NESA Biology Planning Investigations
15 sample questions with marking guides and sample answers · Avg. score: 69.1%
Eloise wanted to investigate the effect of temperature changes on the basal metabolic rate of rats. According to the Australian code of practice for care and use of animals for scientific purposes, eighth edition 2013, she must follow the principles of the 3Rs for the ethical and humane care of the animals. Which of the following is not one of the 3Rs?
Replacement – that wherever possible one should use alternative approaches that do not use animals.
Reduction – one should use the smallest number of animals possible to achieve the aims and statistical design requirements.
Refinement – one should modify methodology to minimise harm to the animals.
Repetition – one should repeat the investigative approach to ensure consistent results.
Reveal Answer
Replacement – that wherever possible one should use alternative approaches that do not use animals.
Replacement is one of the 3Rs of animal ethics, which advocates for using non-animal alternatives (like computer models or cell cultures) whenever possible.
Reduction – one should use the smallest number of animals possible to achieve the aims and statistical design requirements.
Reduction is one of the 3Rs, focusing on minimizing the number of animals used in research while still obtaining statistically valid results.
Refinement – one should modify methodology to minimise harm to the animals.
Refinement is one of the 3Rs, which involves modifying experimental procedures and animal care to minimize pain, suffering, and distress.
Repetition – one should repeat the investigative approach to ensure consistent results.
Repetition is not one of the 3Rs of animal ethics. The internationally accepted 3Rs for the ethical use of animals in research are Replacement, Reduction, and Refinement.
Most vinegar flies have wild type (reddish-brown) eyes. However, some mutants have white eyes and cannot see. Biologists conducted a laboratory experiment to compare the fitness of flies with wild type and white eyes.
The dependent variable in the experiment is the
laboratory conditions.
eye colour of the flies.
vision of the flies.
fitness of the flies.
Reveal Answer
laboratory conditions.
Laboratory conditions are typically controlled variables that are kept constant throughout the experiment to ensure a fair test, rather than the variable being measured.
eye colour of the flies.
Eye colour is likely the independent variable, which is the specific trait or condition being manipulated or categorized to observe its effects.
vision of the flies.
While vision might be related to eye colour, the dependent variable is the specific overall outcome being measured, which in this context is fitness.
fitness of the flies.
The dependent variable is the outcome that is measured or observed in an experiment. In this case, the fitness of the flies is the measured response to the independent variable.
Refer to the information below.
A study was undertaken by which a small sequence of DNA was inserted into a virus. The virus was injected into veins of rats with Type 1 diabetes. The inserted DNA created cells that produced insulin. The purpose of this study was to find a way for humans suffering from Type 1 diabetes to eliminate the need for daily insulin injections.
Ethical approval would be required for this trial to be undertaken in humans after analysis of the results in the rat study. Which of the following would be an important ethical consideration?
number of people available to take part in the trial
possible side effects of the therapy on humans
cost of the trials
approval by drug companies
Reveal Answer
number of people available to take part in the trial
While having a sufficient sample size is important for statistical validity, the number of available participants is a logistical and scientific factor rather than a primary ethical concern.
possible side effects of the therapy on humans
The fundamental ethical principle in human trials is non-maleficence (do no harm), making the assessment of potential side effects and participant safety the most critical consideration.
cost of the trials
The financial cost of conducting a trial is an economic and administrative factor, not an ethical consideration regarding the welfare of human subjects.
approval by drug companies
Ethical approval must be granted by an independent ethics committee or institutional review board, not drug companies, to avoid conflicts of interest and ensure patient protection.
The purpose of a 'control' in an experiment is to
determine the reliability of the experiment.
provide a comparison for the experimental treatment.
reduce the sample sizes needed for the experiment to be valid.
minimise the number of variables to be tested.
Reveal Answer
determine the reliability of the experiment.
Reliability is determined by repeating the experiment multiple times to check for consistent results, rather than by using a control group.
provide a comparison for the experimental treatment.
A control group provides a baseline where the independent variable is not applied, allowing researchers to see the actual effect of the experimental treatment by comparison.
reduce the sample sizes needed for the experiment to be valid.
