressures from consumer prices or wages, indicating the economy has not experienced demand pressures for three years.
The export data demonstrates that Australia has some external stability pressures, because the export value of coal has fallen by $70 billion.
These two datasets, in the absence of further information, indicate that economic activity is weakening. They also provide evidence of negative forces acting within Australia’s economy that require stimulatory policies.
Proposals to achieve a federal budget surplus as expected cannot be justified at this time, because it would mean contracting the economy, which could result in inflation and wages falling further. The fall in wages would be expected to cause households to defer spending and save, causing a flow-on effect on business investment. This would result in several negative forces acting on aggregate demand and reducing economic growth. Consequently, the productive capacity of the economy should be increased.
Data Relationships
Marking Bands| Descriptor | Marks |
|---|---|
Explains a relationship to – domestic aggregate demand pressures (inflation) – external stability pressures (exports) | 2 |
Identifies a relationship linked to either the inflation data or the export data | 1 |
Does not satisfy any of the descriptors below. | 0 |
Economic Activity Deduction
Marking Bands| Descriptor | Marks |
|---|---|
Deduces that economic activity is weak based on the 2 datasets, identifies ceteris paribus | 3 |
Deduces that economic activity is weak based on the 2 datasets OR deduces that economic activity is weak based on 1 dataset, identifies ceteris paribus | 2 |
Identifies that economic activity is weak | 1 |
Does not satisfy any of the descriptors below. | 0 |
Policy Conclusion
Marking Bands| Descriptor | Marks |
|---|---|
Draws a conclusion that stimulus is required so there is no merit in a budget surplus, provides detailed reasoning using an economic criterion | 4 |
Draws a conclusion that stimulus is required so there is no merit in a budget surplus, provides reasoning using an economic criterion OR draws a conclusion that stimulus is required, provides detailed reasoning referring to the sources | 3 |
Draws a conclusion that stimulus is required, identifies a reason using an economic criterion | 2 |
Identifies that contracting the economy is not warranted | 1 |
Does not satisfy any of the descriptors below. | 0 |
Which one of the following economic indicators would increase during a contraction in the business cycle?
share prices
unemployment rates
production of building materials
new business start-ups
Reveal Answer
share prices
Incorrect. Share prices typically fall during an economic contraction as corporate profits decline and investor confidence weakens.
unemployment rates
Correct. During a contraction, businesses reduce production and lay off workers, which causes the unemployment rate to rise.
production of building materials
Incorrect. The production of building materials usually decreases during a contraction because demand for new construction projects drops when the economy slows.
new business start-ups
Incorrect. New business start-ups generally decline during a contraction due to lower consumer demand, economic uncertainty, and tighter credit conditions.
While the planned budget outcome for 2022/23 was a deficit of $78b, the actual outcome was a deficit of $22.1b. The reason for the difference was most likely to be
reduced company tax receipts.
higher than expected unemployment data.
higher than expected commodity prices.
lower than expected economic growth data.
Reveal Answer
reduced company tax receipts.
Reduced company tax receipts would decrease government revenue, which would increase the size of the budget deficit rather than decrease it.
higher than expected unemployment data.
Higher unemployment would lead to increased government spending on welfare and decreased income tax revenue, resulting in a larger budget deficit.
higher than expected commodity prices.
Higher than expected commodity prices boost corporate profits, particularly in the mining sector, leading to increased company tax receipts and a significantly smaller budget deficit.
lower than expected economic growth data.
Lower economic growth typically reduces tax revenues and increases welfare payments, which would lead to a larger budget deficit, not a smaller one.
An economy is experiencing decreasing levels of economic activity.
A cause for unemployment rates remaining at 5% (ceteris paribus) might be
a reduction in the number of hours worked.
an increase in unemployment benefits.
a rise in the number of school leavers.
a delay in workers retiring.
Reveal Answer
a reduction in the number of hours worked.
Firms may respond to decreased demand by reducing the working hours of existing employees (underemployment) rather than laying them off, which keeps the official unemployment rate stable despite the economic downturn.
an increase in unemployment benefits.
Increasing unemployment benefits typically raises the reservation wage and encourages workers to stay unemployed longer to search for better jobs, which would likely increase the unemployment rate.
a rise in the number of school leavers.
An influx of school leavers increases the labor supply; in an economy with decreasing activity, these new entrants are unlikely to find jobs quickly, which would cause the unemployment rate to rise.
a delay in workers retiring.
If workers delay retirement, the labor force remains larger while demand for labor is falling, which would typically lead to a higher unemployment rate as more people compete for fewer jobs.