Using a control group does not reduce the required sample size; in fact, larger sample sizes generally increase the statistical power and validity of an experiment.
minimise the number of variables to be tested.
While researchers keep certain variables constant to isolate the independent variable, the control group itself serves as a baseline for comparison, not a tool to reduce the number of variables.
One of the ethical considerations that must be adhered to during animal research relates to when and how animals can be used. Which of the following is not part of an ethical reason to test on animals?
The research has the potential to significantly benefit humans.
The financial cost of testing on animals is less than humans.
A minimum number of animals will be used during the study.
The use of animals is essential and cannot be substituted for.
Reveal Answer
The research has the potential to significantly benefit humans.
The potential for significant human benefit is a primary ethical justification for animal research, balancing the harm to animals against the good for humanity.
The financial cost of testing on animals is less than humans.
Financial cost is a practical or economic consideration, not an ethical justification for using animals in research.
A minimum number of animals will be used during the study.
Using the minimum number of animals necessary is a key ethical principle known as 'Reduction' in the 3Rs of animal research.
The use of animals is essential and cannot be substituted for.
Ensuring that animal use is essential and cannot be replaced by non-animal alternatives is an ethical principle known as 'Replacement' in the 3Rs.
Use the following information to answer the question.
Dengue is a disease primarily transported by mosquitoes. A group of students wish to investigate whether mosquitoes can be effectively controlled by spraying insecticide. The students will investigate the effect of spraying five different insecticides on mosquitoes.
Which one of the following techniques could the students use to generate quantitative primary data?
obtaining data from other students’ investigations
recording the smell of the five different insecticides
reading newspaper articles on the effect of insecticides on mosquitoes
measuring the mass of dead mosquitoes after spraying each insecticide
Reveal Answer
obtaining data from other students’ investigations
Obtaining data from other students' investigations is an example of collecting secondary data, not primary data.
recording the smell of the five different insecticides
Recording the smell of insecticides generates qualitative data (descriptive), not quantitative data (numerical).
reading newspaper articles on the effect of insecticides on mosquitoes
Reading newspaper articles is a method of gathering secondary data, as the information was collected and published by someone else.
measuring the mass of dead mosquitoes after spraying each insecticide
Measuring the mass of dead mosquitoes generates numerical (quantitative) data and is collected directly by the students conducting the experiment (primary data).
Use the following information to answer the question.
Populations of the koala (Phascolarctos cinereus) can be found along the eastern coast of Australia. In the late 1800s, habitat destruction and hunting reduced the number of koalas dramatically. In an effort to save the koala from extinction, a small number of individual koalas were introduced to French Island, Victoria. The number of koalas on the island quickly grew. Scientists measured the genetic diversity within the island population and found it to be low when compared to populations of koalas in New South Wales and Queensland.
When completing the research on the French Island koalas, the scientists would have needed to take into account bioethical issues. The scientists were aware that they would need to communicate all results, whether favourable or unfavourable.
Which one of the following principles of bioethics would the scientists be addressing?
non-maleficence
beneficence
integrity
respect
Reveal Answer
non-maleficence
Non-maleficence is the principle of avoiding harm or minimizing harm to subjects, which does not directly relate to the honest reporting of all research results.
beneficence
Beneficence focuses on maximizing benefits and minimizing risks for participants or society, rather than the ethical obligation to report all data honestly.
integrity
Integrity is the bioethical principle that requires the honest reporting of all sources of information and communication of results, regardless of whether they are favourable or unfavourable.
respect
Respect involves considering the intrinsic value of living things and their autonomy or welfare, which is not the principle governing the transparent communication of research findings.
Use the following information to answer the question.
Dengue is a disease primarily transported by mosquitoes. A group of students wish to investigate whether mosquitoes can be effectively controlled by spraying insecticide. The students will investigate the effect of spraying five different insecticides on mosquitoes.
The students want to check the reproducibility of their results.
To do this, they should ensure that the investigation
uses only recently calibrated equipment.
has both a positive and a negative control.
is conducted by only one student, in the same laboratory.
is conducted on different days by different students.
Reveal Answer
uses only recently calibrated equipment.
Using recently calibrated equipment improves the accuracy of the measurements, but it does not test whether the experimental results can be reproduced.
has both a positive and a negative control.
Controls are essential for the validity of an experiment to ensure the independent variable is causing the observed effect, but they do not check reproducibility.
is conducted by only one student, in the same laboratory.
Having the same student perform the experiment in the same lab tests repeatability (consistency under identical conditions), not reproducibility.
is conducted on different days by different students.
Reproducibility is the ability of an experiment to be duplicated by different researchers under different conditions (such as on different days) and still yield the same results.
A bacterial pathogen causes eye disease in finches. Biologists wanted to know whether the finches could evolve resistance to this pathogen. Finches from a population that had prior exposure to the pathogen, and from a population that had no prior exposure, were infected with the pathogen deliberately. After two weeks, the biologists determined the pathogen load in the two groups of finches. The independent variable in this experiment is the
deliberate infection of finches with the pathogen.
prior exposure of a population to the pathogen.
two-week duration of the experiment.
pathogen load in the two groups of finches.
Reveal Answer
deliberate infection of finches with the pathogen.
Deliberate infection is a procedure applied equally to all finches in the experiment, not a variable being manipulated or compared between groups.
prior exposure of a population to the pathogen.
The independent variable is the condition that differs between the groups being compared, which in this case is whether the finch population had prior exposure to the pathogen.
two-week duration of the experiment.
The two-week duration is a controlled variable kept constant for all finches, not the independent variable being tested.
pathogen load in the two groups of finches.
The pathogen load is the dependent variable, as it is the outcome being measured to see the effect of the independent variable.
Use the following information to answer the question.
A Year 12 student conducts an investigation into the effects of different amounts of water on the growth of lettuce plants. The following table outlines some aspects of the investigation.
| Lettuce plant | Amount of water (mL/day) | Temperature (°C) | Light wavelength (nm) | Percentage increase in mass of lettuce (%) |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | 150 | 10 | 660 | 5 |
| 2 | 200 | 15 | 660 | 10 |
| 3 | 250 | 20 | 660 | 15 |
| 4 | 300 | 25 | 660 | 13 |
The investigation is not considered valid because
it contains more than one dependent variable.
only lettuce is used in the investigation.
the light wavelength is set at 660 nm.
the temperature is different for each plant.
Reveal Answer
it contains more than one dependent variable.
The investigation only has one dependent variable, which is the percentage increase in mass of the lettuce.
only lettuce is used in the investigation.
Using only one type of plant is necessary to control variables and ensure a fair test, so this does not invalidate the experiment.
the light wavelength is set at 660 nm.
Keeping the light wavelength constant at 660 nm is a controlled variable, which actually supports the validity of the experiment rather than undermining it.
the temperature is different for each plant.
For an experiment to be valid, only the independent variable (amount of water) should change. Because the temperature also changes, it acts as a confounding variable, making it impossible to know whether the water or the temperature caused the difference in growth.
A study assessed the effectiveness and safety of a drug called doxycycline. One hundred and fifty adults hospitalised with malaria were involved. These adults were randomly placed into two groups of equal size. One group received doxycycline in addition to standard care. The other group received standard care only.
The group receiving standard care only was the
control group.
variable group.
unsupported group.
experimental group.
Reveal Answer
control group.
The control group serves as a baseline for comparison by receiving the standard treatment without the new experimental drug.
variable group.
'Variable group' is not a standard scientific term; while variables are tested in an experiment, the groups are typically designated as control or experimental.
unsupported group.
'Unsupported group' is not a scientific term, and this group is still receiving standard medical care for their condition.
experimental group.
The experimental group is the one receiving the new intervention being tested, which in this study is the group receiving doxycycline.
In an experiment investigating the effect of different temperatures on DNA structure, which one of the following is the independent variable?
rate of DNA denaturation
mass of DNA in the sample
number of nucleotide bases in the DNA sequence
temperatures at which the experiment is conducted
Reveal Answer
rate of DNA denaturation
Incorrect. The rate of DNA denaturation is what is being measured as the outcome, making it the dependent variable rather than the independent variable.
mass of DNA in the sample
Incorrect. The mass of DNA is a factor that should be kept constant across all trials to ensure a fair test, making it a controlled variable.
number of nucleotide bases in the DNA sequence
Incorrect. The length and sequence of the DNA should remain constant throughout the experiment, so this represents a controlled variable.
temperatures at which the experiment is conducted
Correct. The independent variable is the factor intentionally manipulated by the experimenter, which in this case is the different temperatures being tested.
Students used quadrats to investigate biodiversity in a grassland community with scattered distribution of plant species. The students agreed on a counting criteria for each quadrat to
reduce the time taken to count the different species.
minimise statistical uncertainty.
ensure all strata were sampled.
minimise bias.
Reveal Answer
reduce the time taken to count the different species.
While clear rules might speed up the process by reducing debate, the primary scientific purpose of counting criteria is to ensure data reliability, not to improve efficiency.
minimise statistical uncertainty.
Statistical uncertainty is primarily reduced by increasing the sample size (the number of quadrats sampled), rather than by defining counting rules.
ensure all strata were sampled.
Ensuring all strata (zones) are sampled is a matter of experimental design and quadrat placement (stratified sampling), not the specific rules used to count organisms within a quadrat.
minimise bias.
Agreed counting criteria (such as rules for plants touching the edge of the quadrat) ensure consistency between students and prevent subjective decision-making, thereby minimizing observer bias.
A student designed and conducted a practical investigation to test for the presence of microbes in water and food samples.
Justify a safety precaution required to prevent infection when conducting the investigation.
Reveal Answer
The wearing of gloves to prevent contact with skin and the subsequent entry of pathogens into skin/mouth
| Descriptor | Marks |
|---|---|
Justifies a safety precaution used to prevent infection | 2 |
Provides some relevant information | 1 |
None of the above | 0 |
Explain how the student could ensure the reliability of the investigation.
Reveal Answer
The student could repeat the experiment by using five plates to culture the same sample of food or water. This would mean the student could check that the results are similar in each test.
| Descriptor | Marks |
|---|---|
Explains how to ensure the investigation is reliable | 2 |
Provides some relevant information | 1 |
None of the above | 0 |
An ecologist investigated the species composition of mangrove trees in a natural mangrove forest and an adjacent 30-year-old planted mangrove forest.
Three 10 m-wide belt transects were sampled from inland to the sea for each of the forests, each covering 100 m on average and placed to cover various strata.
The species diversity of Forest A was determined using the Simpson’s Diversity Index (SDI):
| Population count | ||
|---|---|---|
| Species | Forest A (natural) | Forest B (planted) |
| Grey mangrove | 91 | 77 |
| Red mangrove | 23 | 14 |
| River mangrove | 11 | 8 |
| Orange mangrove | 3 | 0 |
| Diversity | 0.46 | ? |
Use the SDI formula to calculate the diversity index for Forest B. Round your answer to two decimal places.
Reveal Answer
SDI
| Descriptor | Marks |
|---|---|
Demonstrates correct substitution | 1 |
States SDI = 0.37 | 1 |
Identify three reasons why the ecologist used a belt transect rather than line transects or randomly placed quadrats for collecting data to compare these two forests.
Reveal Answer
Belt transects are used for abundance and distribution of species. Random quadrats can be used for abundance, not distribution, and line transects can be used for distribution, not abundance.
Random sampling doesn’t take into account strata (different areas) and may not cover all areas of habitat equally, giving inaccurate measures of diversity and abundance.
| Descriptor | Marks |
|---|---|
States 3 reasons | 3 |
States 2 reasons | 2 |
States a reason | 1 |
Does not satisfy any of the descriptors above | 0 |
Identify one way in which the ecologist minimised bias in the sampling.
Reveal Answer
The locations of belt transects were chosen to take strata into account.
| Descriptor | Marks |
|---|---|
States a way to minimise bias | 1 |